5 ms·
Are people just looking for things to be mad at Zoom for at this point? When Zoom says E2E encryption they're using older notion when it was common for services
by Spivak 7y ago
Are people just looking for things to be mad at Zoom for at this point? When Zoom says E2E encryption they're using older notion when it was common for services to not use encryption at all for these kinds of things and it was somewhat of a technical accomplishment that every client-server-server-client leg was all encrypted.
Like it's fine to point out that the bar has been raised in the security community and that the term E2E now requires that only the participants be able to decrypt the content and they should change their copy but it ignores the fact that E2E in healthcare means exactly what Zoom is doing. In the HIPPA world providers are trusted entities.
- jefftk 7y agoI've always understood E2E to mean that it's encrypted from one end to the other, without any intermediate decryption stops. This is how https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/End-to-end_encryption https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/End-to-end_encryption defines it, and has since it was a stub in 2007 (https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=End-to-end_encryption&oldid=144566198 https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=End-to-end_encryp...). Do you have any links for E2E being used in this "older" way?
- PopeDotNinja 7y agoA simple example could be something like using TLS or DTLS between all nodes in the network. But that doesn't mean data on a Zoom server sitting in the middle of a call is encrypted.
- DCKing 7y agoThe point is that the term "E2E encryption" was never used for "there is TLS involved". Because that's not what end-to-end means. E2E encryption was always clearly defined as "only the two communicating parties can access the information". Using the term "E2E encryption" in other ways is deliberately confusing. Edit: and pretending that E2E encryption meant something else in some unspecified past is revising history.
- PopeDotNinja 7y agoWith true E2E encryption, could you support features like recording a video and making it available for download? If yes, does that reflect how their video recording features work now?
- obituary_latte 7y agoThat’s not the point. If it’s not truly E2E, they shouldn’t market it as such.
- threatofrain 7y ago“Military grade encryption” might’ve sold better too.
- jaywalk 7y agoDon't forget another marketing favorite: "Bank-level encryption"
- nathanlied 7y ago"Bank-level cryptography" with some of them still storing passwords in cleartext, and others made a very painful transition to unsalted md5 within the last 5 years because they "couldn't budget it in" any earlier. No, thanks.
- shawnz 7y agoWhy hire a software engineer when you can just run some ads about the dangers of identity theft instead?
- gsich 7y agoYou can always record at either end.
- 7y ago
- braythwayt 7y agoYou make a useful point about older definitions and/or the world of HIPAA, and nothing else you say dilutes or undermines that. However, I take issue with your opening ad hominem abuse. People are looking for abuses of trust. That has nothing to do with “being mad at zoom.” That has everything to do with uncovering dishonest behaviour that is detrimental to the industry. You positioning it as some kind of emotional crusade does a disservice to people who care about important matters like informed consent. All that being said, the factual information you shared is valuable, and I thank you for it.
- threatofrain 7y agoThe “fact” that E2E has an older meaning in industry seems very hard to chase down right now. We also have the problem that if we accept this as honest or acceptable marketing language, then Apple and Google should be allowed to engage in similar standards of marketing language.
- braythwayt 7y agoI do not think Zoom are being honest about this matter. What they are is “encrypted in transit.” I appreciate that there may be %REASONS% that E2E is unachievable given the feature set they wish to provide, but to me, that juts means they should be up front. “All Zoom communications are encrypted-in-transit. We do process them on our servers to provide features like X, Y, or Z.” Would they lose even one sale if they said this?
- amelius 7y agoThat's messed up, how could the security community have allowed such ambiguity in terminology?
- lozf 7y agoThe "security community" was always clear and unambiguous, but the marketing department aren't quite so precise.
- acdha 7y agoIt didn’t. OP is making a claim which was never at any point since at least the mid-90s correct. Various marketing teams have tried to redefine it but that’s always been criticized rather than accepted.
- 2ion 7y agoe2e always meant e2e. What you are referring to is transport encryption, which as seen doesn't mean execatly the same thing.
- shawnz 7y ago> E2E now requires that only the participants be able to decrypt the content That is the literal meaning of the phrase "end to end"... There is not much room for ambiguity there
- rjvir 7y agoIf the article is accurate, this is clearly not "end-to-end" in the way that most people believe it. If Zoom was considered "end-to-end" encrypted, then any site that uses HTTPS should be able to claim so as well. I interpret end-to-end encrypted to mean only the participants have access to the content, the intermediary couldn't spy on my calls even if they wanted to. This appears to NOT be the case with Zoom.
- gruturo 7y ago??? In IT, E2E has always meant End-to-End, as in, nothing in between can decrypt the content. HIPAA, or brazillian telcos, or the FAA, or my local beer tasting club are fine to come up with whatever interpretation they want, but that doesn't change what it has always been the obvious meaning. No real room for ambiguity here...
- solinent 7y agoEnd-to-end encryption is traditionally defined as a means to stop man in the middle attacks. If there's a man always in the middle it defeats the point a little bit.
- fulafel 7y ago"When Zoom says E2E encryption they're using older notion " This is not the case. End-to-end encryption was popularized as a computing term in the 90's with PGP, and it meant that when sending eg email messages, no computer or server in the middle could decrypt the content. Only the the personal computers of the sender and recipient could. The computing field always used the term that way. If you think about the expression "end-to-end", it carries its own meaning. The only way you could become confused about this is by exposure to totally crazy marketing spiel that will sell you black as white.
- DCKing 7y agoYou could argue whether the attack on Zoom is warranted. But don't start revising history to make your point. E2E has never meant that. There's no such "old notion". I can't find any sources saying HIPAA would use that deviating definition. Most sources I see use Whatsapp as an example, which is E2E under the proper definition.
- SkyPuncher 7y ago> I can't find any sources saying HIPAA would use that deviating definition. That's because HIPAA does not define any implementation details. Google "Hipaa end to end encryption" and you'll quickly realize the Hipaa world uses a much looser definition than the security world. "End-to-end" in the context of Hipaa is typically used to indicate encryption (specifically SSL/TLS) of on-the-wire data through the entire request process. Practically this means on-the-wire data needs to be protected all the way to the underlying app service. For example, if you're running Rails with Docker. SSL/TLS transport needs to be present all the way to the container. A load balancer (or other device) is allowed to terminate/re-encrypt as long as on-the-wire data remains protected.
- KaoruAoiShiho 7y agoWhile I think people need to chill out on Zoom I can't find any alternative standards for end to end with HIPPA. Zoom fucked up here.
- computerex 7y agoInstead of asking people to Google it, your argument would hold more weight if you provided the specific sources you mean readers to go Google and find themselves. It'll save readers some time and improve your argument. Several people have tried to "google it" and tried to find alternative definitions of end-to-end encryption in the context of HIPAA and have so far failed. If end to end encryption really does mean something else in the context of HIPAA, what is your evidence/source?
- SkyPuncher 7y ago
- michelb 7y ago> Are people just looking for things to be mad at Zoom for at this point? I guess when they're being one of the most popular video conferencing platform right now, it invites attention. Doesn't help that people are Zoombombing, and their privacy track record certainly does not help. I mean, nice new unicorn, but very shady dealings ala Facebook. Not a good look.
- pulse7 7y agoIt seems that HN is flooded with commenters trying to redefine the well-established meaning of strong E2E encryption. I ask myself if there is any motivation for such comments?
- prophesi 7y agoYeah, without a single citation supporting the existence of this imaginary "older definition" of E2E encryption.
- f38zf5vdt 7y agoHave you been introduced to our new comment lord and savior, sentiment-based NLP models adjusted to context?
- teddyh 7y agoThe “EARN IT” act of 2020, possibly? https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Section_230_of_the_Communications_Decency_Act&oldid=948057307#EARN_IT_Act_of_2020 https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Section_230_of_th...
- xorcist 7y ago> E2E in healthcare means exactly what Zoom is doing In what context is E2E used within HIPAA in any other context than "not accessible by intermediaries"? Having no experience with HIPAA but plenty with PCI DSS, where E2EE is used only in this regular sense, it is easy to find public HIPAA compliance checklists which are very explicit about the end-to-end part and hard to find anyone that would allow Zoom-like uses.
- tomarr 7y agoAgree. Also surely one of the limitations here is technical / usability. One of the big features of Zoom is transcoding streams from all manner of devices and sending them to all manner of devices. Doing this on the fly is still computationally demanding and not feasible for consumer devices (or the E's in the true E2E model).
- rock_hard 7y agoRemember what they did with Facebook? It’s how the outrage made operates
- samblr 7y ago>> Are people just looking for things to be mad at Zoom for at this point? Having been a really happy user of Zoom for more than couple of years - I have referred many friends to use it succesfully. Despite that it looks like Zoom has legit issues that are surfacing. However I have to say it cannot be ruled out there might be some negative PR going on too since I can't help see using any Zoom alternative! Everything else pretty much sucks.
- fossuser 7y agoI think the answer to your first question is yes. It puts the negative reporting on all other tech companies that start to see success in context.
- hluska 7y agoI’m annoyed by pile on culture and hate when a company goes from darling to demon. But as distasteful as I find that element of our society, I don’t think this is an example of pile on culture. Rather, I think that in this case, Zoom is using a false message with real life implications. If you have a level of technical sophistication, you can see the shades of grey in all security. So maybe this usage of E2E can be overlooked in HIPAA or other threat contexts. But a wider array of people, including senior decision makers in sensitive organizations believe that E2E means ‘gooder’. :) When I look at it through this lens, I’m not comfortable with the implications of their marketing message. I’m not sure this makes Zoom a demon, but I definitely trust them less as a result. Is that reasonable or am I overreacting to something? If I am, I would love to know where I’m wrong!
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]