3 ms·
CFR is always wildly overestimated initially. Various models and data sets put asymptomatic cases at between 20% and 50%. Those are fully asymptomatic - i.e. t
by TheOtherHobbes 7y ago
CFR is always wildly overestimated initially.
Various models and data sets put asymptomatic cases at between 20% and 50%. Those are fully asymptomatic - i.e. total end-to-end progression with either very mild symptoms indistinguishable from a minor cold, or no symptoms at all.
It's almost impossible to estimate expected population mortality with limited and noisy data, but I've seen estimates from 1.5% to 0.05%.
The only thing that can be said with certainty is that social distancing, testing, and tracking all do a lot to prevent initial infection, and good access to ICU hugely improves chances of survival after infection.
The rest is guesswork at this point. Having said that - my current hand-wavy estimate of deaths in the UK is high five, low six figures. Multiply by five or so for the US.
- Majromax 7y ago> Various models and data sets put asymptomatic cases at between 20% and 50%. Those are fully asymptomatic - i.e. total end-to-end progression with either very mild symptoms indistinguishable from a minor cold, or no symptoms at all. That's why I use South Korea as a model. They've tested enough that they should have found the majority of asymptomatic cases, and they still have CFR above 1% (1.7% as of this writing). That also puts a bound on reasonable levels of occult spread. We can support maybe 50% of cases being totally asymptomatic and undetected, but if that is significantly greater then we'd see contact-tracing (again, SK-style) entirely fail as a control measure. So it seems like an absolute best-case CFR is 0.5%, if it would be 1% among symptomatic cases and there again that many that never notice / are diagnosed with the disease. For the UK, that would give an optimistic projection of (66e6 * 50% * 0.5% =) 165k deaths in a "herd immunity" outcome with a "flat curve", so this is consistent with the range of your "hand-wavy estimate."
- nostrebored 7y agoWe will not know how effective testing has been until we have serological tests. There are a few assumptions being made regarding the efficacy of testing, and contact tracing will certainly miss pockets of asymptomatic people.