5 ms·
Note that the UK spends a lot less (per capita) on healthcare than Germany: (£2,989 vs £4,432 in 2017), and that funding for healthcare has generally be conside
by nicoburns 7y ago
Note that the UK spends a lot less (per capita) on healthcare than Germany: (£2,989 vs £4,432 in 2017), and that funding for healthcare has generally be considered to be insufficient over at least the last 10 years in the UK, leading to cuts in service. This may account for at least some of the difference.
Source: https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/healthandsocialcare/healthcaresystem/articles/howdoesukhealthcarespendingcomparewithothercountries/2019-08-29 https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/healthan...
- thu2111 7y agoInsufficient by what measure? You're comparing against - it appears - the second highest spender in the world. There have been no cuts in NHS service. Sometimes I think I need to assign this to a keyboard macro because it's such a frequently repeated myth. The NHS has more funding now than it's ever had, it has been explicitly protected from budget reductions when every other government department has seen massive real cuts, and just last year has been given enormous spending boosts. NHS "cuts" are a bit like the gender pay gap - they exist only when statistics are abused to meet political and ideological agendas. Or, you could equally ask why Germany and the USA seem to spend so much on healthcare. After all the UK spends about average for the OECD. And the USA spends the most of all by far so it should barely notice COVID-19 compared to other countries? I guess we'll see.
- elyobo 7y agoI can't find stats to back this up either way; funding seems to have grown in real terms over time, but I can't see real funding per capita which is probably the more relevant factor.
- pmyteh 7y agoIt has grown in real terms, but not as fast as either demand or costs. Healthcare inflation is very high, and greatly outpaces the CPI index that we use for 'real-terms' comparisons. Basically, the same funding in 'real-terms' doesn't buy you the same level of care as last year in any country. Plus Britain is getting somewhat older, and somewhat sicker (partly because of medical advances meaning that previously-fatal conditions are now chronic and need ongoing treatment). And we can treat more now, so there is more demand. Bluntly, the proportion of GDP which needs to be allocated to healthcare to maintain a good quality service is rising unsustainably in all countries. The NHS is beating CPI inflation (and in doing so doing way better than other parts of government: local government has seen >25% real terms cuts, which has trashed the social care system amongst other things) but not nearly enough to keep up.
- rkangel 7y agoNHS spending has not dropped, but it has not grown at the appropriate rate. There are various discussions that we could have about nursing numbers and junior doctor hours, but instead I'd like to provide one hard data point: Addenbrookes Hospital in Cambridge (technically Addenbrookes Hospital Trust, comprised of several hospitals on one site) is the largest hospital in the UK. For the tax year 2019/2020, the available budget for capital expenditure (building, large equipment like MRIs etc.) was £0. (accurate prior to Covid-19) Occasionally as a result of political manoeuvering (General Election campaigning) pots of money for very narrow purposes with a limited time window on them appeared, but in general things like ward refurbishments have been funded by charitable donations. Most worthwhile capital investments take more than a year, so a predictable capital budget is necessary to implement programs. Having no money for CapEx is not how you maintain a health service long term.
- Zenst 7y agoYeah, let's look at where hospital money goes: https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/hospital-bosses-face-1million-bill-10413015 https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/hospital-bosses-face-1...
- Zenst 7y agoSorry for those who don't like facts that go against their political agendas :(
- thu2111 7y agoNHS spending has not dropped, but it has not grown at the appropriate rate Yes, this is how such threads always go. It's a simple three step process: 1. Someone claims the NHS funding has been cut 2. I point out that's a lie, no such cuts have ever happened and in fact the budget has always gone up 3. Somebody else replies with: but it should have grown even faster. The point I'm making is not about the correct level of healthcare spending, which is arbitrary and values-based as healthcare systems will consume however much money is given to them. Rather the persistent level of outright lying that accompanies any discussion of the NHS in Britain. It's absurd and quite obviously linked to a belief that misleading people is fine if it's for a 'good cause'. But this behaviour has to stop. It isn't OK to lie even if the outcome might appear to be desirable (more political pressure for higher healthcare spending). People learn that they're being manipulated and support for the desired cause can collapse. Having no money for CapEx is not how you maintain a health service long term. I'll repeat this until I'm blue in the face. The NHS has more money now than it's ever had. Not only does the NHS have money for capex but it's been repeatedly allocated money specifically and only for capex, because NHS managers have a long history of preferring to divert spending on upgrades to other forms of spending - frequently salary increases. It's bad management. The government attempts to combat this lack of forward thinking by earmarking of money specifically for upgrades (what you criticise here as "pots of money for very narrow purposes"). One of the first things Boris Johnson did is allocate a billion pounds to the NHS only for capex. Unfortunately it doesn't work: https://www.hsj.co.uk/technology-and-innovation/exclusive-quarter-of-a-billion-marked-for-nhs-tech-goes-unspent/7021476.article https://www.hsj.co.uk/technology-and-innovation/exclusive-qu... "Capital spending was particularly tight with only £150.3m spent from £354.1m of allocated funding ... funding to help NHS trusts to become more digitally advanced accounted for most of this capital underspend. The DH planned to spend £116.2m of capital on these trusts in 2016-17 – instead it spent nothing." The idea the NHS doesn't have money for capex is just another piece of misdirection. It refuses to spend on upgrades even when central government is trying to force its hand, because it knows that the result is No 10 will blink and give up, which is what happens: "The money was not allocated elsewhere but “as with all Department underspends, was available to offset pressures in other parts of the system”, she said."
- peteretep 7y ago> Note that the UK spends a lot less (per capita) on healthcare than Germany: (£2,989 vs £4,432 in 2017) If Germany have provisioned 5 times more ICU beds than they generally need, I can see why their costs might be higher
- Zenst 7y agoMaybe that they count them as beds and have more that can cater for ICU than others. However, let's not forget historical factors and was case of many countries having armies in Germany for legacy war reasons and that may well of seen the mentalities to have a higher number of such beds than most places.
- mapgrep 7y agoI am not an expert here but it seems dangerous to assume as you do that the baseline of “correct number of ventilators” is the UK number. They could be... -Under provisioning for surges (not even Covid, even just a sudden emergency of another sort, a bad flu season, big accident, terror event, whatever) -Going longer between maintenance intervals than is recommended -Delaying ICU admission longer than is strictly recommended -Relocating ICU equipment as needed more than other countries feel comfortable doing -Using more reliable ICU equipment (does the German figure include any older and potentially less reliable gear in the former communist east?) -Have less need among population for ICU On the last point, Germany has accepted by far more refugees from MENA war zones than any other European country and I would not be surprised if this resulted in higher emergency medicine use. Also a quick Google shows Germany is a bit older with 22% of the population over 65 vs 18% in UK. None of this is to say Germany isn’t over provisioned but it is probably not 5X over provisioned, if it is.
- threatofrain 7y agoAt some point under-provisioning is no longer an efficiency miss but a national security issue of how clogged your infrastructure gets during stress.