3 ms·
You are ignoring the fact that cars have to navigate what is basically a set a of 1 dimensional corridors on a 2 dimensional plane. Airplanes don't have these l
by jillesvangurp 7y ago
You are ignoring the fact that cars have to navigate what is basically a set a of 1 dimensional corridors on a 2 dimensional plane. Airplanes don't have these limitations and can fly point to point at their choice of altitude.
Currently most of the congestion in aviation is around airports which are necessarily optimized for large jets. With a small airplane, you can fly to a much larger variety of airports, around ~50K world wide and it's relatively straightforward to build even more of them as needed.
Noise is a function of propeller size, rotation speed, and engine noise. Simply put, lots of small propellers rotating at faster speeds driven by electrical engines are a lot less noisy than larger props driven by combustion engines. The physics around this are complex and involve things like the speed of sound of the tips of the propeller (you break that limit at lower rpm for larger props), the mass and thickness of the propeller, vortices, etc. Basically, all of that improves with smaller props.
Compared to a loud helicopter, an electrical plane at the same altitude could be a lot less noisy to the point where in a busy city you'd hear one but not the other above the ambient noise.
- Zenst 7y ago> Noise is a function of propeller size, rotation speed, and engine noise Yes and also the frequency of sound, which is another factor of complexity as to how that propagates.
- mumblemumble 7y agoI'm guessing that the break-even point on space efficiency is somewhere close to the point where you invent Blade Runner-style levitating cars that require zero extra space for take off and landing, and can move arbitrarily slowly, or even come to a complete stop, without falling out of the sky. Without that, I doubt that that adding some room for vertical stacking would offset the amount of additional lateral space they end up needing. And I believe that effect would be intensified by the the amount of vertical stacking you can reasonably do being constrained by how far a vehicle needs to move laterally in order to gain or shed a given amount of altitude, and the distance of the trip being made. For a traditional fixed-wing aircraft operating over "urban commute" distances, that constraint would be downright tyrannical. For Blade Runner style levitating cars, it would be no big deal.
- athenot 7y ago> cars have to navigate what is basically a set a of 1 dimensional corridors on a 2 dimensional plane. Airplanes don't have these limitations and can fly point to point at their choice of altitude. That's not entirely correct. Planes also have corridors in the sky. Just like roads, there are the highways (with different altitudes for different directions) and slower lanes for smaller aircraft. And airports are basically a confluence of many lanes, which requires a coordination (air traffic controllers). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Airway_(aviation) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Airway_(aviation)
- xhkkffbf 7y agoYes, but these are just by convention. Some pilots argue quick forcefully for allowing point-to-point navigation to save fuel and time. In any case, it's easy to set up another "road" just a few thousand yards north, south, east, west and up or down.
- jillesvangurp 7y agoDepends on what class of airspace you are in and weather you are flying under IFR or with some kind of flight following & flight plan. But even then the air ways can be stacked vertically. If you are flying vfr and in an airspace where that is allowed, you can pretty much go where you want as long as you stay away from controlled areas. Basically most helicopters fly VFR. The recent accident with Kobe Bryant involved a VFR flying helicopter flying into fog in LA.
- bdamm 7y agoTrue, but to provide reliable commuting you pretty much have to fly IFR, especially in a place like SF Bay or LA. This is because often marine layer clouds don't clear until 10am and people want to be at work long before then. It may be possible to do a lot more to improve the availability of IFR approaches and routes if we factor in automated systems. It's going to take a lot longer to build more airports, but I can tell you that pretty much every airport manager in the United States will be thrilled to face that problem.
- nradov 7y ago
- technofiend 7y ago>You are ignoring the fact that cars have to navigate what is basically a set a of 1 dimensional corridors on a 2 dimensional plane. Airplanes don't have these limitations and can fly point to point at their choice of altitude. Absolutely true. However cars are mostly autonomous and airplanes flying through urban airspace are not, with rare exception. The bottleneck will be our air traffic control system, which can not in its semi-automated form scale to the volume required and would not qualify for the usual SV "move fast and break things" treatment, since "breaking things" in this context would be in-air near misses and collisions.
- jillesvangurp 7y agoTrue, this is as much a cultural and legislative problem as it is a technical problem. IMHO, having lots of autonomous capable planes will create a need for having them interact with some form of automated traffic control that does not yet exist. Building that technically is much less of a challenge than getting it certified, standardized, and integrated in the aviation world. IMHO this will play out over decades and will be driven by increasing traffic volumes of basically fully or semi autonomous vehicles causing issues with the current system. But if you think about it, doing things the way we have been doing for the last 70 years with analog radio broadcasts, call signs, people using archaic jargon, chattering about altimeter settings, verbal communication of flight plans, having to monitor multiple radio frequencies, etc. is maybe not optimal in a world where all that info could be exchanged in ms between two autonomously operating systems.
- technofiend 7y agoYup yup - I'm not defending the status quo as much as just commenting it's not built for the future utopia of self-directed or autonomous private aviation. Commercial aviation puts pressure on Congress now to try and marginalize general aviation due in part to system constraints; every private flight that displaces a commercial one is revenue lost as far as they are concerned.
- bananabreakfast 7y agoAutonomous air traffic control is far further along than you think it is.
- LargoLasskhyfv 7y agoHave you seen/heard recently built rescue helos in action? Been very surprised by them. The loudest thing is the whine of their turbine, but not that loud at all. There are many louder cars and motorcycles on the street. I don't know the type anymore, but it was something built by Airbus Industries, based on some Eurocopter platform. Worlds apart from those old Bell UH-1s!