13 ms·
Wow. First of all, I'm curious to what proportions this is driven primarily by remote office work (O365), videoconferencing streaming, recreational video strea
by crazygringo 7y ago
Wow.
First of all, I'm curious to what proportions this is driven primarily by remote office work (O365), videoconferencing streaming, recreational video streaming (does Disney+ run on Azure?), or what.
But second... I'm fascinated by the concept of prioritization rules in place rather than simply raising prices. I wonder if it "looks bad" to raise prices, or if the vast majority of customers already have locked-in prices contractually so that raising prices has little effect. But I'd always thought that with AWS's spot pricing and so forth, that auction-style dynamic pricing was a core feature of clouds.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- stefan_ 7y agoI don't think 1) locking in customers via proprietary APIs 2) limiting supply of resources 3) auctioning off to the highest bidder among your locked in customers was entirely the core feature of clouds. Rather, the idea was "we'll charge so much margin you never need to worry about anything physical, another machine is just an API call away". You don't need to overprovision for peak times and there is less physical stuff on your balance sheet, ez cash flow, win win! Of course now everyone realizes it's a big sham and neither Amazon nor Microsoft are stupid enough to spend a trillion capex on building the datacenters, fiber lines and so on you need to handle a temporary 700% pandemic situation. In a year from now, they don't want that stuff on their quarterly report just as companies going "cloud only" don't want it.
- bobthepanda 7y agoTo be fair, a situation where every single company in the world needed to ramp up on the cloud at the same time is completely unprecedented, and spending the money to do it would've been considered a fools' errand. If people weren't on the cloud, you'd see them scrambling for physical hardware, which also isn't exactly easy to come by on extremely short notice when the world's logistic chains are under stress as well.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- loeg 7y agoThe article probably overstates actual increase in demand, picking some small subunit which has experienced outsized increased use. They may well want to continue expanding their core hardware capacity at 20%+ annually.
- djannzjkzxn 7y agoI think given the growth these cloud providers are having every year, expanding to meet the needs of a temporary increase in demand looks more like moving forward projects that were already planned. It’s not like they are going to have to build a bunch of datacenters they will never need again.
- burkaman 7y agoIt would certainly look bad, and I think it would potentially be illegal in some states. https://consumer.findlaw.com/consumer-transactions/price-gouging-laws-by-state.html https://consumer.findlaw.com/consumer-transactions/price-gou... For example, Georgia: > Selling items or services determined by the Governor during a declared state of emergency to be necessary for public safety at a higher cost than they were immediately prior to the declaration. Kansas: > For any supplier of a "necessary property or service" to "profiteer from a disaster" by charging 25% or more than the pre-disaster price for such goods/services. Louisiana: > Selling goods/services during a declared state of emergency (within the designated emergency area) in excess of the ordinary price range immediately before the declaration. Mississippi: > Selling goods and services at above the prices normally charged during a declared state of emergency (or what was charged immediately preceding the declaration). etc. Also consider that raising prices would itself be a form of prioritization, just prioritizing ability to pay over need.
- x0x0 7y agoThey aren't raising prices; they're limiting availability. All three quoted laws solely cover prices.
- gmanley 7y agoThis thread is discussing the hypothetical legality if they did raise prices.
- jodrellblank 7y agoYes; the laws are being quoted to explain why they are limiting availability instead of raising prices.
- dfee 7y agoI don’t know how I feel about this. In the general case, I feel like price gouging during emergencies is unethical. But, when there is a non-artificial supply and demand issue, I struggle with the derivative effects of these policies. My concern is that rather than simply evaluating on the consumers ability to pay (and backwards-looking at prior statements instead of increased go-forward costs), these policies add only one additional criteria: ability to threaten legal issues. Thus, it’s only effect is to prioritize government agencies alongside wealthy clients. And that’s just governments using force to get better treatment. Which also feels unethical. But maybe there’s a happier and healthier read of the situation.
- hkmurakami 7y ago>does Disney+ run on Azure? Some cursory web searching suggests that at least as of 2017, BAMTECH / Disney were using AWS as their public cloud provider. There's enough inertia here that you'd imagine that this is still the case.
- voltagex_ 7y agoFrom here in Australia, developer tools tells me the video is coming from vod-akc-oc-east-1.media.dssott.com which appears to be an Akamai thing.
- felipelemos 7y agoAkamai is just a CDN so it's cloud agnostic.
- cortesoft 7y agoYeah, but most of the demand base load is going to be carried by the CDN... that is the whole point of a CDN.
- sels 7y agoDisney+ runs on AWS
- mroche 7y agoCan confirm (or back up sels statement).
- chrisseaton 7y ago> I'm fascinated by the concept of prioritization rules in place rather than simply raising prices Do you realise that it's potentially illegal to increase prices based on market demand during a crisis?
- closeparen 7y agoRight. It's important to the public that scarce goods instead by allocated by willingness to stand in line. What does standing in line mean for a corporation that could be anywhere in the world? Maybe some kind of proof-of-work scheme for the CEO or majority owner? Azure could service VM creation requests in the order of their creation, but "take a number" doesn't work as well. The opportunity cost of what else you could be doing with the time spent waiting in line is the "price" that allows the market to clear.
- bachmeier 7y ago> It's important to the public that scarce goods instead by allocated by willingness to stand in line. It's important to keep in mind that a higher price is unlikely to lead to much additional capacity due to the nature of this shock. Companies have to do business with their customers for many years after this is over. "Sorry, we're overloaded with demand due to this crisis" sounds a lot better than "Pay us ten times as much during the crisis or go f* yourself." Microsoft isn't in business to allocate resources according to a simplistic strategy pulled from an intro econ course, they're in business to make money over a period of many years.
- closeparen 7y ago"Sorry, we're overloaded with demand due to this crisis" is "go f* yourself." Although you're right, Microsoft may have correctly assessed that its customer relationships will turn out better if it leaves them completely hosed vs. hosed with an unpleasant escape hatch. It's still an interesting question: what kinds of allocation systems are best when for whatever reason market pricing is off the table? There are certainly better and worse approaches within the space of lotteries, queues, etc.
- avip 7y agoCloud provider is not a grocery store? You can't just wake up and randomly raise prices of services. Also lots of .gov runs on azure.
- yurlungur 7y agoApparently Team usage is up significantly. You can do video conferencing via Team which is one aspect that is quite different from Slack. I imagine there are some new use cases arising from that.
- lewispb 7y agoDifferent in what way? Slack has built-in video conferencing?
- wikibob 7y agoSlack’s video conferencing sucks. They bought ScreenHero and tried to integrate it. They screwed it up so bad that the ScreenHero founder quit after 4 years and has gone and rewrote it and called it Screen: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22676040 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22676040
- pwarner 7y agoYeah Slack themselves use Zoom. Slack is a channel based messaging tool, it integrates with best of class video tools like Zoom and file storage tools like Box or even SharePoint. Teams does it all OKish, although the channel based messaging is probably the worst part. It's sort of wrong to look at Teams as a Slack replacement. Well, it is for who just want chat, and don't care about channel messaging.
- amelius 7y agoI suspect the situation is that most customers have already paid for the service, and would demand a refund if they can't reasonably use the service.
- rashkov 7y agoCould extend this to large companies with multi-year cloud computing contracts with Azure
- perl4ever 7y agoIn general, not necessarily with Microsoft, the problem is that once people get their money back, then the vendor can't pay its bills and you have a potential for the whole economy to go into a seizure if enough people are like "oh, free market, sanctity of contracts" etc. This is happening in real time: https://www.cnbc.com/2020/03/29/coronavirus-mall-owner-taubman-is-telling-tenants-they-must-pay-rent.html https://www.cnbc.com/2020/03/29/coronavirus-mall-owner-taubm...
- eightysixfour 7y agoDon’t forget Xbox Live on Azure, it has had a pair of outages in the last few weeks as well.
- loeg 7y agoLatency in multiplayer games (at least Halo:CE prints well-known Azure region names during game load) has been noticeably worse in the past few weeks, IME. Even during off-peak hours.
- pwarner 7y agoAWS spot prices are rising last 3 weeks.
- gpm 7y agoIs there a graph somewhere that shows by how much?
- p2t2p 7y agohttps://docs.aws.amazon.com/AWSEC2/latest/UserGuide/using-spot-instances-history.html https://docs.aws.amazon.com/AWSEC2/latest/UserGuide/using-sp...
- Operyl 7y agoI looked at a few of the instances (20 or so) and did not see any substantial increase over the past 4 weeks. Which instances are you seeing spiking up?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- whatever1 7y agoSo what do you suggest here ? Prioritize a wealthy workspace sharing startup over a hospital?
- sfifs 7y agoPossibly Teams video chat which seems to work better more consistently than Zoom or Cisco Webex for small groups. At least in my organization, we've seen a lot of folks move to it in the last two-three weeks.
- bharam 7y agoWe now use Teams video chat at work. The results have been mixed. When the number of meeting participants is low (<5) the video seems to work well. Anything above that we start seeing random disconnects. We've had better experiences with Zoom for larger meetings (~25).
- carstenhag 7y agoAt my company we were using Teams' "common" conferences with 230 (1st week) and 250 (2nd week) participants without issues. In this case 248 were listening and 1-2 were talking/videocasting. Due to there being a 250 participant limit we now switched to live events, and there also has been no issue with that.
- rmujica 7y agoI just had a whole company meetup with 100+ people and Teams handled it like a champ.
- prepend 7y agoI would think that additional capacity can be built out to accommodate demand at a rate that still stays profitable after the usage spike. Not that they’re immediately building new data centers, but adding capacity to existing. Just if Microsoft moved internal usage to underused data centers somewhere on earth they could create more capacity for NA, EU, Asia. One of the upsides of cloud is that it’s so much easier to meet demand, even as a provider. I don’t have access to component prices, but I guess they are buying like crazy (aws and gcp too I guess).
- Arainach 7y agoAdding capacity how? PC supply chains are drained - they were impacted by the COVID shutdowns in China a few months ago, and extra demands are in place now: https://www.wsj.com/articles/store-shelves-stripped-of-laptops-as-coronavirus-increases-working-from-home-11584534112 https://www.wsj.com/articles/store-shelves-stripped-of-lapto... While I have no inside information, I have to imagine that these same shortages have affected data center hardware too, and that it's much more difficult/expensive to add capacity at the moment compared to, say, last December.
- pyuser583 7y agoI wonder what the net neutrality people think?
- Cthulhu_ 7y agoNet neutrality is about the network itself, the internet, not cloud computing.
- pyuser583 7y agoI thought net neutrality is “all bits are created equal.” Service providers shouldn’t discriminate between one bit and another - no deals that prefer some providers or traffic over others. It usually refers to ISPs, but I don’t see why it doesn’t apply to cloud providers too.
- azernik 7y agoAs Microsoft noted in their blog post, XBox Live also runs on Azure.
- lultimouomo 7y agoIf this is a temporary spike, raising prices might drive out customers which cannot afford the price hike but would have stayed customers for a long time, while retaining ones that will happily pay now, but go away in a couple of months.
- dspillett 7y ago> I'm fascinated by the concept of prioritization rules in place rather than simply raising prices. Given the sudden need and the circumstances behind it putting prices up might not decrease demand enough to make any difference so while the system will be more profitable it won't be any less congested and now you have people paying more but feeling like they are getting less because they had to wait an hour before they could start that little herd of VMs they usually have available immediately on demand. This could drive people off onto other services, or at least make previously entrenched users look up and scan the horizon.
- PeterStuer 7y agoPrice hiking is the least good option of all the possible prioritization rules I can imagine. Regardless of what we need most in a crisis, let's just dole it out to who has money? Really?
- neop1x 7y agoIt looks like they failed miserably on capacity planning. I thought that those three major clouds are that ridiculously expensive (egress cost, huh?!) just because of guarantees of the capacity and service availability but that seems to be wrong at least for Azure.
- modmans2nd 7y agoHealthcare and first responders shouldn’t have to pay more to get the server resources they need to respond to Covid 19