6 ms·
Some years ago, I saw a comedian mock the idea that immigrants were a threat to American jobs by joking that he had always wanted to be an underpaid farm labore
by DoreenMichele 7y ago
Some years ago, I saw a comedian mock the idea that immigrants were a threat to American jobs by joking that he had always wanted to be an underpaid farm laborer and can't make that dream work because the illegal immigrants took all those jobs.
In America, it used to be common for young men in high school and college to do construction work during the summer. Now, it's mostly immigrants.
When I was still a military wife, they changed the fitness test to be less stringent for younger members because they were having so much trouble getting qualified recruits. It really pissed my husband off because they didn't make his test any easier. He was in his thirties and was told "You've been working out for years. You are in the best shape of your life."
Developed countries are turning into nations of couch potatoes who turn their noses up at hard physical labor and probably couldn't do it if they wanted to. Or could but it would be extremely hard on them and there would be additional personal costs akin to training for a marathon.
- dragonwriter 7y ago> In America, it used to be common for young men in high school and college to do construction work during the summer. Now, it's mostly immigrants. Because college or college-bound adults are, if they are motivated enough to work in the first place, mostly focussed on work that provides a competitive advantage in college admissions and post-college careers, which trade labor mostly isn't.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoAnd because young people are less physically fit than they used to be, so they don't have the muscle and stamina required by such jobs. But the reasons why are almost irrelevant. The pertinent detail is that employers can't fill these jobs without immigrant labor. Most Americans don't want them at any pay rate.
- jopsen 7y agoAt 20 USD/hour I think you would be able to fill these jobs. But if you want to make that salary picking fruit, then we'll have to pay more for it -- or you'll need to have some automation to increase productivity. I doubt we'll want to pay more, consumers would rather buy imports instead.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoEverything I have ever read indicates that white Americans don't want farm labor jobs even if you pay $20/hour.
- jazzyk 7y agoThat's because they would never be able to afford basic things like: - college education ($30K-$75K/year, preceded by purchasing a shack for $800K in a good-school town) - health care ($25K/year for a high-deductible family plan) What's the point? Or do we consider education or healthcare luxury now?
- DoreenMichele 7y agoAmerica has long treated both education and healthcare as luxury items that only the rich deserve. We need to fix those things. They are negatively impacting quite a lot of people. The lack of healthcare is hardly peculiar to farm labor jobs.
- bluGill 7y agoIn the US school is free for 13 years. After that there are scholarships for the poor. Healthcare is expensive, but there are programs for the poor. When you move out of poor things get hard quick though because you don't get the above and so you have to come up with the prices you quote.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoWhat people want to do work that damaged their body, is subject to short term changes in demand due to weather and has high income instability, and leads to no future growth? $20/hour for temporary backbreaking work in exchange for not being near friends or family, having to move constantly, having to live in a rural area (not what most people want), having no upward income mobility. The people that do it, do it because they have no better option. Not because they want to.
- jellicle 7y agoI would suggest advertising some fruit-picking jobs at a guaranteed $50/hour to test your theory that Americans don't want them at any pay rate.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoThat's not "my theory." That's what I have read over and over for some years now.
- phenkdo 7y agoAt that pay rate, your grocery bill will rise 5x-10x and while that might not bother you, there are several people from whom that's a death knell.
- Scoundreller 7y agoNot a chance. When you're paying a couple bucks a pound for fresh ______, it didn't take 15 minutes of a migrant worker's time to plant/pick/care/pack that pound. My guess is that the migrant worker proportion of retail cost is <10%. Quadrupling their income would increase retail cost by 30%. edit: > What would happen to consumer food costs if farm wages rose and the extra costs were passed on to consumers? The average earnings of field workers were $9.78 an hour in 2008, according to a U.S. Department of Agriculture survey of farm employers, and a 40 percent increase would raise them to $13.69 an hour. If this wage increase were passed on to consumers, the 10 cent farm labor cost of a $1 pound of apples would rise to 14 cents, and the retail price would only rise to $1.04. https://www.prb.org/usfarmworkersfoodprices/ https://www.prb.org/usfarmworkersfoodprices/
- phenkdo 7y agoAgain such a naive viewpoint, in an economy everything is interconnected. If the prices of groceries rise, there are knock-on effects on everything. Yep, EVERYTHING From healthcare to housing, to transport, and whatnot will rise many-x and this bravado will evaporate in the time you took to read this post.
- banmeagaindan2 7y agoIt does not need to be most Americans and a lot of office workers would prefer to be farmers if the wage were correct. We have markets - let the prices rise and we will see more farmers in the future. E; I know it is not your theory Doreen - but it is a popular species of liberal (meaning democrat + republican) political propaganda. Everything Moravec's Paradox ever said, everything Peter Thiel ever said about automation - it's right in front of us now.
- cma 7y agoThiel also said companies shouldn’t have big cash reserves because it is a sign of running out of ideas.
- banmeagaindan2 7y agoHello Slow Ban my old friend. For growth technology firms that is true - I remember his debate with Eric Schmidt - he was really arguing being a technology firm should be a temporary award contingent on how the firm behaves instead of a title. Technologies mature into infrastructure and stop being thought of as technologies. This is part of his thesis that technology companies should be monopoly companies - and that the regulator should treat companies like Google as monopolies but the companies producing new value should be classified as different and given a honeymoon period. His pointing at a technology rust belt is evocative evidence for the position.
- cma 7y agoIt could be hard for Google to weather a downturn without cash reserves. Ad revenue could dry up substantially.
- dodobirdlord 7y agoIt would have to be quite a downturn to be a real threat. They would have to have revenue drop by more than their large profit margin and their access to debt markets.
- phatfish 7y agoNot sure how attacking "young people" as weak solves anything. It's simply what the job demands. If you are working in construction chances are you are stronger than someone sitting at a desk. Put the person sitting at the desk in the construction job for a month and I bet they build some muscle. Same as sitting the construction worker at a desk 8 hrs a day will make them physically weaker. This is the reason for the boom in gym membership in the last ~15 years.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoI'm not attacking young people as weak. It's a known trend, a trend that even the federal government implicitly acknowledged by lowering fitness standards for younger military members but not older members. Gym membership may be up because we've lost a lot of other avenues for getting some exercise. Lifestyles have changed in recent decades. Kids are much more likely to play video games instead of playing sports with neighbor kids out in the yard or street. I'm not against vide games. My kids always played a lot of them. But I also made sure they had opportunities to get some physical exercise, if only so my insomniac oldest child would sleep some and he couldn't sleep if he didn't get some physical activity in on a daily basis.
- throwaway_pdp09 7y agoI've done physical work and it's fun at first, and I do like the physicality of it, but it gets boring fast and that I object to. After getting boring it gets soul destroyingly dull. I mean, working eg. in a warehouse can make people hollow. OK, some do like it, but many I knew didn't. Most tolerated it because they had no choice. It's a very good thing for a period, as a part of growing up, but as a career, or for long periods. It's not good. There will be plenty in the fields who would have had a career as a scientist, technician, engineer, who the world is now deprived of that because they are forced financially to work in a field (in the literal sense).
- DoreenMichele 7y agoThe world at large can make it work if people are willing to do these jobs for short periods of time in their youth before moving on to other things. The world is going to die of starvation if we literally can't find anyone who will do this work at all for any amount of time at any pay rate.
- kaybe 7y agoThat basically seems to be New Zealand's (and Australia's?) mode of operation. Give the rich countries' young adults fresh out of school a work&travel visa for a year and extend it for a few months with sufficient farm work. They have fun doing new and interesting things and return to their countries with a good impression of yours. Of course that won't work if every place tries it though. I wonder how they're faring right now.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoThanks for that. I live in a small town with high unemployment and an excess of homeless people. I have fantasies of putting together an "irregular jobs/work" program to help connect locals with remote work, gig work, seasonal work, etc. My theory is that if you can find some way to connect people to "irregular jobs" who don't want (or can't reasonably do) "regular jobs," a lot of people would be willing to work who aren't working currently. When I and my sons were homeless, we tried to figure out how to find something like day labor jobs and we were mystified. I asked around on the internet and got a smidgen of feedback, but we never figured it out. I feel like something went wrong somewhere along the way and America no longer knows how to help people find work of that sort anymore. But maybe some of our social ills would improve if we found a solution to that piece of it.
- robk 7y agoI'm with you. I'm optimistic that if the market can set a fair price there's plenty of work. As someone from maybe a generation after you I'd have been happy to work in the manual labor sector if it paid better than my job at Staples but alas it paid far worse.
- neonate 7y ago> Some years ago, I saw a comedian mock the idea that immigrants were a threat to American jobs by joking that he had always wanted to be an underpaid farm laborer Oh, I heard that too, years and years ago and always wondered who it was. Somehow the internet has delivered! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6PewDctni5c#t=90 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6PewDctni5c#t=90 That's some pretty sharp comedy writing and delivery.