9 ms·
The government is in a real conundrum when it comes to relaxing the lockdown. There are a few things we do know: - It's impossible to keep the lockdown in pla
by refurb 7y ago
The government is in a real conundrum when it comes to relaxing the lockdown.
There are a few things we do know:
- It's impossible to keep the lockdown in place for long enough to completely eliminate the virus. Why? Because there are still essential workers out there, giving it to each other and their families.
- Because we can't eliminate the virus, the main goal to limit spread so that our existing medical resources can handle it.
- End the lockdown too early, and like a wildfire, it will spark up again in a few weeks and we're back at square one (or close to it).
- Keep the lockdown too long and the impact to the economy will only get worse, requiring massive gov't bailouts/support. The longer we're locked down, the longer it's going to take for the economy to recover.
What seems to make sense to me is, keep the lockdown in place long enough to get in front of it. Basically, enough testing so that new cases can be immediately identified and quarantined. That alone will have a big impact.
Then start to identify other essential services and slowly relax restrictions while at the same time keeping up the early identification and isolation of new cases. If things flare up, stop and get in front of it. Then continue to relax the lockdown.
The only way I can see a rapid end to the lockdown is if we either get a vaccine approved (and mass vaccination occurs) or a very effective treatment is found that takes the pressure off of medical resources.
- blattimwind 7y agoThe US is currently experiencing the root of the wave, the face of it is yet to come, then comes the crest. Only then can you start to see what comes after it... the US and almost everyone else is a looooong stretch (exponentially speaking) away from getting in front of anything here. Your administration speaking of "open churches for Easter" is entirely and utterly delusional.
- Wowfunhappy 7y ago> Keep the lockdown too long and the impact to the economy will only get worse, requiring massive gov't bailouts/support. The longer we're locked down, the longer it's going to take for the economy to recover. It's bad for the economy if a million more people than necessary die because our healthcare system was overwhelmed. Yes, the economy is going to suffer no matter what we do. But ending the lockdown too early will make the situation worse, not better.
- gameswithgo 7y agoit would...only... be about one million
- refurb 7y agoIt's bad either way - keeping the lockdown in place for too long or relaxing it too early. The goal is to find the right balance - the least worst option.
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoSure, okay, but I think it's pretty darn clear that we're far away from needing to consider that. When the number of new cases starts going down we can begin having this conversation.
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoWhy would we wait to begin having the conversation?
- tonyedgecombe 7y agoBecause if you start talking about it too early then people will change their behaviour too early.
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoBecause we don't have enough information yet. We still don't really know how deadly this virus is, or how it spreads or mutates.
- beebmam 7y agoMore importantly than anything else: it is profoundly unethical. Are people really okay with abandoning millions of our most vulnerable people to death, abandoning millions more to complications from this illness, just to save some abstract notion of "the economy"? I flatly reject that reality, and everyone should too. Not only do the vulnerable members of our society deserve to be treated humanely, so do our nurses and other medical workers, these genuine heroes, who are subjecting themselves to this illness to reduce other people's suffering. And yes, the economy will suffer no matter what we do, like you mention. But even if it didn't, it is still profoundly unethical. Arguably on the level of genocide.
- themagician 7y agoThe world is changing. There is no going back. Some governments are better able to adapt than others. It’s going to be hard here in the US. We watched communism fail on TV 30 years ago from a government that essentially socially and economically suffocated its people. Now we are watching capitalism fail because of unchecked social freedom and an economy that can only function on infinite growth. We are in the thick of it now. As the President said, “Our country wasn’t built to shut down.” He’s absolutely right, and that may end up being a defining quote in the history books.
- nothrabannosir 7y agoThis is hysteria. I don’t have any sources but that’s apparently the name of the game in this thread, so here we are. Times are tough. It will get worse before it gets better. But it will get better. Pin this post and watch the situation unfold. If we really see the fall of capitalism, I will personally come visit you wherever you are, and we can ritually burn a portrait of Keynes together. To keep warm.
- themagician 7y agoI have no doubt things will get better. But it’s not just going to go back to the way things were. You aren’t going to see the fall of capitalism, but the kind of late stage, cut throat, everyone for themselves capitalism is falling apart. Before it’s even really begun we are already calling for a return to work because that’s all we know.
- krustyburger 7y agoIn the first comment you said that capitalism was going to fail and likened that failure to the one of the Soviet system. Maybe that comment was a bit hyperbolic?
- themagician 7y agoNo, I think that’s pretty apt. I’m specifically talking about the US. Capitalism won’t fall, but the kind of capitalism we have in the US is literally falling apart at the seams. We know what the solution is to the problem, but it is not compatible with our system. We are fighting it every step of the way. So either the system changes or a lot of people die… which will force even more accelerated change.
- nickbauman 7y agoS Korea was able to sort this by stellar tracking of individuals social graph when they got sick while lifting lockdowns. Something hardly anyone is talking about now.
- ganoushoreilly 7y agoBecause of states rights as well as legal rights afforded to every US citizen, a lot of the same options / technologies aren't available by design. You also have to deal with two distinctly different cultures with drastically different outcomes of citizens actions. We can look to them for inspiration, but to expect the same actions / outcomes isn't prudent and pulls away from the focus of figuring out what we can do here in a realistic manner.
- thu2111 7y agoThat's not quite true. Asian countries have used mobile phone data in some cases but so have western countries. South Korea got somewhat lucky (so far) due to the weird way it got into the country, via a cult that was already in effect socially distancing themselves and that was filled with young people. But now their cases seem to be growing again. Also what do you think happens to mobile phone tracking the moment someone walks into a subway system? Orwellian surveillance isn't a magical panacea.
- logicchains 7y agoThis article has a nice solution: https://www.nytimes.com/2020/03/23/opinion/coronavirus-depression.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/03/23/opinion/coronavirus-depre... . Take some of the trillions of dollars that will be spent on bailout, and spend it on building a never-before-seen amount of protective equipment. Once we have enough for everybody to wear a new heavy-duty protective suit every day, people could go back to work. It might be expensive, but still way cheaper than shutting the economy down an extra month or two.
- refurb 7y agoThere is one wrinkle to that idea - compliance. Even if we did give everyone protective suits, I can guaranteed a not insignificant percentage of the country wouldn't play along.
- wincy 7y agoMy family and I went on a walk and everyone was social distancing, then some guy jogged right past us like he didn’t care at all. Pretty annoying.
- joaomacp 7y agoIf only you were in China and could report on him for bad behavior...
- logicchains 7y agoThe nice thing is, assuming the suits work correctly, it doesn't matter if other people comply. As long as you wear a suit, you'll be safe.
- macintux 7y agoWe’re back to the core problem of this virus: it’s not that you have a very high chance of dying from it, it’s that our system isn’t scoped to handle the high hospitalization rates. I can wear a suit, but I’m still impacted if our hospitals are overwhelmed and FEMA runs out of ice trucks for the bodies.
- heavyset_go 7y ago> The longer we're locked down, the longer it's going to take for the economy to recover. The economy would take a serious hit if suddenly millions of people overwhelm the medical system, people collapse in the streets and bodies pile up in and outside of morgues. There's a weird false dichotomy I keep encountering where people insinuate that we either quarantine and hurt the economy, or we don't quarantine because of the damage it would do to the economy. The economy is going to take a hit no matter what.
- refurb 7y agoSure, but the longer the lockdown, the worse it is for the economy. And it's economy that pays for healthcare, food, housing, etc. It's not an ideal situation when we eradicate the virus but have millions of people jobless and homeless in the US.
- viklove 7y agoI'm not sure I understand the "bad for the economy" side of things. Who will suffer if we shut down unessential businesses and just mail people checks? We'll still be able to eat, we'll still have roofs over our heads, etc. The only ones who will really see their lives change significantly are the ultra-rich, who need us riding around in Ubers, renting Airbnbs, and buying plane tickets so they can fund their wealthy lifestyles. Who gives a shit about them? The average American is affected less by a quarantine than an unchecked pandemic. The only reason this is even a discussion is because our political system has been completely bought out to serve only the wealthy.
- tathougies 7y ago> Who will suffer if we shut down unessential businesses and just mail people checks? We'll still be able to eat, we'll still have roofs over our heads, etc. The only ones who will really see their lives change significantly are the ultra-rich, who need us riding around in Ubers, renting Airbnbs, and buying plane tickets so they can fund their wealthy lifestyles. Why do you think this to be the case? The ultra-rich don't need you around to do whatever they want. They have their islands and personal staff to attend to them. When the government bails you out and gives you money, you slowly by slowly become unable to eat, unable to have roofs over your head. Food does not magically appear in a grocery store. Food has a global supply chain that requires your currency to have value. When the government prints money, it makes it harder for it to borrow money in the future. Eventually, your dollar buys less on the global markets, meaning farmers cannot acquire fertilizer and other needed things to grow your crops. We won't be able to hire labor to pick the crops. People will lose their jobs as exports dry up and American dollars buy less and less foreign currency. Eventually, farmers raise their prices to combat all these forces, and the government must print more money. This is just food on the table. Construction materials and workers to put a roof on your head require an even larger, international supply chain. In order to combat this, the government reduces welfare programs and increases taxes. Business and 'the rich' leave for greener pastures. Frankly, inflation kills, and I don't understand why everyone is so dismissive of this. I'm not even touching inflation's effects on doctors ability to do medicine.
- bogomipz 7y ago>"Basically, enough testing so that new cases can be immediately identified and quarantined." Does anyone have a reliable source for the current state of testing? Is this still possible with current rate of infection and the speed at which testing is being ramped up?
- harimau777 7y ago>"Basically, enough testing so that new cases can be immediately identified and quarantined." Currently since everyone is suffering there is pressure on the government to provide aid and for employers to be flexible. I'd be concerned that support wouldn't be extended to people who do need to be quarantined after society as a whole has returned to work.
- feral 7y agoOn the 'essential workers' bit: Worth being clear that it is not necessary to completely eliminate every case of the virus. If the natural r0 is 3, and you eliminate roughly 3/4 of each person's contacts, we've won. You can break these links by things like social distancing, wearing PPE, better hygiene, better contact tracing and isolation, immunity, or closing some portions of the economy. In theory, I'd be surprised if the essential workers cant work while keeping r0 low enough for it to die out. It's not clear how hard it is to get this r0 sufficiently down. Different countries are experimenting with different strategies.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Klinky 7y ago>What seems to make sense to me is, keep the lockdown in place long enough to get in front of it. Basically, enough testing so that new cases can be immediately identified and quarantined. That alone will have a big impact. This does make sense. It is crazy those who think we're "over it" and need to get the "economy going again", despite our inability to even correctly measure the spread yet. It smells again like the people who were thinking "it's a China problem", and then "it's a European problem", as if it'd never be a US problem. Now it is a US problem, and those same people are now saying "well the problem is practically over, let's stop the quarantines..." The time for chronically underestimating the impact is over.
- rubidium 7y agoThe hammer and the dance article covers in depth what you described. We need near very high test availability, and intense tracking of cases. The lockdown just buys time. https://medium.com/@tomaspueyo/coronavirus-the-hammer-and-the-dance-be9337092b56 https://medium.com/@tomaspueyo/coronavirus-the-hammer-and-th...
- daxorid 7y ago> the impact to the economy will only get worse To be fair, most of the economic sectors affected by this are silly frivolities, e.g. travel, tourism, fine dining, vacationing, nightclubbing, cruises, sportsball, etc. The actual, value-generating, real economy will continue on as before, and may possibly even benefit from it as our attentions are shifted away from garbage pursuits that don't advance society at all.
- odkamkfn 7y agoI actually like most of those "silly frivolities" and "garbage pursuits", to the point where I'd give up a huge fraction of my remaining lifespan to keep them. Your values are not universal.
- baxtr 7y agoI’ve heard a concept from a virologist. He called it smart distancing. a) Everybody wears a mask b) people keep at least 2m distance, always c) wash your hands regularly d) keep the elderly extra protected He said with these measures we could reopen slowly again after Easter. It requires discipline though and makes things a packed subway impossible. Which is ok in summer