4 ms·
My only question is: "Why hasn't the world done this two weeks ago?" The US is failing to test on a massive scale, and the outbreak has been growing exponentia
by vkou 7y ago
My only question is: "Why hasn't the world done this two weeks ago?"
The US is failing to test on a massive scale, and the outbreak has been growing exponentially, week after week. Control measures are being taken, but on an inconsistent, fragmented basis.
- grej 7y agoEvery good idea should have been done before it was done. Better late than never. At least testing has ramped up in the US considerably now. As someone in the US, I wish we would implement a lot more in the way of domestic travel restrictions right now. If we’re not willing to do that, then who can blame other countries for restricting us?
- Animats 7y agoThe SF Bay Area did. We are 12 days into lockdown here. In a week or so we will know if it worked.
- Gibbon1 7y agoA lot of bay area tech companies implemented work from home policies a week before that.
- strictnein 7y agoThe US is currently testing ~100k people each day: https://covidtracking.com/us-daily/ https://covidtracking.com/us-daily/ The failure at the beginning was not to have capacity ready. The huge US medical system and its very, very large medical industry has finally gotten pointed in the right direction in regards to testing.
- Barrin92 7y agoThe testing capacity is good now but the response to the actual pandemic is a disaster. If you have the president talk about packed churches on Easter you can soon save yourself the testing because it's going to be hard to find someone who isn't infected
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoIt's important for the president to communicate the message that lockdowns are bad and they're trying to get people out of their homes as soon as possible. I don't think anyone believes the president is actually going to pack churches on Easter if there's still a large outbreak at the time, but that'll be 4 weeks after the national stay at home initiative started, so it's pretty in line with the durations other countries have set.
- triceratops 7y ago> It's important for the president to communicate the message that lockdowns are bad Why? I think we can all figure out by ourselves that lockdowns aren't fun. The people losing their jobs don't need to be told that - they have better experience than anyone else. Leadership means communicating difficult truths and convincing people to do the right thing even when it's unpleasant.
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoIn order to effectively communicate difficult truths and convince people to do the right thing, you have to acknowledge their pain and present a plan for ending it. To just say "you have to lock down, too bad so sad" would be incredibly cruel and ineffective.
- rsynnott 7y agoSome countries have said they’ll re-evaluate around the middle of April. Generally in the sense of potentially easing very strict lockdowns of the ‘“don’t go outside your house except to the supermarket unless you’re essential personnel” variety. Nowhere else but the US is claiming that as an end date, as far as I know.
- SpicyLemonZest 7y ago
- jdkee 7y agoI was tested this past Thursday and came back negative yesterday. Two weeks ago I was exhibiting the classic symptoms. Last week I had five days of noticeable shortness of breath, lethargy, sinus infection and a dry cough. I wanted to get tested a week ago this past Monday but did not meet the criteria. Now I am awaiting the availability of serological tests to see if I have the antibodies. I pulled the kids out of school on March 10th, ahead of our local district closing on March 13, and we have been self-quarantined since then. If I had the virus, the recent testing would likely not measure me as a positive case due to low viral expression. The fact that the U.S. did not have widespread surveillance testing since mid-January is criminally inept. China bought us eight weeks of ramp-up time which was bungled by our Executive branch who was more worried about the economy and stock market reaction than people's lives. Historically, this will likely go down as the largest failure of public health management in U.S. since our founding. After this passes, there needs to be large scale accountability for the CDC, FDA and the Executive branch that has brought us to the collapse of public health which will likely cost millions of U.S. lives.
- mancerayder 7y agoTo add fuel to the fire, you could have mentioned the initial response from the executive branch: "It's basically like the flu." Over two weeks ago I was correcting people who are otherwise intelligent but "executive branch supporters" to use a potential euphemism, to get their elder parents outside of the city. One of these friends has someone close to them in the ICU on a respirator as I write this. Are they any less supporters of the executive branch? I think you already know the (depressing) answer.
- foobiekr 7y agoChina bought us eight weeks of ramp up time? Was that before or after suppressing information about the issue for almost two months including getting WHO to claim there was no evidence of human-to-human transmission in January?
- ireflect 7y agoAfter
- mancerayder 7y agoIt took a very long time to get started. Check the history using the news headlines as your timeline. The Federal government rejected non-US tests/guidelines, while the CDC worked on a test. The test didn't work. The U.S. State of Washington had a solution, but the Federal government rejected it. Meanwhile some countries were conducting tests like crazy and were able to do some initial containment. In The U.S. we continued to go to the beach (Trump country), we went to farmer's markets (DNC country), and neither U.S. political culture made any effort to involve the authority figures to force citizens to stay apart. Because Freedom. Nice job, U.S. I write this holed up in the U.S. city with the most infections and deaths at the moment.
- jdkee 7y agoStay safe. This too shall pass.
- vkou 7y ago> The US is currently testing ~100k people each day: Given how many people are still sharing their stories of "I am symptomatic, and I can't get tested, because I'm not literally dying in hospital", I daresay, we are not doing a good enough job of it.
- JohnTHaller 7y agoIt's way too late for widespread testing to stop the initial big spread. We missed that window thanks to lapses in leadership, technical mistakes, and bureaucratic nonsense. Statisticians and doctors estimate that 600,000 to 1,200,000 are already infected.
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoControl measures are supposed to take place on an inconsistent, fragmented basis - American states have significant independent sovereignty.
- grej 7y agoAnd far different densities, demographics, levels of travel, airport accessibility, etc. As lamentable the initial response has been at the federal level, I have take some solace in seeing more local leadership successfully emerge.
- vkou 7y agoThis is a cross-state issue. Unless we close state borders, inept handling of the outbreak by one state endangers the rest.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoThere's no option available with zero danger. The question is how we want to weigh reducing the danger against compromising our values, and state sovereignty is a very important American value.
- rsynnott 7y agoWhat they don't have, though, are significant resources. A US state might have ideas on how to deal with coronavirus, but it would struggle to pay for it without significant federal aid, so would need to wait on the federal government. They're in a very different situation to, say, an EU country, where nearly all revenue goes to the member state, not the EU. As an example, Ireland and Alabama have about the same population. Alabama's revenues are about $10bn per year. Ireland's revenues are about 80bn EUR (90bn $) per year. A couple of weeks ago, Ireland announced a shutdown of everything but essential businesses, with a package of financial supports (chiefly paying minimum wage to everyone put out of work, plus supplementing up to 450 euro per week of the salaries of temporarily laid off workers where the employer continues to pay them) which will cost ~4bn over a 12 week period. In addition, it made extra resources available to the health service social services and so on which may come out costing about 3bn. And the government has signalled that this is really only the start; more billions will be required. In practice, this will be paid for in the short term by issuing debt. Alabama, by contrast, couldn't do this sort of ~full shutdown without federal support; at a cost of $8bn it would be almost its entire annual revenue, and US states have very limited means of raising debt. US states really had to wait for the federal government to move before they could take serious measures (or else risk total economic devastation).