5 ms·
A Woman in Black: The last judicial duel in France
- mytailorisrich 7y agoAnd the last recorded duel in France dates back to 1967, between two MPs/Representatives. One had insulted the other in the House.
- joecool1029 7y agoThe duel was not to the death and was filmed. According to this source it was a mayor that was insulted: http://www.tameshigiri.ca/2014/03/27/last-epee-duel-in-france-1967-recorded-on-film/ http://www.tameshigiri.ca/2014/03/27/last-epee-duel-in-franc...
- mytailorisrich 7y agoYes, he was mayor and MP (quite common in France).
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoThis story goes to pains to explain how the actual events might have unfolded. But in France at the time, I cannot imagine that mattered one whit. What mattered was, who had who's favor in court, who had leverage upon the judges, and who paid more or less for advantages. To discuss this woman's claims at this date is silly. Its not about that at all.
- pyuser583 7y agoThe author was pretty clear about the role of favoritism: it strongly influenced the initial judges, but became less important during the appeals. “But when he returned a few days later and heard his wife’s story, he angrily brought charges against Le Gris in the court of Count Pierre of Alençon, overlord to both men. Le Gris was the count’s favorite and his administrative right hand. A large and powerful man, Le Gris was well educated and very wealthy, though from an only recently ennobled family. He also had a reputation as a seducer—or worse. But the count, infuriated by the accusation against his favorite, declared at a legal hearing that Marguerite “must have dreamed it” and summarily dismissed the charges, ordering that “no further questions ever be raised about it.” “Carrouges, without whom his wife could not even bring a case, resolutely rode off to Paris to appeal for justice to the king.” It also doesn’t explain why the parlement decided “we have no idea.”
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoThey couldn't decide without offending one of two powerful men. So they didn't decide. I don't see how that quote advances the case at all. It illustrates my point exactly, then with the brief 'appeal for justice to the king'. Why does anyone imagine that went any differently? It didn't. They wanted to see blood sport, so they decided that way - as the huge crowd confirms, it was a popular decision, not a just one.
- ellyagg 7y agoReminds me of the Sacco and Vanzetti case, which I learned as a kid was an unambiguous miscarriage of justice and xenophobia. It's perhaps not well known, but there's pretty good reason to think they were guilty all along: https://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=5245754 https://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=524575... ...but generally people feel when stories catalyze social progress that's more important than the details. I think about this a lot, and how it applies to stories we tell in every aspect of life, from personal to business to policy. I'm not sure how I feel about it.
- pjc50 7y agoThis is making me think of the OJ case, where although he actually did it (as found in the subsequent civil suit), at the time it was obvious to everyone that he was being lazily framed and the post-Rodney King LAPD was still profoundly racist. Then there's the Lockerbie case, which was weird on a whole number of levels; I can believe it was carried out by Libya but the actual evidence is unconvincing.
- thaumaturgy 7y agoWe remember the circumstances of the OJ case at the time somewhat differently. LAPD were still in the news for the Rodney King riots when the OJ Simpson trial kicked off. There were some pretty damning recordings of the lead detective (Fuhrman; had to look it up) with a lot of racist content and talk of planting evidence. But opinions of the case, by my recollection, fell along predictable racial and political lines. There were an awful lot of people that were certain from the beginning that he was guilty, and they had among their spokespeople Rush Limbaugh, who started practicing talking out of both sides of his mouth right around then by refusing to talk directly about the OJ case but instead spending a lot of air time on the "cultural differences" between white people and black people. I remember it somewhat distinctly because, unfortunately, both my dad and his dad were listeners of that show and that was about the time I first realized that they were a little bit racist.
- pieterhg 7y ago
- kerakaali 7y agoI came in expecting a quick skim but was captivated by the narrative until the end. A truly fantastic bit of writing. Thanks for the share.
- ink_13 7y ago> Louvel’s naming of Le Gris just prior to the squire’s own arrival would seem to put Le Gris indisputably there—unless Marguerite’s story was a deliberate fabrication. There's a third option: a framing of Le Gris by Louvel. The attacker wasn't Le Gris, he just sort of looked like him, and after the assault, disappears. Both Le Gris and Marguerite are telling the truth.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoThat seems pretty far fetched.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoSome of the themes here continue to be true to this day. Women get accused of lying or making up the assault and it's dangerous to them to even report the rape. A man's reputation is often deemed to be more important than a woman's actual welfare. Male careers are founded upon reputation. They don't want it besmirched by insinuations or ugly truths and will happily do yet worse things to silence such. Often, a woman has no real power to seek justice in the world. To this day, justice all too often hinges on her having a de facto male champion. The community at large often tries to sweep sexual scandal under the rug, often very much at some woman's expense, especially if the man in question is "a pillar of the community" type. You will note Le Gris was a squire. In other words, he was (as I understand it) a young nobleman, not a peasant. His reputation, future and career mattered. We no longer duel to the death, but we still don't seem to have good solutions for a lot of the issues that swirl around such a case. Excellent read overall, but perhaps an uncomfortable read for a lot of women who have, themselves, been raped or sexually harassed by a man in a position of power, etc.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- gumby 7y agoIt’s pretty clearly not the last judicial duel in France as the most famous such duel, that of Jarnac and Châtaigneraie (and source of the term coup de Jarnac) was caught in 1547 almost 200 years after the events described here, of Carrouges and Le Gris. And Châtaigneraie had evidentially been the victor in several previous judicial battles.
- vidarh 7y agoIt seems the one you described was a formal challenge without a trial, rather than court ordered after a trial?
- gumby 7y agoThe Wikipedia entry (sorry only in French) glosses the background including multiple appeals to the monarch (there was a change of king which helped) and the fight was presided over by the king. Here’s a lengthy discussion in English that describes the process of the trial with multiple appeals to the king as it was in process: http://www.thearma.org/essays/DOTC.htm http://www.thearma.org/essays/DOTC.htm Per the standards of the era it was a judicial trial. Though I have an undergraduate degree in French History I didn’t study medieval law (!) which in any case wasn’t as formal as it was today. But this was clearly not taught under the rules of private duel which would have been arranged and resolved relatively quickly.
- orwin 7y agoThis one of the last time a duel could replace a proper trial. Somehow, in case an dispute between two nobles could not be resolved in a trial (no witnesses is the first thing that came to mind), they could re-enact thes kind of trial. I think one of the last duel en France was as late as the 1960, between two french politicians, so yes, not the last.
- gumby 7y agoSee my comment to vidarh
- tlear 7y agoSo what happened to Louvel? From article it seems he was tortured to verify his testimony? Never confessed, I am guessing executed later?
- BXLE_1-1-BitIs1 7y agoThe Last Duel by Eric Jager covers this story and is sympathetic to the lady's side. An interesting book.
- laughinghan 7y agoEric Jager is also the author of this article.