3 ms·
Scrutinising unverified medical advice on social media which could be false or a joke isn't a sign of depression, it is skepticism. The concern is towards medic
by rvz 7y ago
Scrutinising unverified medical advice on social media which could be false or a joke isn't a sign of depression, it is skepticism. The concern is towards medical advice from unverified sources like social media related to the outbreak which is very serious if not dangerous; joking or not. It's just as serious as people jokingly pretending to be doctors or medical professionals to diagnose people on the internet such as yourself.
It's kind of bad taste and timing to throw around April Fools themed medical advice around this pandemic when there are people actually taking anything 'recommended' by so called 'social media experts' to cure themselves from the disease don't you think? Unless you're willing to trust everything you see and read on the internet?
- Dylan16807 7y agoBut you're praising Google for cancelling a bunch of jokes that have absolutely nothing to do with medical advice. Stop conflating the two so utterly.
- mulmen 7y agoFor me Google.com has the search box and then a link to “DO THE FIVE. Help stop coronavirus” and then some news tiles, the second tile is about protecting your family from coronavirus. Google.com is directly giving health advice. Any joke on that page will be related to that advice. Would it be appropriate to redirect those links to Rick Astley videos on April 1? Even the other links? Can you see how that would undermine Google’s credibility?
- Dylan16807 7y agoThe jokes usually aren't on the front page in the first place. It would be bad to put it right there, on such a sparse page, next to the coronavirus note. But that's a tiny tiny subset of possible jokes. And even then, it's not messing with the medical advice. Give them the tiniest amount of credit. > Can you see how that would undermine Google’s credibility? Do you honestly think I might be okay with the specific action of redirecting the coronavirus links, and that it's a fair representation of my point? Or are you falsely equating that with 'jokes on the same page' and 'jokes on other pages' as a deliberate strawman?
- mulmen 7y agoGoogle has established themselves as an authority on the topic of Coronavirus by putting those links on their home page. Similarly news.google.com has a link to see news about Coronavirus. If Google then adds a joke to other properties or pages how do I know what to trust? Should I even bother clicking the Coronavirus links? Your previous comment said the joke would have nothing to do with coronavirus. The point I am trying to make is that everything Google does right now is related to the coronavirus. As evidence to support that position I provide the front page and news.google.com. I have made no disingenuous arguments here and I would appreciate you not accusing me of doing so.
- Dylan16807 7y ago> The point I am trying to make is that everything Google does right now is related to the coronavirus. Please. I doubt google is putting anything approaching 1% of their resources into it. It takes so little effort to add an advice page and a news category. A bit of software to help with dealing with the disease is a nice gesture but they're not a coronavirus company. > I have made no disingenuous arguments here and I would appreciate you not accusing me of doing so. You asked me a pretty insulting question. And don't ignore the 'or' in that sentence. If you think your question was fair, then I was not accusing you. But we can drop that if you want. I still think you're extremely wrong to equate any link on any page as so close to the coronavirus links that it would discredit them. Google already has tons of nonsense links, after all.
- pyuser583 7y agoIs it really appropriate for google to be giving health advice? As opposed to linking directly to the CDC?
- rvz 7y agoPerhaps you didn't read the article. I praised Google for the reason why they cancelled their April fools jokes, given the current climate and possible bad timing. "Google will take the year off from that tradition out of respect for all those fighting the Covid-19 pandemic."[0] Google also gives verified medical advice about preventing the spread of Covid-19 and Twitter, Facebook, Instagram and YouTube have all done the same to combat misinformation and unverified medical advice on their platforms. Unless you think it makes sense for them to show a bunch of April fools jokes on the front page with the covid-19 advice also present there? [0] https://www.businessinsider.com/coronavirus-google-cancels-april-fools-day-jokes-pandemic-2020-3?r=US&IR=T https://www.businessinsider.com/coronavirus-google-cancels-a...
- Dylan16807 7y agoWhat they said doesn't support your argument. And as I said already, the jokes usually aren't on the front page anyway.
- rvz 7y agoIt is relevant and it does support my original argument since I agreed with Google cancelling the April fools jokes for another time, as it would be bad timing due to the seriousness of the Covid-19 pandemic regardless if the jokes are on the front page, Gmail, Maps or wherever on Google. In relation to that it's bad enough that there is false and misleading medical content and advice floating around the internet and on social media which is very dangerous for non-medical experts. Thus, such resources should be used to promote medical content from verified sources for lots of people seeking clarity of the outbreak, since Google and others already have the reach to do this and they are indeed doing this. My point is there's a time and place for April fools jokes. This April probably isn't the wisest of times when being in a middle of a pandemic. Especially if you're running a large social network or search engine with hundreds of millions of daily users potentially consuming and sharing medical advice or content which could be misleading or unverified.