7 ms·
> The longer we're locked down, the longer it's going to take for the economy to recover. The economy would take a serious hit if suddenly millions of people o
by heavyset_go 7y ago
> The longer we're locked down, the longer it's going to take for the economy to recover.
The economy would take a serious hit if suddenly millions of people overwhelm the medical system, people collapse in the streets and bodies pile up in and outside of morgues.
There's a weird false dichotomy I keep encountering where people insinuate that we either quarantine and hurt the economy, or we don't quarantine because of the damage it would do to the economy. The economy is going to take a hit no matter what.
- refurb 7y agoSure, but the longer the lockdown, the worse it is for the economy. And it's economy that pays for healthcare, food, housing, etc. It's not an ideal situation when we eradicate the virus but have millions of people jobless and homeless in the US.
- viklove 7y agoI'm not sure I understand the "bad for the economy" side of things. Who will suffer if we shut down unessential businesses and just mail people checks? We'll still be able to eat, we'll still have roofs over our heads, etc. The only ones who will really see their lives change significantly are the ultra-rich, who need us riding around in Ubers, renting Airbnbs, and buying plane tickets so they can fund their wealthy lifestyles. Who gives a shit about them? The average American is affected less by a quarantine than an unchecked pandemic. The only reason this is even a discussion is because our political system has been completely bought out to serve only the wealthy.
- tathougies 7y ago> Who will suffer if we shut down unessential businesses and just mail people checks? We'll still be able to eat, we'll still have roofs over our heads, etc. The only ones who will really see their lives change significantly are the ultra-rich, who need us riding around in Ubers, renting Airbnbs, and buying plane tickets so they can fund their wealthy lifestyles. Why do you think this to be the case? The ultra-rich don't need you around to do whatever they want. They have their islands and personal staff to attend to them. When the government bails you out and gives you money, you slowly by slowly become unable to eat, unable to have roofs over your head. Food does not magically appear in a grocery store. Food has a global supply chain that requires your currency to have value. When the government prints money, it makes it harder for it to borrow money in the future. Eventually, your dollar buys less on the global markets, meaning farmers cannot acquire fertilizer and other needed things to grow your crops. We won't be able to hire labor to pick the crops. People will lose their jobs as exports dry up and American dollars buy less and less foreign currency. Eventually, farmers raise their prices to combat all these forces, and the government must print more money. This is just food on the table. Construction materials and workers to put a roof on your head require an even larger, international supply chain. In order to combat this, the government reduces welfare programs and increases taxes. Business and 'the rich' leave for greener pastures. Frankly, inflation kills, and I don't understand why everyone is so dismissive of this. I'm not even touching inflation's effects on doctors ability to do medicine.
- omegaworks 7y ago>Food has a global supply chain that requires your currency to have value. Not true for all food. > When the government prints money, it makes it harder for it to borrow money in the future. What causes it to be harder to borrow is the faith of people willing to hold government debt. The American government has never reneged on its debt. "Printing money" has very little to do with the government's ability to borrow. >Eventually, your dollar buys less on the global markets, meaning farmers cannot acquire fertilizer and other needed things to grow your crops. We produce these things locally. Every nation-state with a half-decent national security apparatus does. >People will lose their jobs as exports dry up and American dollars buy less and less foreign currency. This is one of the most glaring cognitive dissonances in this thought process. Currency is relative. When the American dollar is strong, it means foreign currency buys fewer tangible American goods, and we actually export less. When the American dollar is weak, foreign currency goes farther and we export more. >When the government bails you out and gives you money, you slowly by slowly become unable to eat, unable to have roofs over your head. As Alan Greenspan put it when Paul Ryan brought this fanciful line of thinking up in Congress: inflation happens when there are too many dollars chasing too few goods. There are two sides to this equation. Given the difficulty the Fed has had meeting inflation targets, it is far more likely we are constrained by the allocation of dollars either because we are not able to get them where they need to be in the economy, or because there's just too little circulating.
- tathougies 7y agoAmerica needs phosphate and imports it currently. We cannot produce enough locally. This is needed to produce enough food. I'm not sure how you get around this in your magical world. > What causes it to be harder to borrow is the faith of people willing to hold government debt. The American government has never reneged on its debt. "Printing money" has very little to do with the government's ability to borrow. Yeah, making up money and having people sit at home (thus not paying taxes) is really going to inspire people to hold American debt!
- omegaworks 7y ago
- bkruse 7y agoThis is entirely incorrect The ultra-rich will have a variable level of "decreased performance in their portfolio". They're still rich, especially if not over-levered. They are also well positioned to take advantage of any hyper-inflation event. The average american, with the loss of their primary income and no real UBI is going to feel it the most.
- vkou 7y agoFor the USD to hyperinflate, we would have to print quadrillions and quintillions of dollars. Hyperinflation is about as real a threat as Bigfoot, or little green men from mars.
- pengaru 7y ago> The only ones who will really see their lives change significantly are the ultra-rich, who need us riding around in Ubers, renting Airbnbs, and buying plane tickets so they can fund their wealthy lifestyles. [citation needed]
- heavyset_go 7y agoThe wealthy's assets require hired labor to keep and increase their value. Their wealth is derived from those assets.
- tathougies 7y agoThere's lots of hired labor around the world, no one needs to live in the united states. That is not actually a requirement to be rich.
- pengaru 7y agoIn a world where people's identities have become hopelessly conflated with their occupation, preventing them from working for a prolonged period would seem like a pretty major change to their lives. I'm talking about working-class folks here, not the ultra-rich. Life isn't just about having money to buy food.
- a_tractor 7y ago>I'm not sure I understand the "bad for the economy" side of things Rest assured, you don't. What about the people driving the Ubers, or the middle-class property owners who have come to depend on the income they receive from their extra room via Airbnb, or the stewards, pilots, and all the other airport employees, all whom depend on "us" riding, renting, flying, and buying... Not to fund anything close to a wealthy lifestyle, but likely their basic living expenses. Their many more of them than the people at the top its almost as if the so-called "ultra-rich" are completely irrelevant. >Who gives a shit about them? I almost can't believe you think this way.
- hodgesrm 7y agoAlso, there are other solutions like serological testing, aggressively developing ways to manage the illness, testing vaccines, etc. It's not just quarantines, folks It's almost as if the US government does not have a coherent plan. /s
- tathougies 7y agoThe FDA has started vaccine tests?
- slenk 7y ago14-month trials.
- heavyset_go 7y ago> Also, there are other solutions like serological testing, aggressively developing ways to manage the illness, testing vaccines, etc. It's not just quarantines, folks Unless we want to completely overwhelm the medical system within the next couple of weeks and potentially have over a million people drop dead from infection or lack of adequate healthcare, quarantine is the one tool we have at our disposal right now to manage this pandemic.
- selimthegrim 7y agoIs the UK really going to have serological testing up and running that quickly?
- jandrese 7y agoThere are people arguing that it would be better to stop the quarantine now and get it over as quick as possible. Everybody over retirement age would be refused treatment to reduce the long term burden on the social security system. Fortunately there isn't much serious discussion of this approach outside of certain think tanks because the optics are bad even for true died in the wool libertarians. You'll even see arguments like "more people will die of the quarantine because they have no job if we keep the economy stopped for much longer". IMHO this kind of one sided thinking comes from only considering the markets when making a decision. The markets don't care if you live or die, only that money is being made and spent.
- heavyset_go 7y ago> You'll even see arguments like "more people will die of the quarantine because they have no job if we keep the economy stopped for much longer". There are a few of these arguments in this thread, even.
- stallmanite 7y agoA plan to refuse treatment to everyone over retirement age has a lot of problems but one of them is that there are a fair number of really tough, armed, and knowledgeable old people out there. I doubt they’d just surrender without a fight.
- foogazi 7y ago> A plan to refuse treatment to everyone over retirement age has a lot of problems but one of them is that there are a fair number of really tough, armed, and knowledgeable old people out there. Are they armed with a vaccine ? Otherwise how would being armed help?
- DoreenMichele 7y agoIf you sentence everyone over a certain age to death, some of them are likely to decide they have nothing to lose. They may not be able to compel anyone to treat them, but they can take a few doctors with them out of spite to make sure the rest of us are as screwed as they are.
- Barrin92 7y agoforget the economy. Imagine the practical consequences of letting the virus run wild in the population. The deaths are not an abstract number. It would mean northern Italy in every city. Doctors overwhelmed, patients suffocating on hospital floors. So many corpses you actually have to transport them away on army trucks. That's where Lombardy is right now. It's a joke to even think society and the economy would go on as normal even if you would ignore the health impact, it would destroy the reputation and fabric of pretty much any modern state.
- jpindar 7y agoNew York hospitals have already had to bring in refrigerated trailers to store the bodies.
- m0zg 7y agoEvery single news outlet is showing _the same_ hospital, and the same empty trailer. Notice also what an eye trained for bullshit sees in the video: rows of ventilators that aren't even plugged in, "easy" patients with oxygen cannulas and face masks ("hard" ones would be intubated, sedated, lying prone, and they would be immobilized), empty beds here and there. All the while the narrative is "we're piling up the bodies over here". 13 deaths for a large hospital _do not_ require a mobile crematorium or a trailer refrigerator. At best, you're seeing selection bias. At worst, you're being deliberately lied to, to drive clicks
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoAt double worst, you're being deliberately lied to because the media believe, truly and honestly, that it's their job to manipulate you into believing socially useful things.
- m0zg 7y agoYeah I'm sure they consider blind, raging panic they're trying their hardest to stoke to be "socially useful" somehow.
- m0zg 7y agoThe guy who predicted millions of deaths in the US is walking back his study as we speak: https://www.newscientist.com/article/2238578-uk-has-enough-intensive-care-units-for-coronavirus-expert-predicts/ https://www.newscientist.com/article/2238578-uk-has-enough-i.... Dr Birx mentioned the study in today's presser and said the task force is working on the mass serological test to determine the rate of latent, asymptomatic infection. There won't be "millions of deaths", no matter how much CNN would like you to believe otherwise. There will, however, be a few tens of thousands of deaths, and the public needs to be prepared for that. And it's currently not prepared at all.
- heavyset_go 7y agoThere is no "the guy", there are only people who understand statistics. If this coronavirus has a similar disease burden as the flu, more than a million people will die, even if we assume that everyone that needs care gets adequate care. Should the healthcare system become overwhelmed, people that need care won't get it, and even more people will die. Should this coronavirus have a higher disease burden than the flu, which the data shows is very possible, even more people will die. I have never watched CNN in my life.
- m0zg 7y agoRead the article.
- heavyset_go 7y agoI did. I am in the US. You should read the tweets from "the guy"[1] that clarifies his statements, and how they're being misinterpreted[2] by people like yourself: > I think it would be helpful if I cleared up some confusion that has emerged in recent days. Some have interpreted my evidence to a UK parliamentary committee as indicating we have substantially revised our assessments of the potential mortality impact of COVID-19. > This is not the case. Indeed, if anything, our latest estimates suggest that the virus is slightly more transmissible than we previously thought. Our lethality estimates remain unchanged. > My evidence to Parliament referred to the deaths we assess might occur in the UK in the presence of the very intensive social distancing and other public health interventions now in place. > Without those controls, our assessment remains that the UK would see the scale of deaths reported in our study (namely, up to approximately 500 thousand). [1] https://twitter.com/neil_ferguson/status/1243294815200124928 https://twitter.com/neil_ferguson/status/1243294815200124928 [2] https://www.nationalreview.com/corner/coronavirus-pandemic-neil-ferguson-did-not-walk-back-covid-19-predictions/ https://www.nationalreview.com/corner/coronavirus-pandemic-n...
- sershe 7y agoWhat was the hit to the economy from Spanish Flu, that also mostly killed the young? What is the specific serious hit to the real economy that you expect, other that short-term, from "bodies piling up"? Sure, I agree it's terrible, but the claim about the economy is what's weird.