18 ms·
Note that they're carefully dancing around the elephant in the room: As far as I know, no one has ever demonstrated that Lyme spirochetes survive a course of st
by PragmaticPulp 7y ago
Note that they're carefully dancing around the elephant in the room: As far as I know, no one has ever demonstrated that Lyme spirochetes survive a course of standard antibiotics (Emphasis mine):
> Standard treatment of Lyme disease is oral antibiotics, typically doxycycline, in the early stages of the disease; but for reasons that are unclear, the antibiotics don't work for up to 20% of people with the tick-borne illness. One possibility is that drug-tolerant bacteria cause the lingering symptoms.
Many people experience lingering symptoms after contracting Lyme disease. Officially, this is known as "Post-Treatment Lyme Disease Syndrome". The CDC page for the PTLDS has more information: https://www.cdc.gov/lyme/postlds/index.html https://www.cdc.gov/lyme/postlds/index.html
These PTLDS symptoms are definitely real, but the idea that persistent lyme infection is the cause of the lingering problems is more of a hypothesis at this point.
It will be interesting to see if this new antibiotic produces different outcomes in PTLDS patients, but it's misleading to claim that this is the only antibiotic known to act on the Lyme disease spirochetes. The original study specifically explored the action of Azlocillin on Doxycycline-resistant spirochetes. From the study:
> Our results also demonstrate that azlocillin and cefotaxime can effectively kill in vitro doxycycline-tolerant B. burgdorferi.
The authors point to indirect evidence suggesting that spirochetes might still be present in PTLDS patients, but acknowledge that no one has yet been able to culture a viable spirochete from PTLDS patients:
> A recent study in humans demonstrated that B. burgdorferi DNA was identified in PTDLS patient by xenodiagnosis but unable to culture viable spirochete17. In about 85% of Lyme arthritis patients, B. burgdorferi DNA was detected in synovial fluid by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) testing
It would be great if this antibiotic could produce positive outcomes for PTLDS patients, but I wouldn't get too excited until we see some human studies. PTLDS (aka "chronic lyme") has a long history of promising treatments failing to produce results in patients.
- tempestn 7y agoI don't have any knowledge beyond what's in this article, but it appears that there is some evidence of Lyme bacteria surviving antibiotics, and the reason why this can occur: "According to the recent study, azlocillin shows promise because it appears to be able to kill the two morphological forms of the Lyme bacteria -- the actively replicating spiral forms and the semi-dormant round-body forms. Azlocillin also appears to kill drug-tolerant persisters very effectively. These protective persisters form when the bacteria are threatened with defensive immune system biochemicals or antibiotics. After the threat has passed, the bacteria can reemerge to cause active disease. Many researchers believe that doxycyline's inability to clear the persisters may account for the ongoing symptoms of some Lyme sufferers."
- PragmaticPulp 7y agoYes, but note that they also admit that we only have some indirect suggestions that persistent infection is the cause of PTLDS symptoms: > Many researchers believe that doxycyline's inability to clear the persisters may account for the ongoing symptoms of some Lyme sufferers "Many researchers believe" is not the language you use when you have concrete evidence supporting the claim. To date, no one has been able to culture these supposedly persistent bacteria from a PTLSD patient. Researchers are relying on indirect evidence, with no explanation for why the spirochetes can't be found in PTLSD patients.
- smallnamespace 7y agoYour evidence bar may be unrealistically high here—Lyme has never been successfully cultured in any context (unless you count xenodiagnosis as a form of culturing).
- PragmaticPulp 7y ago> Lyme has never been successfully cultured in any context Not true. Not sure where you are reading that. Lyme is difficult to culture, but it can be cultured: Scroll down to the "Culture" section: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4441761/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4441761/ Regardless, my bar for evidence would be human trials in PTLDS patients with Azlocillin. Given that Azlocillin is already FDA approved and the researchers initially started studying it in 2016, I'm surprised no one has tried it yet.
- oblib 7y agoWell, all he's really doing here is pointing out it's not time to pop the cork on the bottle yet. That's not the same as saying this work won't help lead to that. We can all hope it does while waiting to know for sure. I appreciate the additional info and context provided.
- mrfusion 7y agoDo PTLDS patients actually show active antibodies against lyme? That would be a good indication what’s going on.
- megous 7y ago"Antibodies normally persist in the blood for months or even years after the infection is gone; therefore, the test cannot be used to determine cure." https://www.cdc.gov/lyme/diagnosistesting/index.html https://www.cdc.gov/lyme/diagnosistesting/index.html
- mrfusion 7y agoSorry I meant IgM not IgG.
- megous 7y agoThe page says that: "Positive IgM results should be disregarded if the patient has been ill for more than 30 days." The reason may be this: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1198743X14608120 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1198743X1...
- mrfusion 7y agoThanks for responding. But that study says they assumed the results were false positives. Maybe for the purpose of that paper that’s fine. But I’m not sure if it supports your statement.
- megous 7y agoThey also list a few reasons for the assumption. Anyway, the study itself is not the reason for the quoted statement on the CDC page. I was just trying to find some relevant basis for the statement, and this study has some reasons listed in the dicussion/conclusion.
- 7y ago
- James_Henry 7y ago>> A recent study in humans demonstrated that B. burgdorferi DNA was identified in PTDLS patient by xenodiagnosis but unable to culture viable spirochete17. In about 85% of Lyme arthritis patients, B. burgdorferi DNA was detected in synovial fluid by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) testing The previous sentence is also important: >Many research studies has [sic] shown that B. burgdorferi establishes persistent infections after antibiotic treatment in various animal models.
- PragmaticPulp 7y agoI'll review the citations in this study once again, but the evidence for lingering spirochetes in humans is always thin. Much of it relies on indirect testing that is difficult to replicate or prone to laboratory errors. I'd love to be completely wrong and for this to be a game-changing solution, but after years of following this research I'm suspicious of the idea that persistent yet mysteriously undetectable (in humans) spirochetes are responsible for PTLSD symptoms.
- wolco 7y agoThe idea of lingering unwanted resistant bacteria not being killed by antibiotics have been shown true with other spore type bacteria. I don't have the background in this specific bacteria, why do you believe it would be so different?
- loeg 7y agoIt seems like their opinion is informed on the basis of the existing scientific evidence, which is eminently reasonable, IMO.
- power 7y agoI'm interested in your opinion of the citations too. They purport to show persistence beyond standard treatment in mice, dogs, macaques and humans, the latter via xenodiagnosis and PCR. PCR is pretty direct.
- Alex3917 7y ago> no one has ever demonstrated that Lyme spirochetes survive a course of standard antibiotics This is true, but what I think most people don't realize is that the evidence that antibiotics kill the bacteria in the first place is also extremely dubious. If you read the main paper, it literally boils down to "people who take antibiotics are less likely to get a rash."[1] [1] https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/nejm200107123450201 https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/nejm200107123450201
- PragmaticPulp 7y agoYou linked to a study of single-dose Doxycycline as potential prophylaxis. That's not how Lyme disease is treated. Lyme disease treatment protocols are shown here: https://www.cdc.gov/lyme/treatment/index.html https://www.cdc.gov/lyme/treatment/index.html Doxycycline is generally used for 14-21 days, twice daily, not a one-time dose as used in your linked study. Even the linked study shows that Doxycycline acts on B. burgdorferi, even in the difficult stationary phase. Scroll down to Figure 6: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-020-59600-4 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-020-59600-4 . Obviously Azlocillin is superior in this in vitro study, hence the news. But it still shows that Doxycycline is active against the bacteria. It's too bad that the authors didn't continue the test long enough to see Doxycycline either reach zero (presumably) or level off. Seems like a crucial piece of data that they strangely neglected to measure.
- Alex3917 7y agohttps://www.cdc.gov/ticks/tickbornediseases/tick-bite-prophylaxis.html https://www.cdc.gov/ticks/tickbornediseases/tick-bite-prophy...
- PragmaticPulp 7y ago> https://www.cdc.gov/ticks/tickbornediseases/tick-bite-prophylaxis.html https://www.cdc.gov/ticks/tickbornediseases/tick-bite-prophy... Please read the study and the CDC web page you're linking to. They don't support your point. From the CDC link you provided: > Doxycycline (100 mg orally BID X 14 days) is generally recommended for prophylaxis in adults. From the study you linked to above: > A single 200-mg dose of doxycycline given within 72 hours The CDC recommends a 14-day course of twice-daily dosing (BID = twice daily). It has no relationship to the single-dose NJEM study you linked to above.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- foobarian 7y agoOut of curiosity how come you have such detailed familiarity with the topic? Sorry if may be a sensitive question but it seems a relatively obscure thing to randomly get into. And to be sure I really appreciate your posts.
- shmageggy 7y agoHundreds of thousands of people have been diagnosed with Lyme, so probably millions know someone who has. There are posters about ticks at nearly every trailhead I've visited in the northeast US in the past five years. It's not obscure.
- PragmaticPulp 7y ago> Out of curiosity how come you have such detailed familiarity with the topic? I developed the typical Lyme symptoms after spending a lot of time outdoors in a Lyme area and removing ticks from myself several different times. I tested positive for Lyme under the relatively strict CDC criteria from a trusted laboratory. A 28-day course of Doxycycline changed something, but the fatigue and general malaise stuck around. I've spent the next decade consuming every bit of research I could find on the topic. I'd love as much as anyone for this already FDA-approved antibiotic like Azlocillin to be a miracle cure for my problems. I would gladly welcome properly structured RCTs. However, I've learned to be extremely skeptical of antibiotic therapies for Lyme. Patients who self identify as having "chronic Lyme" are notorious for holding strong beliefs that antibiotics improve their condition after reading about hidden spirochetes and undetectable infection theories for years, but double-blind studies show no benefit. I think the much more likely explanation is that Lyme can trigger long-lasting alterations in the body somewhere, even after the infection is eliminated. Sadly, the topic has become so political that mainstream researchers won't touch it. Now that "chronic Lyme" is so closely intertwined with the alternative medicine community, anyone who denies the persistent infection theory is treated as if they are denying the persistent symptoms of sufferers. That couldn't be farther from the truth for me, as I suffer the symptoms myself. The topic is so politically charged that I only use my pseudonymous alternate account for discussing it online. I've had chronic Lyme sufferers dox me and send vaguely threatening messages in the past, just for discussing the research online. It's no wonder that more researchers don't want to investigate Lyme disease.
- vimy 7y agoPersistent Borrelia Infection in Patients with Ongoing Symptoms of Lyme Disease. >RESULTS: Motile spirochetes identified histopathologically as Borrelia were detected in culture specimens, and these spirochetes were genetically identified as Borreliaburgdorferi by three distinct polymerase chain reaction (PCR)-based approaches. Spirochetes identified as Borrelia burgdorferi were cultured from the blood of seven subjects, from the genital secretions of ten subjects, and from a skin lesion of one subject. Cultures from control subjects without Lyme disease were negative for Borrelia using these methods https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/29662016 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/29662016 The CDC is wrong and negligent about persistent Lyme. Just like they are about the masks for covid-19. This is just one study demonstrating spirochetes surviving. I'm not gonna bother digging up the others, honestly not worth my time to try and convince one random person. Look up disulfiram and it's effects on Lyme patients. It's another drug discovered in the same way as this one. Miraculous.
- torgoguys 7y agoThe linked study's lead author is Middelveen. Isn't she the one who tried to say Lyme is an STD a few years back? I know nothing about the linked study, haven't read it, but her sloppiness with scientific rigor makes me nervous about taking the abstract at face value...
- djsumdog 7y ago> Just like they are about the masks for covid-19 What is the CDC saying about masks for covid-19? Are you saying they're not effective or the CDC is downplaying their effectiveness?
- voldacar 7y agoWeeks ago the CDC lied, saying that masks aren't effective and that the general public shouldn't wear them. They did this ostensibly to keep the existing mask supply available only to medical workers. Needless to say, if they're ineffective for the general public, they're ineffective for doctors and nurses. And so people saw through the bullshit
- hinkley 7y agoLyme disease talk just makes me think of Nicholas Zakas and then I get bummed out. I know there's a guy, or maybe he represents a group of researchers, who thinks that Chronic Fatigue Syndrome is caused by inflammation in the brain, either due to some undetectable infection, or just a misfiring that is a lingering effect of some other insult (sounds to me like a histamine response aka allergy). If your body thought you had the flu but you didn't, you'd be knocked on your ass not unlike many people with CFS or Lyme. And if it never stopped you'd be in pretty bad shape a year in. So. Are we treating microbes that don't culture in a petri dish, or are we solving an autoimmune response gone whacky? You could really ask the same question about Crohn's or IBS. I recall years ago reading a long story about a consultant who was called in to figure out why this black soot was all over a neighborhood around a brewery. The brewery said it was diesel exhaust. But why only this neighborhood? He heard of a similar problem is some town in the UK. But Petri dish after Petri dish cultured nothing that could explain the black soot. Ergo, it's not microbial. Our intrepid consultant pours a small amount of distilled spirits onto a sample dish, and gets a bunch of black shit. The 'soot' was feeding off the Angel's Share (evaporative losses from the brewery), and would barely grow without it. Vigorous growth in vivo, negligible growth in vitro. We've come up with a cure or treatment for so many microbes that we can detect, but how do we know we're detecting them all? People die of cancer not because cancer is getting worse (well, pollution notwithstanding) but because Cancer is patient. There's a lot of space in the middle for new vectors to slip in.
- kortex 7y agoI really enjoy your writing style. Flows extremely well.
- jamisteven 7y agoGreat writing.
- hinkley 7y agoThanks. I can be hit or miss. Maybe I need an editor :) Sometimes I read old stuff and think, "wow, I said that?" other times, "I have no idea what point I was trying to make."
- Ericson2314 7y agoNot to get in this heavily politicized fray, but PTDLS sure sounds easiest to explain as permanent damage after the disease. I mean, we already know nerves heal poorly. Why don't I hear more about this hypothesis?
- caycep 7y agoIn my (brief) experience with PTLDS sufferers, there have been a couple of disturbing realizations/experiences: 1) it seems that "chronic lyme specialists" are physicians who realized that each patient they diagnose with "chronic lyme" is potentially a cash cow. In that they can be persuaded to pay out of pocket for regimens of IV infusions of antibiotics costing up to tens of thousands of dollars (and which make no antimicrobial sense). For years, because the "spirochete is hiding, round bodies, etc etc". The agents used also make no antimicrobial sense - when we show the med history to ID specialists and PharmD's, they just roll their eyes... 2) As a resident, we had a couple of cases roll through the door of a) temporal lobe epilepsy with mesial temporal sclerosis, b) Parkinson's disease, both pretty clear diagnoses, told by various "chronic lyme specialists" that their symptoms were due to Lyme,taken off their meds and put on strange regimens of IV ceftriaxone (at out of pocket expense) and ending up hospitalized as a result. With such severity that efforts were made to have the state board revoke the medical licenses of these practitioners.
- matthewdgreen 7y agoI don’t doubt everything you’re saying, and that unscrupulous physicians are genuinely taking advantage of their patients. However, as someone with a family member who was recently diagnosed with a (largely untreatable) autoimmune disease, I want to explain why patients become so desperate that they’re willing to try anything. The basic problem here is that anyone who goes online and reads about their condition (eg PTLDS) will find ample scientific evidence that there’s a real condition there — however, a huge majority of medical practitioners aren’t as caught up on the research as their desperate patients, and will often express skepticism that the condition even exists. (Note that this is different from acknowledging the condition is real and being unable to offer a treatment.) This destroys credibility in the conservative medical establishment, and makes it much easier for charlatans to make inroads, simply by acting like they believe the patient. My point here is that a little empathy can go a long way to protecting patients from this outcome.
- stainforth 7y agoDoctors are being empathetic when they restrain from pushing the nonsense quacks do, just to satisfy a patient's anxiety, no?
- hhas01 7y ago“As far as I know, no one has ever demonstrated that Lyme spirochetes survive a course of standard antibiotics” QFT. While PTLDS is a real thing (being long-term sequelae to the original Lyme infection), be very wary of anything labeled “chronic lyme”, which is a common code-word concoction of “Lyme-literate” MDs/DOs, naturopaths, and other quacks for peddling their nostrums (including permanent courses of antibiotics; a great way to make anyone sick as a dog). https://sciencebasedmedicine.org/?s=lyme https://sciencebasedmedicine.org/?s=lyme -- Bonus irony: GSK actually created a successful vaccine against Lyme 30 years ago: https://www.vox.com/science-and-health/2018/5/7/17314716/lyme-disease-vaccine-history-effectiveness https://www.vox.com/science-and-health/2018/5/7/17314716/lym... No prizes for guessing who destroyed that.
- ejstronge 7y agoThis is amazing - thanks so much for the LYMERix link. I'm nearly done with medical school and somehow never heard this story!
- krisn 7y agoI wrote up the blog for this study, and I agree it was poorly written and an incremental finding at best. To me, the most important point is that the IDSA/CDC has been recommending doxy for decades knowing that other drugs are more effective. To PragmaticPup: There is, however, lots of evidence supporting the point that Lyme spirochetes easily survive 2 to 4 weeks of doxy through the formation of blebs. Look up the primate studies by Monica Embers @Tulane and the mice studies by Barthold @UCDavis. Borrelia, like Syphilis, is notoriously hard to culture, and Barthold says that persistence is the "rule rather that the exception." I think there have only been 7 randomized double blind clinical treatment trials on humans since the 1981 discovery, and they all tested single drugs, rather than the drug cocktails, which might address both the spirochete and bleb forms of the bacteria. Michal Tal at Stanford is doing groundbreaking work on ways the Lyme bacteria evades the human immune system. I don't want to steal her thunder, but we definitely need new approaches to treating this formidable disease.