7 ms·
Markets are broken when oil usage develops towards sustainable levels? We have to drastically cut down oil use, let's not pretend that the pre-corona oil consu
by fulafel 7y ago
Markets are broken when oil usage develops towards sustainable levels?
We have to drastically cut down oil use, let's not pretend that the pre-corona oil consumption was tolerable, much less desireable.
Now would be a good opportunity make internaltional agreements to cap oil consumption and extraction to its current level in shutdown, and when the shutdown starts to get rolled back, the shock will be smaller as rising demand and price mechanisms reconcile how the remaining lower oil supply gets used.
- bamboozled 7y agoThis!!! This seems like great news to me.
- johnchristopher 7y agoFrom what I read (analysts and decision makers) that's not what's going to happen. Money is injected and more will be to salvage industries and make up the loss (by increasing production after the crisis (or before the end)). This will increase pollution and energy demands in the coming months at a higher level than before the crisis. Well, from what I've read. I am a total idiot in these matters.
- bitreality 7y agoGovernment and industry will want demand to ramp back up, but it's doubtful that will be supported by consumers. I don't think you're going to see an instant rush back to international travel. Same goes for most other industries. This isn't a situation where you just wake up one day and it's over. It's not a war where you just make up and get back to work. This virus is out there, and most experts say even if you were already infected, you will only become temporarily immune (similar to flu). So until you see a vaccine develop, coronavirus is not going away by any stretch. It will continue to cause problems in the medium term.
- Robotbeat 7y agoCitation for “most experts.” Most actual virus experts I’ve seen say the opposite: the virus is mutating slowly (at least in the spike protein, which is the part the immune system responds to) and the “reinfection” measurements are likely measuring residual virus genetic material, not necessarily true reinfection. @trvrb on Twitter. And this other guy, with this thread: https://mobile.twitter.com/PeterKolchinsky/status/1244029896453754880 https://mobile.twitter.com/PeterKolchinsky/status/1244029896... (Which doesn’t mean I disagree with your overall point that this won’t be an instant-bounceback.)
- bitreality 7y agoI'm not suggesting that people will become quickly reinfected, I'm saying that their immunity will be temporary, such as one or several "infection seasons".
- johnchristopher 7y agoI work in the travel industry (in a weird IT/social media guy position) and the consensus seems to be that people will get back to traveling but in their own country. “Public” tourism industry is going to be okay (and aren't too worry about it for better or worse) but OTA and traditional tour operators are bleeding and some will eventually die. Small local actors too but they will be replaced (or back after a year of unemployment, with loans from bailout banks).
- amelius 7y agoThese things are often counter intuitive. We should subsidize pollution and at the same time tax it. This allows us to strategically put an accounting framework in place that will allow us to later turn the knob to increase the taxes. You first have to give the corporate world a gift before you take it away. Similarly to how the corporate world treats consumers.
- digitalsushi 7y agoYou're not an idiot at all, you're just preemptively deflecting ad hominem responses. I think that it's possibly efficient because it burns one clock cycle of a respondent's thoughts, and lets them remember the human.
- mrfusion 7y agoI hate to disagree but the free market is often a great guide to tell us how much we need of something. The USSR tried telling industries how much to produce each year and we can agree that didn’t turn out well. Of course oil is a problem but a tax or cap and trade system would make more sense to address it.
- specialbat 7y agoYou can't have a free market when there is a monopolistic producer
- syshum 7y agoWho would that be?
- vikramkr 7y agoOPEC et al. Oil is a classic cartel controlled industry.
- syshum 7y agoI figured that would be the response, and the current price drops proves that the be wrong as the it is not just falling demand that is causing the price collapse, not that started long before COVID, it is a price war between 2 (of many) large suppliers, This idea that OPEC controls everything in oil is simply false
- standardUser 7y agoOil doesn't operate in a free market, not even a "mixed economy"-style regulated market. The majority of oil production is managed by a cartel.
- fulafel 7y agoIn economics there is a wide consensus that the free market is a lousy guide when it comes to incorporating externalities like accelerating climate change causing millions of unnecessary deaths vs perceived need to drive around in gas guzzlers. Taxes and cap-and-trade systems are indeed the mechanisms of how current international agreements try to attempt CO2 emissions, they're a fine way to implement it.
- csours 7y agoEven if you drive a BEV or take public transit and bike, a lot of the things you buy are delivered by fossil fueled vehicles (semi trucks). A flood is often followed by a spike in price as supplier companies fail. Price is a good way to reduce consumption, but price spikes are not.
- Robotbeat 7y agoI want to agree with you, but I don’t think people have yet realized the depth of the depression we’ll be in even when the peak has passed. We’re going to need to bounce back as much as we can, which means increased oil consumption. It might mean coal gets knocked back, however! Just saw a coal train going to the coal export terminal by my house that looked mostly empty. Already, coal is down to just 22% of US electricity as of the end of January. It’s possible it could fall below nuclear power by the end of the year.
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> Now would be a good opportunity make internaltional agreements to cap oil consumption and extraction to its current level in shutdown Really what they should do right now is take the opportunity to put in place a carbon tax. That would raise current prices back to previous prices, but it would also suppress demand even after the pandemic passes, so that the wholesale price stays low. You'd essentially have the tax getting paid by Russia and Saudi Arabia because demand would never return to a level that would absorb the supply glut.
- ogre_codes 7y agoRight now national politics is so broken and the Republicans are so against any kind of carbon tax it's impossible. Individual states could probably slip in an increase in gas taxes while gas prices are low, but it's unlikely... Who would want to be the governor seen as increasing taxes at the beginning of economic troubles? In general any kind of tax increase at the moment is going to fall flat.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoOne of the best ways to do a carbon tax is to pay the revenues back as a dividend. States aren't allowed to print money, so you could reasonably have a bunch of blue states right now say that they're going to start paying dividends to people to help them out because they have to stay home, and hey let's fund it with a gas tax -- which people don't mind nearly as much right now because they're staying home anyway. And then if it happens to still exist two years from now, it's already the status quo.
- kevin_thibedeau 7y agoThe battery taxes won't be far off.
- elamje 7y agoI think most people forget that the American oil industry is one of the largest in the world, i.e. it employs a ton of middle and upper class labor. For that reason, it makes this a political issue. For instance, just one aspect of oil that is huge in the US is Shale production, which is not profitable at the current WTI price per barrel. What does that mean? Well, hundreds of thousands of people, or more likely millions, would permanently lose their jobs in the US, which is why this is politically untenable. I think it would be incredible for the US do push towards renewables and cut oil consumption, but sometimes you have to accept the world as it is, and not how you want it to be.
- badrabbit 7y agoI disagree, the pre-corona energy usage was desirable since it was a result of healthy economic activiy. What is not desirable is how most of it was fossil fuel. To replace fossil, you need renewables to be cheaper or to compete with oil, this means oil should be used more but produces less so it costs more than renewables(which was the pre-corona trend). My opinion is, the focus should be on switching consumption to renewables one large milestone at a time. For example, diesel would be produced less and used more enough for a renewable alternative engine and fuel supply chain for cruise ships to make economic sense, then within a few years all cruise ships will be on renewable. Fossil fuel is not the enemy, fossio fuel dependency is. You can make similar economic arguments for more public electric transport for example (what people pay in tax is miniscule to what they pay for gas every year).
- redisman 7y agoThat' not what OP said. "oil consumption" not "energy consumption". But yes pretty much anyone with half a brain and no vested interested in fossil fuels agrees that fossil fuels need to be ran down ASAP and replaced with renewables. I'd imagine with optimized solar and next generation nuclear we could get a lot closer to "unrestricted" energy.
- badrabbit 7y agoYes,but maybe you missed my point, it was that "oil consumptiom" needs to go up along with oil prices before it can be taken down by renewables. That is fastest way, the slow way is to wait for disasters to keep happening and hope nations force change.