3 ms·
The general public is only going to support strikes to the extent that they look like protests against unacceptable treatment. If the strikers start "flexing th
by SpicyLemonZest 7y ago
The general public is only going to support strikes to the extent that they look like protests against unacceptable treatment. If the strikers start "flexing their labor muscle" - if it looks like they're exploiting rather than responding to the crisis - the millions of unemployed Americans are going to sour on it very quickly.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoWe can re-evaluate in a few weeks when the healthcare system and supply chains are failing under extreme load (hundreds of thousands of deaths, millions infected). Why work a terrible job when the federal government will compensate you to remain home in safety? Meet their demands or experience pain. It's not emotional, it's economic cause and effect. I will admit I'm enjoying the schadenfreude of workers finally having some power due to a Congressional response to a pandemic, much to the chagrin of "but that's how the free market works" apologists.
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoRight, that's the framing that will make people lose sympathy. "Give us what we want or you'll be in a world of pain" is an obviously sociopathic response to a pandemic; if the organizers took such a stance I honestly think strike-breakers might be resurrected to deal with it.
- toomuchtodo 7y ago> if the organizers took such a stance I honestly think strike-breakers might be resurrected to deal with it. That'll sell well in an election year with states and the federal government overextending themselves already due to a woefully inadequate initial response. We can't even get masks and ventilators manufactured at the necessary rate, and we're going to send force to assist Amazon Fulfillment? We're not even sending in force to assist first responders and medical practitioners. Amazon workers have options during this, including just going home. That's Amazon's problem, not the country's. No one is entitled to cheap delivered ecommerce services. If Amazon can't make the economics work without coerced labor, good riddance.
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoWe're absolutely sending in force to assist first responders and medical practitioners. The National Guard has been building overflow facilities across the country, and the Navy's landed in LA and New York with hospital ships.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- vkou 7y agoIt's sociopathic that these essential workers doing critical jobs are among the lowest-paid in our society, yet we all seem to be just fine with that. You're contemplating the use of violence to compel people to work, when those people don't like their terms of employment. The word for that is 'slavery'.
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoWe're not fine with that, which is why Amazon has significantly increased their pay for the duration of the lockdown. If Instacart hasn't I agree they should.
- throwaway894345 7y agoWages are largely a function of supply and demand. This downturn favors critical workers because the demand increased faster than the supply can increase, so their wages/perks should go up accordingly, but nothing happens over night.
- vkou 7y agoThey seem to be working towards making it happen, by pushing on the supply side. Good for them.
- throwaway894345 7y agoWho is "them" and how are they pushing on the supply side? The supply is only increasing insofar as workers from other industries are able/willing to transition, and even for "menial" jobs such as these, there is surely a fair amount of training that must be done. Moreover, corporations will probably prefer to temporarily increase wages for their current workers rather than take on a glut of novice workers and then do layoffs or wait for attrition afterward, so the supply side seems limited in my view.
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoI think there's a misunderstanding here. "Strikebreakers" aren't people who beat up strikers to make them go back to work; they're people who are hired to replace the strikers after the strikers are fired en masse. (It's generally illegal to break strikes this way, the company must instead negotiate with the people striking.) I agree it would be terrible to compel anyone to work through violence.
- throwaway894345 7y agoFor better or worse, your schadenfreude will only last as long as the aid package. When the money runs out, the power dynamic reverses, and the economic aftermath may well leave poorer Americans in a worse bargaining position than they were before (as economic downturns often do).
- toomuchtodo 7y agoLet's see what the electorate looks like, and its appetite for change is, after 10 months of a raging global pandemic. We're only a few weeks in, and we've already drastically expanded benefits to those in need (the stimulus bill I mentioned upthread) much more than we would've under normal circumstances. Quite a bit of change can occur in a year, no?
- throwaway894345 7y agoThere is that possibility, and while I can understand the desire for a change of administration after all of this, I can't understand why socialists are so positively gleeful. The federal government (not just the administration, but the CDC and the FDA as well) have failed in every conceivable regard in this pandemic response (somehow after 3 global outbreaks including 2 respiratory diseases in recent years, the CDC couldn't be bothered to secure a supply of masks and ventilators, never mind the testing debacle) while private industry and state/local governments are picking up the slack (scaling up testing capacity, innovating on treatments and interventions, lobbying for aid, scaling up supply chains, etc). Maybe the media will take care to spin this as a "failure of capitalism" somehow, but as far as the truth is concerned, it doesn't strike me as favoring more government.
- toomuchtodo 7y ago> Maybe the media will take care to spin this as a "failure of capitalism" somehow, but as far as the truth is concerned, it doesn't strike me as favoring more government. The Fed is predicting 47 million unemployed [1], at a 32% unemployment rate. That's a lot of folks without health insurance. 68k people in the US die every year because of lack of access to healthcare, and 50% of bankruptcies are due to medical debt, under "normal" circumstances. That is a "failure of capitalism" not replicated in other developed countries. Sometimes, to fix a system, you must break it. This is the "break it" part. [2] [1] https://www.cnbc.com/2020/03/30/coronavirus-job-losses-could-total-47-million-unemployment-rate-of-32percent-fed-says.html https://www.cnbc.com/2020/03/30/coronavirus-job-losses-could... [2] https://reason.com/2020/03/27/pandemic-related-unemployment-and-shutdowns-are-a-recipe-for-social-unrest/ https://reason.com/2020/03/27/pandemic-related-unemployment-...