10 ms·
Leaked Amazon memo details plan to smear fired warehouse organizer
- barryrandall 7y agoThis Vice story is just part of the smear campaign. Strategy: “We should spend the first part of our response strongly laying out the case for why the organizer’s conduct was immoral, unacceptable, and arguably illegal, in detail, and only then follow with our usual talking points about worker safety,” Zapolsky wrote. “Make him the most interesting part of the story, and if possible make him the face of the entire union/organizing movement.” As applied: “I was frustrated and upset that an Amazon employee would endanger the health and safety of other Amazonians by repeatedly returning to the premises after having been warned to quarantine himself after exposure to virus Covid-19,” he said. “I let my emotions draft my words and get the better of me.”
- claudeganon 7y agoI don’t think this tracks. If anything, it exposed that all of Amazon’s statements around this are not in anyway to be trusted.
- wmeredith 7y agoAgreed. They are totally exposed as arguing in bad faith. All of their statements on this will be tainted.
- notJim 7y agoThey call this message discipline. When the press asks you about something, always bring it back to your talking points.
- lozenge 7y agoYep, literally applying the strategy Vice exposed, in the article exposing it.
- anigbrowl 7y ago“I let my emotions draft my words and get the better of me.” What a pathetic excuse from the General Counsel of one of the world's most powerful firms when caught engaging in employee retaliation. This isn't acceptable from any lawyer.
- guitarbill 7y agoif you were cynical, you might say this is just yet another attempt at spin; to present himself as a relatable human (like "we all get angry, we all make mistakes", although note he didn't use e.g. angry, but "frustrated", "upset", and "emotions", vaguer and more passive options). this could work, too, as long as you forget that drafting words seems to literally be his job (for which i'm sure he's handsomely rewarded).
- throwanem 7y agoLifting it from one of my comments downthread: Better to make the world's worst excuse than lie in a way that'll instantly be revealed in discovery for any case that comes of this. The surprise is that he let himself be reached for comment at all. Between that and the "yeah, I sure goofed it, huh?" style of what he said when he was, I wouldn't be too astonished to see a golden handshake eventuate in the fullness of time.
- ape4 7y agoNot smart or articulate.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 7y agoOddly, it reminds me of the way big banks handled Occupy movement. That was the first time I saw memes used as a carrier for straight propaganda. It was a sad moment for me. Mostly because having seen one of those memes, I immediately understood how terrifyingly effective they can be. Amazon has clearly learned a lot over the past few decades. odd edit: Just in case. I was kinda doing a fair amount of shorts on Amazon lately, so my opinion is not unbiased.
- pas 7y agoCould you show a few of those memes from back then?
- jshevek 7y agoI'm also interested. I was paying attention to memes during that period and don't remember any which fit.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 7y agoI dug through my hdd and for the life of my I could not find the ones I was thinking of ( maybe it is time to finally tag my stuff properly ). I looked online and I was only able to find one example of what I was thinking of ( https://awwmemes.com/i/spreads-message-of-anti-capitalism-from-his-apple-computer-2nerd-com-get-dc335a50639b4fbb9ee3193163f244bb https://awwmemes.com/i/spreads-message-of-anti-capitalism-fr... ). The one I remember was equally silly along the lines of "hates banks, uses money = hypocrite". I will keep digging, because I know what I am looking for and it is not ancient history. I should have it somewhere.
- ric2b 7y agoThose are extremely lazy and I don't understand how someone takes them seriously. It's like saying: "Kidnapped victim runs away by shooting the captor's knee... with the captor's gun, hypocrite much?!"
- A4ET8a8uTh0 7y ago
- j4nt4b 7y agoWhat are the legal implications for Amazon from these revelations? I already know it's illegal to discourage union activity, but I'm curious about how this evidence affects the situation.
- vkou 7y agoA civil suit from Smalls, maybe. All of this evidence would have been found as part of discovery if there would have been real litigation, anyway, so I doubt it's going to be particularly painful for Amazon.
- binarymax 7y agoIf admissible, this may be evidence in a wider case for a labor law violation. The NY Atty General was notably unhappy about what had transpired: https://www.npr.org/2020/03/31/824423595/new-york-attorney-general-seeks-investigation-over-fired-amazon-warehouse-worker https://www.npr.org/2020/03/31/824423595/new-york-attorney-g... ...Until events unfold more, we cannot speculate as to the charges (if any) will be brought against Amazon.
- imglorp 7y agoNYAG also called for NLRB to weigh in, which isn't going to happen. They've been offlined at the worst time. https://www.rawstory.com/2020/04/nlrb-suspends-unionizing-amid-covid-19-crisis/ https://www.rawstory.com/2020/04/nlrb-suspends-unionizing-am...
- Mizza 7y agoA really disgusting but predictable thing to fall out of this whole fiasco is to watch Obama-era staffers aggressively side with management against labour: https://twitter.com/JayCarney/status/1245474780746330119 https://twitter.com/JayCarney/status/1245474780746330119
- TechBro8615 7y agoAt the risk of making a generalization, it's interesting that political PR firms and/or workers from them tend to get companies in trouble. Recall that Facebook retained a republican PR firm that pushed anti-Soros conspiracies, for example. Maybe the lesson here is that people who worked in politics/lobbying are not trustworthy and can be a liability to the integrity of your company if you hire them.
- luckylion 7y ago> Maybe the lesson here is that people who worked in politics/lobbying are not trustworthy and can be a liability to the integrity of your company if you hire them. Well, if you give them very high paying jobs at weird companies you control through a few layers of obfuscation, it will look even more like you're paying them for services rendered.
- thawaway1837 7y agoYou mean a current SVP at Amazon? Is it possible that his current role is defining his response more than one he held at least 3 years ago?
- tw04 7y agoHe's an SVP at Amazon... what does being an "Obama-era staffer" have to do with him supporting the company currently paying his paycheck? Not to mention he was Press Secretary for Obama, played literally no role in policy.
- creddit 7y agoIt's part of the strategy of the far left to help push the Democratic Party further left by vilifying anything and everything associated with its party's center. EDIT: Adding that I really can't see, otherwise, how it's relevant.
- creddit 7y agoI know that that's the title of the article but I read the article and came away mostly thinking nothing was all that bad. Is it because the notes said the organizer isn't eloquent or smart that there is reason to be upset?
- dougmany 7y agoI took away that they picked an in-eloquent person to poster up as the leader and that the push to unionize has a broader base.
- inerte 7y agoNot because they said the organizer isn't eloquent or smart, but because Amazon wants to make this person the face of the movement. They're trying to make the whole movement look dumb by proxy, or that anyone who joined the movement is dumb because they're following a dumb guy. The public PR angle is that only a dumb stupid babbling person would deny the goodness that Amazon does for its employees and try to organize a walkout. I think it's interesting the contrast with the SVP who said he let his emotions got the better of him. If the union guy says something not-smart, he's dumb and the whole movement is dumb. If the SVP says something not-smart, he was just trying to protect the workers.
- malandrew 7y agoHow is this any different than the liberal media making Trump the voice of conservatives in the 2016? (which backfired spectacularly and led to his rise and eventual win in the election). Before liberals downvote me. Conservative media does this too. In fact, journalism these days regardless of political views is riddled with making someone look bad to score cheap points. One of the most toxic more recent developments is taking particularly unflattering still images from high definition video to present someone as dumb, stupid, angry or any of the myriad emotions one might present in the course of existing while filmed. Making your opponent look bad is sadly par for the course pretty much everywhere these days from politics to corporate PR to social media debates on facebook and twitter. Heck, you see it here on HN too these days. Certainly far more than in the past.
- claudeganon 7y agoI know many good people work on tech at Amazon and that treating low-wage workers, organizing to defend their health and safety this way, is not something you all would embrace. Now is your chance to organize and prove this is true. Google employees did it and so can you.
- ahelwer 7y agoThe quote from Zapolsky is especially funny, because it exactly follows the PR strategy outlined in the leak notes the paragraph prior. What an incredibly fake, dishonest person. Not really the best candidate to be calling a union organizer "not smart, not articulate".
- wmeredith 7y agoI also think it's deliciously ironic that his description of someone as "not smart, not articulate" is in and of itself the way a dumb or inarticulate person would speak :D
- emmelaich 7y agoFunny thing, people using the word "articulate" are generally misusing it! They mean eloquent, not "articulate".
- thu2111 7y agoarticulate: "Expressing oneself easily in clear and effective language" That meaning is fine. What makes you think Zapolsky is wrong? As far as I can tell this guy is a freaking PR genius. He managed to turn a leak into another chance to ram home his message. The entire Vice article is ridiculous. People trying to organise a union smear their employers all the time, it's rather inherent in the task. Employers smearing back is now shocking behaviour? Double standards are rife.
- jseip 7y agoThe definition of smear: "to damage the reputation of (someone) by false accusations; slander." Where is the 'smear ' here? Amazon has not made, or planned to make, false accusations against this worker.
- claudeganon 7y agoI listened to an interview with Smalls. He seemed perfectly intelligent and articulate to me. Demonstrably more than these people or his bosses, who put his coworkers in danger, while he’s trying to protect them. It’s thus hard not to see attempts to frame him as “not smart” or “ not articulate” as classist and racist dog whistles intended to discredit a courageous man.
- rijoja 7y agoRacist dog whistle give me a break. All of this paranoia about hidden racists is just mind blowing. To me it seems as you have a problem with other "races", if you hear "not smart" or "not articulate" and immediately starts thinking of the color of someones skin. not a term that is scientifically accepted when discussing humans
- claudeganon 7y agoReferring to the way working class people talk (and especially working class black people) in this way is something the rich and powerful have always done to discredit them. Go read all the blood spilt by right-wing hacks about the “legitimacy” of AAVE, for example. If you want to be a credulous dupe and think that the richest man in the world and his highly-paid PR team don’t understand this history and context, be my guest.
- kevingadd 7y agoThe claim that he exposed employees to COVID is a transparently false accusation. His last time of exposure was well outside of the danger zone and Amazon waited until the last possible moment to quarantine him (and only him)
- voz_ 7y agoBezos and Amazon are examples of the worst parts of our modern take on capitalism. Shame on them.
- Smoosh 7y agoYou might like to read this opinion article: https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2020/apr/01/amazon-coronavirus-new-york-chris-smalls-dismissed https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2020/apr/01/amazon...
- tehjoker 7y agoAlso this opinion piece criticizing the economic incentives that create monstrosities like Amazon: https://msuweb.montclair.edu/~lebelp/MarxEngelsTheCommunistManifesto1848.pdf https://msuweb.montclair.edu/~lebelp/MarxEngelsTheCommunistM...
- throwawaysea 7y agoThis article's title is sensationalist. Based on the article's content itself, there doesn't seem to be anything in here about "smearing" at all. Definition from https://dictionary.cambridge.org/us/dictionary/english/smearing https://dictionary.cambridge.org/us/dictionary/english/smear...: "to publicly accuse someone of something unpleasant, unreasonable, or unlikely to be true in order to harm their reputation" Second definition from https://www.merriam-webster.com/thesaurus/smearing https://www.merriam-webster.com/thesaurus/smearing: "the making of false statements that damage another's reputation " From the article itself, which quotes meeting notes written ostensibly by "Amazon General Counsel David Zapolsky": > “He’s not smart, or articulate, and to the extent the press wants to focus on us versus him, we will be in a much stronger PR position than simply explaining for the umpteenth time how we’re trying to protect workers,” This statement from the notes is not accusing the former employee in question of anything, and it is not making false statements about him either. It is expressing an opinion. There is absolutely nothing wrong with that. Furthermore, this article and others from Vice, Vox, Huffington Post, and others are proving why Amazon does not want to explain for the "umpteenth time" what they are doing in response to the virus. There is only so much that can be done within the confines of a physical operation like an Amazon warehouse, and it is crucial that online stores keep operating at this time, so that shoppers stay home. And yet, all these articles make it seem like Amazon has done nothing. In actuality, apart from providing industry leading wages for warehouse workers, Amazon has increased baseline pay, overtime pay, and enacted numerous reasonable changes to alter the operations of their warehouse. Vice buries one of the most interesting bits, which is how Amazon has been trying to get PPE but has had difficulties: > Zapolsky’s notes imply the company’s attempts to purchase N95 masks from China fell through. “China has deemed N95 masks as ‘strategic,’” Zapolsky wrote. “They’re keeping them for optionality. They also want to use them for ‘diplomacy.’ The masks in China that we thought we had probably got redirected by profiteers.” Even the "protests" outside Amazon's warehouses in response to this news story are overblown. For instance https://www.cbsnews.com/news/amazon-fires-chris-smalls-walkout-staten-island-new-york-warehouse/ https://www.cbsnews.com/news/amazon-fires-chris-smalls-walko... notes that although activists claimed there were 50 employees protesting, the actual count was 15, and only 9 of those were Amazon employees. Yet mainstream left-leaning media keeps amplifying this story. In actuality, it appears Amazon has been continuously attempting to improve working conditions, and were finally able to get masks based on orders they placed weeks ago - well before the recent social media / left-leaning journalists' attacks on Amazon began. See https://techcrunch.com/2020/04/02/amazon-begins-running-temperature-checks-and-will-provide-surgical-masks-at-warehouses/ https://techcrunch.com/2020/04/02/amazon-begins-running-temp... for more on that: > Amazon has already described some precautions it’s been taking, including mandatory paid 14-day quarantines for employees who test positive, as well as increased cleaning and sanitation efforts of facilities and infrastructure. The new measures to be introduced next week include taking temperatures of employees at the entrances to warehouses, with any individuals with a fever of more than 100.4 degrees Fahrenheit to be sent home, where they’ll have to have three consecutive days without fever to return to work. Employees will also be provided with surgical masks starting next week, the company says, once it receives shipments of orders of “millions” placed a few weeks ago. Lastly, everyone seems to ignore that this employee violated a direct work order to not come on site, because he had been in contact with someone who tested positive for COVID-19. Regardless of what people speculate about Amazon's reasons for firing this person, no one seems to be disputing that this employee violated a requirement to not come to the work site. That is clearly grounds for termination, irrespective of other considerations. So can we please stop sharing these low quality articles over and over on Hacker News?
- choward 7y agoAll I wanted to do was read the memo and I couldn't find the link. I'm not sure if I missed it or what but this is a common problem I run into on "news" sites. They quote (often out of context) parts of something but give no links to the actual source.
- throwawaysea 7y agoThat's very much by design, in order to paint a certain picture, generate outrage, and ultimately clicks. Recall when the James Damore story was breaking? Many outlets like Motherboard (owned by Vice, authors of this story) circulated quotes and even modified documents that didn't show the full list of research references quoted by Damore, in an attempt to paint a certain picture. Unfortunately this is the low bar set by a lot of modern journalism. We need a way out of it back to neutral, factual reporting.
- DubiousPusher 7y ago> Unfortunately this is the low bar set by a lot of modern journalism. We need a way out of it back to neutral, factual reporting. Creating fact focused journalism is a laudible goal but I'd be curious of what specific time in history you think that this was generally the case?
- throwawaysea 7y agoThat's a good point. I can't say whether we've ever hit the mark on that generally. However, old news broadcasts (you can find them on Youtube) do seem a lot less emotional and more neutral. They probably still had their biases; I am unsure. However, I feel like HN is often sources from outlets like Vox and Vice, both of which are recognized as having a strong bias (see https://www.allsides.com/media-bias/media-bias-ratings https://www.allsides.com/media-bias/media-bias-ratings). We can at least do better, even if we can't be perfect.
- DubiousPusher 7y agoThere is as much bias in what you choose to report on as there is in the way you report it. For most of the mid-late 20th century major media outlets uncritically reported information stated by the White House and the military. To do so without commentary or comparison to factual reality is a kind of bias but feels neutral because it doesn't create contention in an individual's mind. There are exceptions such as Cronkite's broadcast after the Tet Offensive which I am not lauding or criticizing here, only to say it was out of the norm.
- sct202 7y agoI wonder if Amazon is throwing Zapolsky under the bus.
- ignoramceisblis 7y agoEver the victim. He threw himself under the bus.
- MattGrommes 7y agoAmazon really could be just as big as they are without going down the Walmart route of being actively shitty / evil. It sucks that they're choosing not to do that.
- gentleman11 7y agoIt’s why I cancelled my prime a few months back
- thosmos 7y agohttps://cancelprime.com https://cancelprime.com
- CaptainZapp 7y agoIt's why I never shopped at Amazon and don't plan to ever do it. The exception was in the very beginning a few books. After they apruptly changed their privacy policy that did it for me.
- dylan604 7y agoThe only way to beat Walmart is to out Walmart them. Overwork and underpay employees, find the cheapest products forgoing legitimacy/quality/etc. It's not very shocking this is where we are.
- jdkee 7y agoAs I have said elsewhere, Amazon needs to have the full force of anti-trust law thrown at them and be broken up.
- booboolayla 7y agoYes, Marxist agitators usually get a taste of their own medicine.
- gentleman11 7y agoI worked warehouse and factory jobs once. The good ones are unbelievably better and safer than the bad ones. I feel bad for everyone who was not able to find one of the good ones
- brnt 7y agoAh, Amazon. Classy, as always. I'm wasn't counting, but I must be close to a 3 year no-Amazon streak. Who's with me?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Der_Einzige 7y agoWhat do you expect when the CEO is a literal vampire for the purpose of staying young. It was fucking horrifying reading up on that practice. It freaks me out to even type out this stuff but it's all true.
- meowface 7y agoIf I could afford it, and if it really work, I'd be a vampire, too. Pay some young people to donate a bit of their blood to a facility, get a transfusion, and you might retain your youth for longer, with a longer quantity of life and longer + higher quality of life? I'm below 30 now, but I'd sign up for such a thing without hesitation even if it bankrupted me - if it truly works and is safe. Of course it'll be many years or decades before we have any real clarity on that, but if it works, and if it's a negligible, non-risky amount of blood donated by each person which also isn't risky for the recipient, and if it can be afforded, it really feels very ignorant not to sign up, to me. They just need to lower the costs so ordinary people can easily partake as well, not just super wealthy people.
- yaitsyaboi 7y agoWait, is this real? It seems deeply weird to me. I think they have a carve out for plasma, but surely selling your literal blood is illegal? If not, why can't people sell organs? I think this just introduces a sort of inequality that even American society can't stomach.
- meowface 7y agoYes, it's real. And yes, it's plasma, not blood. (It's just more sensationalistic to call it blood because then you get the vampire analogies and "blood boys" from the Silicon Valley show. I find it amusing, personally.) Obviously giving away an organ is far more health-adverse than giving away a small amount of plasma. Unfortunately, lots of people already do donate plasma in exchange for money because they desperately need the money, and that's just for plasma that goes to sick people. In my opinion, if rich people are offering those same plasma donors 10x or more than the amount they'd get from donating to a typical blood bank, then it's at least a big improvement over the current situation. And hopefully they put limits and ID checks in place to ensure people never donate above a certain amount of plasma per day/week/month and risk their health. Hopefully we'll one day be able to grow or synthesize the youth-preserving compounds in the plasma without requiring the donors.
- stefan_ 7y agoZapolsky seems like the kind of person who, and you don't have to go too far back in history, would be drafted, deployed and then promptly unceremoniously shot in the back by those around him when they discovered his adventurous streak in putting them at risk. Now that we are in a state of emergency, maybe we can instead arrest those psychopaths that sit at home in pyjamas, log into their Zoom meeting and draft up plans to disparage and terminate the people exposed and speaking up against unsafe practices. They are traitors, a net negative on the world.
- draw_down 7y agoI’m with you. But of course that won’t ever happen.
- Zooper 7y agoDamage control really ate these comments.
- ipsocannibal 7y agoCalled it: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22740540 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22740540
- jshevek 7y agoI'd have a lot more faith in this story if I could see the memo for myself. Vice is not above twisting people's words and taking them out of context.
- meowface 7y ago>You ideally want to take measures to reduce the likelihood of a given recipient seeing anyone else's copy and thus having a chance to spot the variance, but there are ways to do that How, exactly? If you know someone else received what you believe to be the same document, what's the disincentive? Is it mostly a matter of attempting to not give away any indication of who else may have received it, so that no one knows who could be a candidate to compare with? Or including some amount of explicitly-marked data specific to the recipient which they somehow would have difficulty censoring before sharing?
- thosmos 7y agoWe the customers can exert influence on its ethics and character by engaging in a consumption strike. Put your money where your ethics are. https://cancelprime.com https://cancelprime.com
- jmull 7y agoI don't really see a problem here. It's not smearing, just PR strategizing. They think Smalls is going to hurt himself and his cause and they want to let him do that. (If he really did break 14-day isolation early it's going to work too.)