4 ms·
During the clinton administration, NIH funding doubled over ~5 years. This led to a glut of PhDs (far, far more than there are faculty slots or biotech jobs) w
by dekhn 7y ago
During the clinton administration, NIH funding doubled over ~5 years. This led to a glut of PhDs (far, far more than there are faculty slots or biotech jobs) who had limited job options and it didn't really translate to higher scientific productivity (in some sense, it just ended up selecting for professors who were more cutthroat and willing to publish lower quality stuff in higher h-index journals).
I've also seen, repeatedly, that most biologists (both wet-lab and computational) will just waste more money rather than using it to scale up productivity.
The real question is ultimately "how do we scale scientific productivity in a way that benefits humanity directly and in the short term", and few people have any answer to that. It seems like the current state of the art, and hard to improve on, is to fund lots of people, give them time to be creative, and then send them to meetings to get tipsy with people who have money, while demonstrating their posters. I'm not kidding.
- pen2l 7y agoCorrect me if I'm wrong, but the average institution or entity that Bill Gates chooses to fund is much more productive than the average NIH funded lab. I think the answer lies in taking a good look at where the money is going. Particularly, I think I think we need to give more to the very productive people and institutions. I know it's the million dollar question, by what is Salk doing that others are not? Or CSHL which has something like 8 nobel laureates there. One last observation is that a career in science just doesn't make sense anymore. Why slave away making $40 or $50k as a postdoc or an instructor after years of studious study when you can pull 6 figures in tech right out of school? This right here is one of the things that tells the bright ones to stay away from academia.
- dnautics 7y agoEx-Scientist here: While I agree the gates foundation is likely doing a better job than the nih... The danger is this, how do you decide upon a metric for productivity? How do you then prevent 1) corruption, absent that, 2) inadvertent corruption via biases (I'm going to judge proposals in my field more favorably because they are less confusing or more comfortable, or the inverse, more harshly since I want to keep competition out or know the pitfalls better), and absent that, 3) goodhart's law?
- phkahler 7y agoIs there a psychological measure of internal bias? Hire decision makers that score low on that?
- mistermann 7y agoHow about we vote on it?
- pdm55 7y agoScience is accidental, boring, repetitive, focused, finicky, wasted, political, ... A beast not easily tamed. Think of Edison's 100 trials to develop the light bulb. I continually think of my own truncated scientific career. I couldn't, early on in my projects, see the woods for the trees. About the only thing, I recognised was that I was just one cog in a vast enterprise. Looking back, I wish I had had the energy and insight to see beyond my lab work to where it might lead. Back in those days, you needed the term "business model" in your grant submission in order to attract funds. I walked away, thinking I had interests that could better generate a business.
- godelski 7y agoCurrent scientist: I think the answer is easy. Take more risk. Science is by nature risky. We're trying to figure out things that we don't know. That results in a lot of failure (I definitely wouldn't use the Silicon Valley model of failure being a metric of success though). One major change I would make from public money is publishing of results good or bad. There's this competition to get into top tier journals (which I don't think is bad or you can get rid of), but this is done at the cost of dumping good science just because it wasn't good enough for a top tier. Using impact as a metric is good but not great. The mark of a good scientist is their work and their passion, not where they publish. While there's a correlation, there's also Goodhart. If this is the only metric that we really concentrate on, then it will lead to slower science. We all know that we learn much more from failure than success. We all know that most of science is banging your head on the table for weeks out of frustration. But that's also not common knowledge. So I'd say that those funding science need to be more risky and those in science need to be more open about their failures and be realistic in their discussion of science.
- Retric 7y agoThe way to increase efficiency over time is to develop useful tools like CRISPR not simply look for the most beneficial research to solve a specific problem. Bill Gates has a focus on specific goals which are extremely valuable today, but arguably shortsighted. Further, the NIH is focused on solving problems for the UK not say Ethiopia. But, as poor countries develop they start using UK style solutions not cheaper though less effective alternatives. So it’s really a question of which metric you’re using to evaluate each system not some universal efficiency metric. Global impact over the next 20 years vs global impact over 200 years etc.
- wtvanhest 7y agoThe older I have gotten, the more I believe that short term gains are better than long term strategies because short-term gains build on each other. I don’t know the history of crispr, but I doubt it was just a single check, single project completed from start to end. I’m sure it took a lot of iteration and success of many small short-term goals
- Retric 7y agoIt’s the nature of the goals not the time it takes to reach them that I am talking about. A COVID-19 vaccine is extremely valuable today, but it becomes useless even 5 years from now. On the other hand our experience with COVID-19 is likely to spawn a great deal of research into developing vaccines faster which while useless for this epidemic could be extremely valuable for the next several. Clearly a COVID-19 vaccine could save millions of lives and is worth investing in, but it’s a specific finite number. So called basic research can save more people’s lives than are alive today.
- runako 7y ago> develop useful tools like CRISPR not simply look for the most beneficial research to solve a specific problem You're describing a 40+ year body of research as if it were a project to develop CRISPR as an endpoint. But that's nothing like the process that actually produced CRISPR. Take the Hsu et. al. paper describing CRISPR-Cas9 (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4343198/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4343198/), for example. That paper cites 100 other papers, with multiple citations in each decade going back to the 1980s. (The first paper cited was published based on research that likely happened 10 years before before the sequencing of the entire genome of an organism.) And those 100 papers lean on other papers, etc. Science is not an engineering project.
- lonelappde 7y ago> Correct me if I'm wrong Can you start with any evidence? Correct me if I'm wrong: Gates projects are less productive than NIH, counterproductivey harming education policy, and focused on different, cheaper problems like non-US basic health and malaria.
- anonlinear 7y agoWhy not create more research labs and professorships? There are many state universities without great programs right? Also glut of PhDs doesnt seem to be a problem for a lot of engineering fields.
- dnautics 7y agoHow do you know small labs are more productive? Are we trying to do science for society or trying to be a jobs program? These two objectives are not necessarily synergistic.
- dekhn 7y agoThe challenge with those is hiring. State unis without great programs have a hard time hiring the top folks needed to make great programs. Also, top universities will just hire away the best professors from state universities after the profs become successful. I think the rich folks are more interested in making Institutes- the Allen Institute and CZI being two examples. Institutes which are not affiliated with a university have a lot of advantages to the folks they hire- tend to be in popular locations, with higher salaries, more resources for crazy ideas, less overhead on grants (just a guess, I don't really know for sure), and NO TEACHING REQUIREMENTS (many top research profs hate teaching because it eats so much time).
- hocuspocus 7y agoI worked at something a bit like the Allen Institute, but that is governed by a public university. It's not an issue if done right. We collaborated with them quite a bit by the way, and they faced almost exactly the same issues. Salaries aren't that good really (maybe 10-20% higher than in US national labs), they struggle to hire people who usually can make twice the money at Amazon or Microsoft. And you still need some ties to academia. From my point of view, as a developer who didn't understand anything about the science my platform was used for: - I think you probably want to have a few PhD students, postdocs and professors. They are the ones who can be creative given the right environment: no pressure to publish, access to sufficient resources (material and human) that enable their work. - You need more money, but more importantly to spend it wisely. Pay people enough (in my case 20-30% more) and you'll cut the turnover by 2-3x.
- grawprog 7y ago>I've also seen, repeatedly, that most biologists (both wet-lab and computational) will just waste more money rather than using it to scale up productivity. While I agree to an extent, it's not necessarily possible to 'scale up'. I helped run a project off around $40,000 of grant money. Our goals were research and education. About half went to pay my coworker and I about $15/h, another large chunk went to gas. The rest went to equipment and stuff. We couldn't charge for anything, we had no product to sell. We made brochures and buttons we gave out by donation, our work was in no way marketable. We had to justify everything we did by proving the value of the animals we were studying to agriculture. There's a ton of scientific research that isn't directly valuable in the short term. Especially when it comes to biology. As it is, much of the work is just gathering data because we have painfully limited knowledge of our ecosystems. But the more we learn, the more we understand how important they are for the long term functioning of the planet. It's exceedingly difficult convince a logging company or an oil company, the government they bribe, or the public in general that caring about the long term gains of researching these things should come before the short term gains of exploiting them. At least in my experience.
- jvanderbot 7y agoI think we should look at the environment of the sputnik, Manhattan, and Bell labs era. I suspect the incentives are misaligned. Currently, my success is basically citations, publications, speaking engagements, and grants won. Technology developed should serve those purposes. At the labs of old, this was not the case as real technological developments were the goal. I think. There's also some insight here: https://www.quora.com/Why-was-Bell-Labs-so-successful https://www.quora.com/Why-was-Bell-Labs-so-successful
- buboard 7y agomore funding doesnt mean funding more scientists
- killjoywashere 7y ago> how do we scale scientific productivity in a way that benefits humanity directly and in the short term This is actually pretty straight forward and if you read my comment history, the clues are in there. If you have $500M+ you'd like to spend on curing cancer, feel free to reply with a means of contacting you and be prepared to provide proof you're good for the funding.
- magwa101 7y agoInefficiency is intrinsic to all human activities. Double over 5 years is just shy of 20%, risks have grown by much more than that amount. Current budget is a paltry ~30B. Progress is better than perfection.