2 ms·
It’s pretty clearly not the last judicial duel in France as the most famous such duel, that of Jarnac and Châtaigneraie (and source of the term coup de Jarnac)
by gumby 7y ago
It’s pretty clearly not the last judicial duel in France as the most famous such duel, that of Jarnac and Châtaigneraie (and source of the term coup de Jarnac) was caught in 1547 almost 200 years after the events described here, of Carrouges and Le Gris. And Châtaigneraie had evidentially been the victor in several previous judicial battles.
- vidarh 7y agoIt seems the one you described was a formal challenge without a trial, rather than court ordered after a trial?
- gumby 7y agoThe Wikipedia entry (sorry only in French) glosses the background including multiple appeals to the monarch (there was a change of king which helped) and the fight was presided over by the king. Here’s a lengthy discussion in English that describes the process of the trial with multiple appeals to the king as it was in process: http://www.thearma.org/essays/DOTC.htm http://www.thearma.org/essays/DOTC.htm Per the standards of the era it was a judicial trial. Though I have an undergraduate degree in French History I didn’t study medieval law (!) which in any case wasn’t as formal as it was today. But this was clearly not taught under the rules of private duel which would have been arranged and resolved relatively quickly.
- orwin 7y agoThis one of the last time a duel could replace a proper trial. Somehow, in case an dispute between two nobles could not be resolved in a trial (no witnesses is the first thing that came to mind), they could re-enact thes kind of trial. I think one of the last duel en France was as late as the 1960, between two french politicians, so yes, not the last.
- gumby 7y agoSee my comment to vidarh