9 ms·
I'm not sure exactly what those quotes are referring to, but many reports of European settlers to the New World, while technically true, were greatly misleading
by crazygringo 7y ago
I'm not sure exactly what those quotes are referring to, but many reports of European settlers to the New World, while technically true, were greatly misleading.
Prior to arrival of the Europeans, the continent was full of Native Americans who lived in an ecological balance with wildlife.
When the Europeans arrived, the diseases they brought wiped out 90+% of the indigenous population, according to some estimates. By the time they explored the continent, the population was mainly gone, far in advance.
So there's a strong theory that the incredible over-abundance of wildlife the Europeans saw was actually a huge ecological imbalance, as many animals had lost their natural (human) predators.
And that phenomena such as millions of passenger pigeons blocking out the sun overhead weren't "natural" at all, but actually severe ecological imbalance.
(This isn't to say, of course, that now we haven't swung way too far in the other direction. But just that the tales of abundance aren't necessarily a naturally balanced state either.)
- nroets 7y agoNative Americans arrived less than 80,000 years ago. That's a blink of an eye in evolutionary terms. They were not the natural predators.
- bryanrasmussen 7y agoI think the phrase natural predator just means the predator in the environment that keeps some other species in check. 80,000 years may be a blink in an eye in evolutionary terms but it does not take that long for a predator to come into an environment and become entrenched as the natural check on some other species. I would say https://science.sciencemag.org/content/314/5802/1111 https://science.sciencemag.org/content/314/5802/1111 for example of introduction of species something like this https://www.journals.uchicago.edu/doi/abs/10.1086/285705 https://www.journals.uchicago.edu/doi/abs/10.1086/285705 for how dominance of predator works. However not sure how well the Native Americans were actually keeping animals in check given the many species they have been shown to have helped bring to extinction. That said not sure how long it would take from being a natural predator to being a keystone species.
- cutemonster 7y ago@nroets, Humans (the Europeans in this case) made the Dodo bird extinct quite fast, closer to 80 years than 80 000. One doesn't need to be someone's long time natural predator to have an impact
- mwaitjmp 7y agoI believe the accepted period is around 15,000 years ago, possibly slightly earlier.
- netcan 7y agoThose dates are in flux recently. As is the pattern in discoveries of our very ancient history... the story gets more complicated as we go. The fallacy that, IMO, we are falling into is (ironically) caused by scientific reductionism... the simplest explanation is probably the correct one. This doesn't work as well for the evidence types paleoanthropology has to work with.
- toasterlovin 7y agoWith the advent of ancient DNA, we now have a second, relatively precise type of evidence also pointing at, IIRC, 15-20k years ago as when the initial peopling of the Americas took place.
- netcan 7y agoInitial peopling, or oldest known genetic ancestors of current individuals. Take Israel or Morocco as a comparative example. There were sapiens there before Neanderthals, but they are not thought to be ancestral to any modern people. The majority are not. This makes intuitive sense when thinking of species or subspecies (eg Neanderthals), but it works the same with populations. Also, it's easy to think of ourselves in permanent "infinite growth" mide, where we colonise and dominate. But, recent years aside, humans bloomed and receded just like other species. Range expanding and contracting. Just because a population is in the same place does not mean that it's ancestral. The first, second or eighteenth population may have no current ancestors... or none in that area. As Dawkins puts it "descendants are common, ancestors are rare."
- Eric_WVGG 7y agoperhaps I’m misunderstanding you, but humans are believed to have hunted many, many animals to extinction on the American content millennia before the Europeans got here. https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2001/06/010608081621.htm https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2001/06/010608081621.h...
- orbital-decay 7y ago> the continent was full of Native Americans who lived in an ecological balance with wildlife Native Americans weren't a monolithic group, and the balance with wildlife is just a part of the noble savage myth, for most of the groups. Maya, Toltec, and Aztec societies deforested Central America quite significantly before collapsing (and before Columbus).
- fit2rule 7y ago>noble savage myth Closet racism. There is far more evidence that Europeans destroyed these cultures and ignored their advances, than there is proving this so-called myth. See for example, the Australian FNP. They were far, far more advanced than European propagandists could allow anyone to imagine. We are STILL uncovering major advances in these cultures today.
- pinkfoot 7y ago> … the Australian FNP. They were far, far more advanced than European propagandists could allow anyone to imagine. Other thank some claims about land management and herbal medicine, what were that not only more advanced in but FAR more advanced? Ship building, metallurgy, literature, maths, chemistry, conflict management, law? I am genuinely curious.
- pinkfoot 7y agoSurely its easier to tell us all what the advancements were than downvote me? I am genuinely curious. [after all propagandists have prevented me from imagining, let alone knowing.]
- dang 7y agoPlease don't break the site guidelines like this. Flamewar dross and empty complaints about downvoting are both off topic here. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- 7y ago
- netcan 7y agoIt's possible that there was a temporary bloom in bison and/or a few other species during the formative period of American inland exploration. The populations were hunted out so quick after this that it's hard to know how temporary this was.. if it happened at all. But those quotes are about a lot more than one iconic species. Overall, the picture is accurate.
- 9q9 7y agoNative Americans who lived in an ecological balance with wildlife. One of the competing explanations for the disappearance of the woolly mammoth in North America about 10k years ago is that they were hunted to extinction. Other explanations make hunting a co-factor.