4 ms·
It doesn't have to be a disaster to extend the lock down (aka some restrictions). Remote work exists. Contactless food delivery exists. Homeschooling is easier
by DoreenMichele 7y ago
It doesn't have to be a disaster to extend the lock down (aka some restrictions). Remote work exists. Contactless food delivery exists. Homeschooling is easier than ever.
We just need to focus on helping people make those transitions. We need to stop focusing on "just say no" and start focusing on "You can say yes to these things. We can help you make that choice."
- bagacrap 7y agothis is a very white-collar centric view of the world. Anyone who's living paycheck to paycheck in an hourly job, or a small business owner, is unlikely to be able to work from home. And how do you work from home and homeschool at the same time? Anyway, even if you personally can get by, there will be mass failures to make rent in both commercial and residential sectors which will destroy financial markets and that will actually affect you even if you have a cool tech job in SF.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoI have known people who homeschooled to make life easier. I was one of them. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22681334 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22681334 Takeout is allowed. Food delivery is allowed. Amazon and grocery stores are hiring. Those are not white collar jobs. I've been dirt poor for years. I do remote work. I'm a freelance writer, not a programmer. It helped me establish an income and pay down debt while homeless. If you think remote work is only for the privileged few, that's your bias showing, not mine. I have been promoting remote work and gig work as a solution for homeless people for years. I run several websites and a few reddits supporting that model. I've never gotten traction. Maybe I will never get traction. But I've absolutely done all of the above and not because I have some privileged upper class life. Quite the opposite. I've done it to accommodate my health problems and the needs of two special needs kids.
- dtnewman 7y agoThere's a limit to how many people can work remotely. Certainly, factory workers, restaurant employees, healthcare professionals, retail workers and bank tellers can't do this. And homeschooling isn't for everyone... But it's virtually impossible to do if both parents are working full time. Not to mention the effect this has on children. It's very difficult for children to be socially isolated. It's good for their mental health to be around other kids.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoAh, the socialization argument. Such an old saw. It was openly mocked and derided on homeschooling lists when I was a homeschooling parent. That was before the argument was "We absolutely need to risk the lives of people in the face of a plague. Think of the social needs of the children!" Edit in response to your deleted comment: Particularly, socialization research confirms that young people can grow up more mature and poised than their age-peers if they avoid the age segregation characteristic of almost all schools. https://learninfreedom.org/ https://learninfreedom.org/ The author was a school teacher and he's the founder of some education organization or other. You can probably find a lot more info under his hn handle of tokenadult. I don't plan to continue this argument.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- swiley 7y agoAs a homeschooler who grew up in a very rural area and didn’t attend a co-op I feel like I missed out on a lot of things socially. It’s not really economically impacting but not everything is about making money. I think I made up for it in college but not everyone gets to do that, and it took a lot of effort on my part.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoNone of us gets to go back in time and run the simulation over and see how it would have gone had we taken the other path somehow. You are romanticizing public school and assuming it would be have been a wonderful social experience that you missed out on. Perhaps it would have been a terrible experience. Perhaps you would been horribly bullied. Most people do not seem to look back on k-12 and miss it terribly as the most wonderful time in their life. They usually found it wanting, at best, or even quite awful. Please don't conflate positive college social experiences with positive K-12 experiences. College students are generally legal adults who have, to some degree, chosen the school in question, chosen their major, chosen their classes and can very much choose their social activities. In contrast, K-12 kids are usually thrown together against their will, have very little real choice, etc.
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoYes, it has to be a disaster to extend the lockdown. You're severely underestimating how unhappy many people are to be locked down. If it starts stretching into 3 or 4 months, I and a lot of other people are going to just refuse to comply.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoI have an incurable medical condition. I've lived with a lot of restrictions for a long time. I feel my life is a great deal fuller than it used to be. It's vastly better to not be miserably sick and in pain all the time. I have more energy for other things. I have a better quality of life. That's why I am saying we need to emphasize what activities are possible. I'm not trying to keep people imprisoned in their own homes. I'm trying to tell you this doesn't have to be pure misery with no income, etc. I'm sorry you are having a hard time adapting. It's been a hard road for me for a long time. I just think this emphasis on "a return to normal" is misguided. I think we don't have to choose between having germ control and having a life. I think we can have both. I feel I do.
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoTrying to return to complete normality is misguided, certainly. Nightclubs and stadiums will likely stay closed for a while, and schools aren't realistically going to start back up until the fall; all of that will suck, but I'm confident we can adapt. The current set of lockdown restrictions ban me from hanging out with my friends or visiting my parents. I reject your kindness and flatly refuse to adapt to that. After some number of weeks, which I haven't quite nailed down but is certainly not in the double digits, I'll happily organize a riot at city hall if that's what it takes to hug my mom again.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoI'm not personally asking you to not hug your mom. Have a nice evening. Or whatever time of day for your time zone.