4 ms·
> Keep the lockdown too long and the impact to the economy will only get worse, requiring massive gov't bailouts/support. The longer we're locked down, the lon
by Wowfunhappy 7y ago
> Keep the lockdown too long and the impact to the economy will only get worse, requiring massive gov't bailouts/support. The longer we're locked down, the longer it's going to take for the economy to recover.
It's bad for the economy if a million more people than necessary die because our healthcare system was overwhelmed.
Yes, the economy is going to suffer no matter what we do. But ending the lockdown too early will make the situation worse, not better.
- gameswithgo 7y agoit would...only... be about one million
- refurb 7y agoIt's bad either way - keeping the lockdown in place for too long or relaxing it too early. The goal is to find the right balance - the least worst option.
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoSure, okay, but I think it's pretty darn clear that we're far away from needing to consider that. When the number of new cases starts going down we can begin having this conversation.
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoWhy would we wait to begin having the conversation?
- tonyedgecombe 7y agoBecause if you start talking about it too early then people will change their behaviour too early.
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoBecause we don't have enough information yet. We still don't really know how deadly this virus is, or how it spreads or mutates.
- beebmam 7y agoMore importantly than anything else: it is profoundly unethical. Are people really okay with abandoning millions of our most vulnerable people to death, abandoning millions more to complications from this illness, just to save some abstract notion of "the economy"? I flatly reject that reality, and everyone should too. Not only do the vulnerable members of our society deserve to be treated humanely, so do our nurses and other medical workers, these genuine heroes, who are subjecting themselves to this illness to reduce other people's suffering. And yes, the economy will suffer no matter what we do, like you mention. But even if it didn't, it is still profoundly unethical. Arguably on the level of genocide.
- H8crilA 7y agoThis recent month is like a nightmare where you realize just how bad it is, but slowly. So many people would actually throw (someone else's) grandpa under a bus for a profit; it's just that they haven't had a chance yet to do it. And now we have it. This begs an interesting question, the paradox of tolerance on steroids: is it ethical to murder people that put profits over the lives of their neighbors?
- foobarian 7y agoI find there is an uncomfortable blurry line in the sand here where it is somehow OK to let the flu kill tens of thousands without us batting an eyelash, but not OK for this illness to kill a million. At the end of the day the decision is pragmatic and based on money, similar to allowing motor vehicles on public roads (to the point where they are de facto required).
- vkou 7y agoThis virus is currently killing people 30 times faster than the flu. ~0.01% of the population dies from the flu each year. 0.12% of the population of Italy died over the past two weeks from COVID-19, and the rate of deaths has still not peaked - despite a complete lockdown. Had there not been a lockdown, the death rate would have continued doubling every 3 days. You're drawing a false equivalence.