6 ms·
A year from now, will we look back and say it was worth the suffering for something 5x as bad as the flu? (based on Germany’s numbers, which are more fully acco
by mensetmanusman 7y ago
A year from now, will we look back and say it was worth the suffering for something 5x as bad as the flu? (based on Germany’s numbers, which are more fully accounting for those with mild symptoms)
Shows how important testing randomly is, if the denominator is low because you are only testing those in the hospital, it looks like the second coming of the Spanish flu.
- matwood 7y agoEven if we raise the denominator to make the percentages look better, there is no denying that hospitals are being overwhelmed. The flu often already pushed hospitals to the edge, so even only (heh) 5x worse will cause most hospital systems collapse.
- mensetmanusman 7y agoShould 1000 people go unemployed to save one person?
- cbruns 7y agoPhrased differently, are you willing to die to give employment to 1000 people?
- mensetmanusman 7y agoPhrased differently, I would be willing to die to give employment to 1000 people who can work to save 10 (?) people. If people aren’t working to care for the system, then doctors can’t find helpers with their kids, etc. The system collapses in this scenario as well. I don’t have a real answer, but this event is helping discuss interesting and difficult questions. If I was over 70 y.o., I would think that I would be willing to die to prevent my grandchildren from experiencing the great depression.
- gnulinux 7y agoObviously right? Clearly temporary unemployment of any number of people seems less important than death of thousands, if not millions of people.
- Der_Einzige 7y agoYes, yes, extremely yes. Luckily the calculation is far less shitty than that. Contrary to what folks claim, the reducing in fatalities from automobile accidents and from dramatically lowered pollution outweighs suicides and other economic reasons for people to die. This lockdown is a dramatic net positive for human lives and significantly reduces the risk of death from many sources.
- graeme 7y agoGermany hasn’t reached health system overwhelm. When systems overwhelm, the death rate spikes. Both from corona and also from other causes that now can’t be treated.
- gnulinux 7y agoWho cares if it's 5x the flu? I understand that you don't want to be proactive, but can you at least be reactive? Hospitals are already overwhelmed by COVID, and we're barely starting. It simply doesn't matter if it's 5x the flu, or 0.5x the flu. If it infects millions of people in a matter of weeks, since no one has immunity to this disease (unlike flu), it's gonna collapse the health system. Once the health system collapses, deaths will follow.
- lm28469 7y ago> based on Germany’s numbers, which are more fully accounting for those with mild symptoms It's only "5x" the flu (you say so, I didn't look it up) BECAUSE everything is locked down. If we continued to live and work as usual hospitals would be overcrowded (they already are in italy, spain and some parts of france), which means a bicycle accident, a car crash, a bad fall = you'd die because no one could take care of you. In Italy they had to call the army to get more body bags and more people to carry the dead out, NY is already running out of space to store dead people. You can't just look at low numbers due to aggressive lock downs, project them in your imaginary world and draw conclusions while ignoring all the side effects.