2 ms·
> It's not about achieving 100% perfect protection, it's about some protection. But it might not even be 10% or 1% protection, especially outdoors outside of a
by seanmcdirmid 7y ago
> It's not about achieving 100% perfect protection, it's about some protection.
But it might not even be 10% or 1% protection, especially outdoors outside of a sterile hospital environment. Is it worth wearing them for a some small amount of protection, or is the false sense of security they provide more dangerous than their benefit?
Surgical masks are pretty leaky compared to N95 masks we wore during crazy bad air days in Beijing, but the latter are so uncomfortable that they cause people to touch their face more, doing more harm than good in this context. That’s why all the videos we see in Asia just have crowds wearing flimsy surgical masks, I mean, they are super easy to wear, so why not, but let’s not delude ourselves into thinking they are doing much good.
- verroq 7y agoIt's not just about protection, it's also about preventing people that are sick and asymptomatic from spreading. >but the latter are so uncomfortable that they cause people to touch their face more The logic just doesn't work here, you can't touch your face if you have a mask on and N95 respirators aren't as unconformable as you claim, if anything they are often higher quality and the cheap elastic bands on surgical masks are more uncomfortable on the ears. >That’s why all the videos we see in Asia just have crowds wearing flimsy surgical masks It's because they can't get N95 masks. No one wears a mask for comfort.
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoI’ve worn many N95 masks and have constantly been touching my face to adjust them while being worn, they also irritate your skin around your face where they try to make a seal (this wasn’t even a pandemic, just a 700+ bad air day). They are super uncomfortable. Surgical masks are easy to wear in comparison, but they are also basically noops.
- verroq 7y agoSurgical masks are roughly 6 times better than nothing. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23498357 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23498357 I have also worn N95 masks and they aren't as uncomfortable as you describe.