3 ms·
Control measures are supposed to take place on an inconsistent, fragmented basis - American states have significant independent sovereignty.
by SpicyLemonZest 7y ago
Control measures are supposed to take place on an inconsistent, fragmented basis - American states have significant independent sovereignty.
- grej 7y agoAnd far different densities, demographics, levels of travel, airport accessibility, etc. As lamentable the initial response has been at the federal level, I have take some solace in seeing more local leadership successfully emerge.
- vkou 7y agoThis is a cross-state issue. Unless we close state borders, inept handling of the outbreak by one state endangers the rest.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoThere's no option available with zero danger. The question is how we want to weigh reducing the danger against compromising our values, and state sovereignty is a very important American value.
- rsynnott 7y agoWhat they don't have, though, are significant resources. A US state might have ideas on how to deal with coronavirus, but it would struggle to pay for it without significant federal aid, so would need to wait on the federal government. They're in a very different situation to, say, an EU country, where nearly all revenue goes to the member state, not the EU. As an example, Ireland and Alabama have about the same population. Alabama's revenues are about $10bn per year. Ireland's revenues are about 80bn EUR (90bn $) per year. A couple of weeks ago, Ireland announced a shutdown of everything but essential businesses, with a package of financial supports (chiefly paying minimum wage to everyone put out of work, plus supplementing up to 450 euro per week of the salaries of temporarily laid off workers where the employer continues to pay them) which will cost ~4bn over a 12 week period. In addition, it made extra resources available to the health service social services and so on which may come out costing about 3bn. And the government has signalled that this is really only the start; more billions will be required. In practice, this will be paid for in the short term by issuing debt. Alabama, by contrast, couldn't do this sort of ~full shutdown without federal support; at a cost of $8bn it would be almost its entire annual revenue, and US states have very limited means of raising debt. US states really had to wait for the federal government to move before they could take serious measures (or else risk total economic devastation).