4 ms·
I feel like this is a valid concern, but really when it comes to abusive relationships ... a lockdown isn't the problem / aggravating circumstance /etc. I work
by duxup 7y ago
I feel like this is a valid concern, but really when it comes to abusive relationships ... a lockdown isn't the problem / aggravating circumstance /etc.
I worked with kids who came from abusive / were in abusive families. The volume of abused partners who willingly stayed with the abuser was astonishingly high. They would even follow an abuser from one town to the next, even with services and options to not do so available.
That's not to blame them, and circumstances make things very hard (especially if you're poor, have kids, or both). But it is the simple reality that the abused partner's willingness to leave and stick to that decision was the real trigger for any positive change, and not the circumstances of their life. It is not an easy decision or easy thing to do, but there was just not getting around that it was the key too.
Obviously you can't just throw that at someone being abused because recrimination is of zero help / won't make things better.
Either way in a lockdown, or out of one, the victims are often just as "locked" in psychologically.
- scott_s 7y agoThe lockdown is not the problem, but it a problem. A new and novel one, as the article explains. My girlfriend works at a non-profit which provides shelter and support to domestic violence survivors. She counsels people in all stages. Some of her clients are dealing with this exact problem.
- jasondclinton 7y agoThis is the most HN comment I've seen in a week. You tried not to blame the victim and acknowledge poverty is the trap but then came off as doing that in the context of personal responsibility shaming. Poverty or the fear of poverty is the real decision maker here; the math is as unforgiving as orbital mechanics. And please don't reply, "But there are programs!" Governments and NGOs convince voters and donors that they are doing something by creating programs for domestic violence and then make those programs so difficult to enroll in that they spend half of their funding creating labrythine beurocracy. Anyone already at their mental capacity with abuse struggles even starting these processes.
- duxup 7y agoI think you can recognize that when you see victims get out of abusive situations, it is the victim is the one who ultimately took the decisive action (abusers just generally don't stop doing that on their own...) as a fact, and still recognize how difficult it is, and you can even call for MORE / better programs (that's what I was working in ...), and there isn't any inherent blame or conflict there.
- jasondclinton 7y agoI appreciate that you brought your own perspective to the problem with your comment. I would have liked to have seen more clarity on how victims could be helped to choose to escape.
- tw04 7y agoI'm sorry but this is a pot/kettle situation. What's more HN than pointing out that all of the things society is doing to fix the problem are useless? Then not actually providing a single solution to what you claim is a horrible problem. Having had a relative go through one of the programs you mentioned above successfully - on top of having friends who work for the institutions you claim are setup to do everything BUT help - I consider your response more offensive than his. Do you have some hard examples of "it's impossible to get any help from these programs" or are you just another "government is inefficient and useless, we need to eliminate it" libertarians?
- jasondclinton 7y agoThis thread is not the appropriate place to propose a policy solution because the parent article is about a sad topic with lots of terrible suffering. To make policy proposals here would be insensitive. And, no, I'm not a libertarian. I think that dysfunctional organizations are a moral problem that we must strive to solve, collectively. The free market will not.
- carapace 7y agoTo me it seems like you're falling into the trap of thinking that poverty somehow diminishes the agency and responsibility of the person.