9 ms·
Palantir in Talks with Germany, France for Virus-Fighting Tool
- rdxm 7y agoLOL!.....What could possibly go wrong!
- zzleeper 7y agoHow is a stupid Java app with clueless consultants going to help against covid? Or is it Thiel selling yet more snake oil?
- dogma1138 7y agoIm guessing contact tracing, it should actually be pretty decent for this if they can get good inputs.
- nogabebop23 7y agoYes, that was my thought. Contact tracing is likely the top reason Singapore. S. Korea (and to a lesser extent Japan) were able to selectively & aggressively contain infections, along with active policing and enforcement. Palantir's core focus is on databases for tracking "assets" with a geographic component, so it would seem like a natural application. If this reduces the need and application for nation-wide bans like contact tracing did in Singapore than whatever the cost it will be a rounding error.
- tastroder 7y ago> than whatever the cost it will be a rounding error. "Whatever the cost" disregards the non-monentary costs of giving a player like Palantir access to this data. If you need to implement digital help for contact tracing, at least pretend to do it in a privacy-preserving manner (plenty of attempts out there). There's no need to give surveillance data to the security apparatus of another country just because they have a few spreadsheets already.
- new2628 7y ago> Contact tracing is likely the top reason Singapore. S. Korea (and to a lesser extent Japan) were able to selectively & aggressively contain infections, along with active policing and enforcement. That and masks on people's faces.
- dogma1138 7y agoIt’s also pretty decent at constructing social networks and interaction graphs form different types of data which is what they pitch for fraud detection and tracing. Basically one of their only models that actually works seems to be suited for contact tracing nearly perfectly. I understand the reservations of people here regarding the company itself tho, but I’m not against it as a blanket statement. E.G. on prem installation on German government servers with German staff doesn’t seem like an overreach, especially considering that the German government is already a client.
- throwawaymanbot 7y agoThere are other companies that can do it. Palantir is not the one to be allowed do this.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 7y agoThiel thinks he is the first to discover that government contracts pay exorbitantly for software that under delivers.
- wmeredith 7y agoAnd HN thinks they're the first ones to be mad about it ;)
- starfallg 7y agoInviting a lot of unwanted attention too, given his reputation. This is going to be interesting.
- pstuart 7y agoThiel is your classic contemporary libertarian: no government except when there's money to be made or self interests are at stake.
- chrisseaton 7y agoWhat has the language it’s written in got to do with it?
- zymhan 7y agoBecause no good technology is written in an out-of-style language! \s
- animalnewbie 7y agoIn general Java's ubiquity means that a lot of substandard programmers know java. Nothing wrong with the language per se.
- nabnob 7y agoGovernments love having an excuse to increase their surveillance of citizens. First it was terrorism, now it is coronavirus.
- tasogare 7y agoThe goal is not to fight the epidemic, it’s probably to track: (1) current social networks talk about the no-go zones that don’t respect confinement, and (2) see if any Gilets Jaunes 2.0 or any revolutionary groups is forming. The risk is real for the government, which was already hugely unpopular and as handled the crisis catastrophically (see below). Government mistake includes: - doing nothing for two months - lying about the dangerousness of the virus - saying that masks are useless for citizens yet requesting all available - sending masks to China at the beginning of epidemic - not restocking masks despite the existence of a pandemic emergency stock - neglecting hospitals for decades (staff was striking a few months ago) - battling the potential treatment of Pr. Raoult because of a personal feud between him and the ministry of health’s husband - putting chloroquine under toxic medicine list just as the epidemic starts - changing the layout of the paper need to present to police everyday - enforcing confinement on a part of the population but not another one - ... I probably forget a lot more Sources: French media, friends, family and social networks. People are genuinely angry at the govt response and some are already talking in insurrectional terms.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jacobush 7y agoPhew, I was getting worried there for a second for the US. If any Gilets Jaunes would form in the US, they wouldn't turn on the administration. And they'd be more of "Gilets Brune" anyway. They'd be on the side of the administration ready to torch whatever group must bear the blame. Some Palantir-like intelligence can be very useful when you want to direct your s̵h̵o̵c̵k̵ ̵t̵r̵o̵o̵p̵s̵ supporters to peacefully protest.
- angry_octet 7y agoSounds like they've done about twice as well as the US Govt then. I don't think they need to worry about manifestations because going to one is a fast pass to getting COVID-19.
- code4tee 7y agoPlease don’t let this company anywhere near the healthcare system.
- boringg 7y agoSecond to that - that company feels so sketchy.
- sm2i 7y agoThey are sketchy: https://duckduckgo.com/?q=palantir+cambridge+analytica https://duckduckgo.com/?q=palantir+cambridge+analytica
- diggan 7y agoImplying they don't already have all that data and has been/is actively pursuing getting into it more for quite some time now. https://www.palantir.com/palantir-foundry/impact/healthcare/ https://www.palantir.com/palantir-foundry/impact/healthcare/
- benevol 7y agoThat company is one of the most corrupt ones - it is the real virus. You know how they say, Never let a good crisis go to waste.
- drocer88 7y agoCurrent administration supports Peter Thiel's Palantir and getting them contracts: FDA, CDC, NIH. Apparently Mr. Thiel was one of the few Silicon Valley supporters of Mr. Trump. https://www.fpds.gov/ezsearch/fpdsportal?q=palantir+DEPARTMENT_FULL_NAME%3A%22HEALTH+AND+HUMAN+SERVICES%2C+DEPARTMENT+OF%22&s=FPDSNG.COM&templateName=1.5.1&indexName=awardfull&x=0&y=0&start=30 https://www.fpds.gov/ezsearch/fpdsportal?q=palantir+DEPARTME...
- trymas 7y agoHaven't Thiel donated 7 figure sums to Trump's campaign? After contracts are being awarded left and right - I cannot see those donations none other than bribery.
- stevespang 7y agoPalantir sales pitch: We can provide you a tracking solution, and after the pandemic is over, you can continue to use the product to track and spy on all your citizens. What a perfect way to incorporate our superior technology into your Gov't, all under the auspices of a public emergency !
- Sol- 7y agoI sure hope governments will be wise enough to not cooperate with Palantir, which is the embodiment of the worst excesses of surveillance capitalism. Managing the spread of the virus is a critical issue and if some surveillance of the population is required, it necessitates a lot of trust and transparency on part of the government. Working with Palantir would undermine that from the start. In principle, I'd have been open voluntarily to installing such a privacy-preserving bluetooth contact tracing app (provided it's open source and auditable). But knowing that Palantir may or may not be involved in analyzing that data, I'll probably pass.
- nogabebop23 7y ago>> ... such a privacy-preserving bluetooth contact tracing app (provided it's open source and auditable Hey, whip that for the the world, if you don't mind? Queue the inevitable deluge of "it's not that big of a project, more than 5 Devs would be a shocking waste, etc." comments...
- colonavilus 7y agoFraunhofer is already field-testing an app based on that concept
- throwawaymanbot 7y agoPlease. Germany rethink this.
- lalos 7y agoIn some positive light, 3-4 years ago Google or Facebook would've jumped on and published a contact tracing app without thinking twice. I wonder what's going on inside in terms of discussions. Some positive side effect of the tech slash to step back and think twice of side effects or maybe they've learn to avoid possible bad PR.
- maps7 7y agoHow is that positive? They have great engineers, great infrastructure and a lot of money. It would be great if they could help.
- mellow2020 7y agoWhen everybody acts as if they're already infected, and so is everyone else, how is this helping?
- maps7 7y agoEverybody is not acting like that. I meant help in any way that would benefit everyone.
- mellow2020 7y ago> Everybody is not acting like that. The vast majority does. > I meant help in any way that would benefit everyone. And I'm asking how that would help. So far, every single proponent of "surveillance because covid" I asked this avoided the question. It's also pretty incredible how you split hairs about "everybody" in the first sentence, and then talk about something that will help "everyone" in the second, without even saying how.
- maps7 7y ago> The vast majority does. How can you say that? The Netherlands still has people going to cafes. The UK is talking about banning outside exercise. Even if you can point to a figure saying people are moving less and adhering to their government's guidelines I don't think it follows that you can say the majority of people are acting like they are infected. As for the second part, by definition, if those companies actions benefit everyone.. it would help. I didn't say and I don't know how they would do that. Since this conversation started, it looks like Google has used their great engineers, great infrastructure and lots of money to publish movement reports. This might feed into Government decisions and hopefully will be a benefit for "everyone". Check it out here: https://www.google.com/covid19/mobility/ https://www.google.com/covid19/mobility/
- Nekorosu 7y agoGoodbye-Civil-Liberties virus.
- bandage 7y agoAs a person that had the opportunity to work with them and their products, seeing a post like this makes me angry and sad. I personally find the company extremely incompetent, that hires young postgrade students without any prior experience to solve big problems for the biggest companies around the world. How it ends up is technical depts and gigantic costs. Not to mention few shady things that seems normal for them - full access to their customers business data and source code. Epidemics should not be a time for business opportunities. It's not like they have any closed patented solution that will suddenly solve any problems... It's definitely not a equivalent of openai in data engineering world. They are just experts in marketing bs.
- troughway 7y agoSo wait. Are they the big bad all-present panopticon, or are they incompetent, inexperienced muppets?
- crispyambulance 7y ago> big bad all-present panopticon, or are they incompetent, inexperienced muppets? Sadly both are possible at the same time in a large well-funded company. If they succeed in getting these contracts from scared governments, they'll be better positioned in the future for more such work. Privacy and freedom "mishaps" will be chalked up to "oh, it was an emergency, we had to do what we had to do."
- beagle3 7y agoNo inside knowledge, but by all accounts they seem to be both, and there’s no conflict. An incompetent customer facing layer can enable a competent layer to act with full data and less visibility. The incompetent layer also helps extract finances.
- nabnob 7y agoIf a platform involves tracking huge amounts of personal data and then making decisions off of that data, incompetence makes it more dangerous, not less. LAPD has been using Palantir to track people in poor and working class neighborhoods in LA - https://www.bloomberg.com/features/2018-palantir-peter-thiel/ https://www.bloomberg.com/features/2018-palantir-peter-thiel... >The LAPD uses Palantir’s Gotham product for Operation Laser, a program to identify and deter people likely to commit crimes. Information from rap sheets, parole reports, police interviews, and other sources is fed into the system to generate a list of people the department defines as chronic offenders, says Craig Uchida, whose consulting firm, Justice & Security Strategies Inc., designed the Laser system. The list is distributed to patrolmen, with orders to monitor and stop the pre-crime suspects as often as possible, using excuses such as jaywalking or fix-it tickets. At each contact, officers fill out a field interview card with names, addresses, vehicles, physical descriptions, any neighborhood intelligence the person offers, and the officer’s own observations on the subject. >The platform is supplemented with what sociologist Sarah Brayne calls the secondary surveillance network: the web of who is related to, friends with, or sleeping with whom. One woman in the system, for example, who wasn’t suspected of committing any crime, was identified as having multiple boyfriends within the same network of associates, says Brayne, who spent two and a half years embedded with the LAPD while researching her dissertation on big-data policing at Princeton University and who’s now an associate professor at the University of Texas at Austin. “Anybody who logs into the system can see all these intimate ties,” she says. To widen the scope of possible connections, she adds, the LAPD has also explored purchasing private data, including social media, foreclosure, and toll road information, camera feeds from hospitals, parking lots, and universities, and delivery information from Papa John’s International Inc. and Pizza Hut LLC. The LAPD have been careful not to cite information from this software in court documents so that its constitutionality cannot be challenged.
- corporateslave5 7y agoLittle known fact is that peter thiel used palantir analytics to help Donald trump understand where to campaign.
- gazelle21 7y agoDo you have a source?
- corporateslave5 7y agoThere’s no source, it would never be made public.
- Semaphor 7y agoIt doesn’t affect me (because I don’t trust my government enough with this data to use that voluntary service, use of any such things tends to expand more and more and deleted data hasn’t been deleted), but when I first read that Palantir is one of the companies being talked to I had to laugh.
- nrki 7y agoI wonder who responds positively to Palantir recruiters? Is the money so good that it is easy to suspend your morals? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Palantir_Technologies#Controversies https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Palantir_Technologies#Controve...
- therealdrag0 7y agoGetting a job is not easy for everyone and sometimes it's easier to take the first bite you get no matter what it is.
- thulecitizen 7y agoMaybe those who were violently 'other'-ed or marginalized in our dysfunctional technological society? Those who developed a subsequent unconscious (euro-centric) savior-complex? The harmful ubiquity of the lone genius myth doesn't help. Alexander Karp talks about 'terrorists', and seems to be very patriotically committed to the American empire: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gUX0hxlrVXc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gUX0hxlrVXc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MeL4BWVk5-k https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MeL4BWVk5-k
- ng12 7y agoOutside of the minority in the Twittersphere bubble most engineers are apolitical. Palantir offers the opportunity to work on interesting software solving interesting problems and that gets them very far. Defense contractors building bombs and the NSA don't really struggle to hire engineers, either. Assuming everyone has your same belief system is a critical mistake.
- fesoliveira 7y agoAre you sure about that last point? I remember reading somewhere that U.S. government agencies were having a hard time hiring tech talent, as they did not pay as well as Silicon Valley nor had the same growth opportunities. Moreover, they had issues with the patriotic argument, as many millenials don't share the same ardent patriotism that previous generations had. It's been a while since I read that article, so things might have changed and I might be wrong.
- Prospektor4ever 7y agoWorked for them as a Product SWE for 2 years. For the record, I would not recommend it if you have good alternatives as a SWE. That being said, I want to give a more nuanced comment because, in my opinion, crisis require some pragmatism which I find to be surprisingly lacking from the usually reasonable HN crowd. I understand why Palantir create this epidermic reaction and in most cases I would agree that they are justified. There is an issue of sovereignty, countries should aim be self-sufficient in critical areas like Defense, Healthcare, Counter-terrorism. It is a shame that it is not the case. Many Palantir employees are motivated to help their country but concluded that the most straight-forward path, if they did not want to spend many years in a bureaucracy hell, was to join a startup/software style company, that would respect their value-added as young/bright engineers and make some of them (the majority in commercial works on boring stuff) able to work on those topics. Yes, compared to many cool tech companies, there is nothing great about their tech. It's a glorified Spark wrapper with a pretty UI and terrible UX. Nothing with significant tech depth is built-in house. However, THAT is compared to cool/good tech companies. Compared to a lot of what big corp and bureaucratic governments can readily provide TODAY, it's a significant improvement and it is ready, TODAY. It is also more secure compared to what an in-house gov team could build, as in, they actually encrypt things and there is no obvious security flaws. Now is the time to use the tool that can reduce the death tools without compromising security, tomorrow is the time to ask our politics to invest in their own technology sector and promote young/bright engineers to build state-of-the-art data platform that does not involve Palantir. Why Palantir is doing such action is not to gather data (they do not), or to earn money (it's likely pro bono) but to establish a relationship with governments, a trojan horse if you will, so that they can sell their services to more departments. The pragmatic action would be to accept the help now in crisis time and leverage their tools and somewhat competent Forward Deployed Engineer workforce, but decline their expansion when we are past the crisis.
- jacobush 7y agoIt really shows how weak the State is when it to a company like this appear as new territory to be colonized. Send in the scouts! Bring blankets and trinkets, try to sign agreements with local leaders, bring any intel back.
- 7y ago
- ur-whale 7y agohttps://archive.is/NHJLn https://archive.is/NHJLn
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jacquesm 7y agoThat's the last company I want to see involved here.
- SSchick 7y agoI had a recruiter from them reach out to me and ask if I was interested in moving back to Germany for a 'hot' work position. I guess that's why.
- LatteLazy 7y agoI strongly oppose the existence of companies like this and the sorts of mass surveillance activities that the NSA, GCHQ etc engage in. Having these programs makes core processes in our society like democracy and trial by jury uncertain. But given we have let them in, I am also amazed how little we seem to demand of them. The NSA should easily be able to track everyone an infected person has been near. That includes people who have been to places shortly after the infected person was there. So why aren't they doing that? The marginal cost to our society is nothing and this epidemic is already worse than all the terrorism ever in most western nations. These organisations are not just dangerous, they're dangerous and so far totally useless.
- vkou 7y agoThis is fantastic news - if you're gambling on governments failing to contain this virus in a prompt manner. By the time Palantir ships something that works well, we'll probably be half a year past having a vaccine.
- bane 7y agoI actually really get the general reaction here to Palantir. What I don't get is why the FOSS community hasn't just done the right thing and produce a competitor yet. It's not like link analysis [1] with shared backends isn't an interesting problem and big business producing billions in revenue for various companies every year. - Palantir $6B valuation - IBM Analyst Notebook - https://www.ibm.com/security/resources/demos/i2-analysts-notebook-demo/ https://www.ibm.com/security/resources/demos/i2-analysts-not... - Maltego - made by a company called Paterva with something like 200 employees popular in cyber circles Where can somebody go and just apt-get gnu-links? 1 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Link_analysis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Link_analysis
- medecau 7y ago> Where can somebody go and just apt-get gnu-links? https://gephi.org/users/install/ https://gephi.org/users/install/ But it was last updated in 2017 - https://github.com/gephi/gephi/wiki/Releases https://github.com/gephi/gephi/wiki/Releases
- bane 7y agoGephi (and other graph tools) aren't quite the same thing. The front-end user interface, and the workflows are different. It's a little closer to how maybe yED works with dragging and dropping of entities, connections, groups, but also a robust meta-data system attached to all of those things + some tools that make bringing in new information from free-text (or wherever) simple. Then all that stuff should be stored in some kind of centralized semantic database that any user using that system can search and find stuff somebody else already put in there. Maybe a document search as well so you can see what raw documents have been ETL'd. Then take various attributes off of some of the entities and relationships (like dates, or geos, or IPs) and builds various ways of looking at, filtering, and search that stuff quickly.
- bborud 7y agono. just no.
- FrojoS 7y agoFYI, they are already working for a while with the police in some German states (Bundeslaender) [1]. So this is not as big news, as it might seem to some. [1] Source: Someone who works for them on that.
- angry_octet 7y agoIt's a great opportunity for Palantir to do some corona-washing and get their hooks into EU Govt. On the plus side, Palantir has a reputation for delivering results. Govt needs to do location and contact tracking on a mass scale, integrated with the test regime, and it needs rapid analysis of this data. Negatives include what they will do for governments post the immediate Corona crisis. I'm expecting forcible deportation on a mass scale to deal with the long tail of hard to manage infected populations, and general xenophobia.