3 ms·
Dalton, Lack of health care during a worldwide medical emergency could outright destroy the lives of those you lay off should they or their families get sick a
by echelon 7y ago
Dalton,
Lack of health care during a worldwide medical emergency could outright destroy the lives of those you lay off should they or their families get sick and require medical intervention.
Are you trying to give guidance to startups to lay off? Why not advocate for pay cuts instead, that way they can keep their healthcare? I think most would be understanding.
Lives are worth immeasurably more than the businesses at risk.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoIf the company dies, everyone is out of work. That's not an improvement. I posted an article earlier today about expanded unemployment benefits in the US. It's not a founder's job to provide a nanny state (so to speak). It's the job of government to look out for the people in that way.
- dalton 7y agoThat's a fair point, and there are a number of situation dependent factors. I wrote this letter to myself because I know what I would do differently 12 years ago and I have the benefit of hindsight now. Obviously the crisis is different today, we didn't have a pandemic in 2008, there is definitely no one-size-fits-all advice, and every company needs to be figuring out the right thing to do right now. But keep in mind what ended up happening 12 years ago is that everyone lost their jobs. The letter is my thoughts about what could have prevented that outcome back then, at least partly.
- echelon 7y agoThanks for the explanation. > I wrote this letter to myself because I know what I would do differently 12 years ago and I have the benefit of hindsight now. > keep in mind what ended up happening 12 years ago is that everyone lost their jobs That's my fear for this pandemic, too. It's a really awful situation. Stay safe.
- taurath 7y agoI have to say, it’s sad to me that your lesson to your past self was to act in a more ruthless and uncaring manner.
- popinman322 7y agoLaying people off is always a large burden. Laying off multiple flights of people with latency and inducing stress (e.g. "will I be next?") is probably worse. Alternatively: If the business goes under, all employees will suffer. If some are laid off and the business continues to survive, those that make it will be spared. So from a harm reduction point of view, laying nobody off is probably worse than laying some people off. Even if you reduce pay, people may not be able to afford housing even though they're still working for you (e.g. in the bay area). And health benefits still cost the same even if you reduce other employee associated costs. Things are not as simple as (I'm interpreting) you're implying they are. It's not black and white, and the decision needs to be made on a case by case basis.
- taurath 7y agoCertainly not thinking things are simple, or that any of your points are innacurate. I’m sure it is very tough, and maybe even the right call for the goals at that moment in 2008. My criticism was that through this lens and with the audience the OP has, the lessons of an economic downturn being basically “lay off more people” is incredibly sad from a humanistic point of view.
- Aeolun 7y agoI don’t understand. How is preventing 30% of your workforce from losing their jobs ruthless and uncaring? Is all going down together a better outcome?
- digitaltrees 7y agoThe goal has to be first survival so that at least some of the team can be provided for. Otherwise, everyone will lose health care. But I agree, leaders have an obligation to balance this with the wellbeing of the team. If 70% of payroll costs have to to be cut for survival, pay cuts won’t suffice. Perhaps leaders should do an analysis of which team members have health care through other sources, or ensure that COBRA is paid in full. Lots of difficult choices ahead. Let’s take care of each other.
- kortilla 7y agoYou don’t lose your healthcare when you get laid off unless you choose to not pay for it.
- kaitai 7y ago"Choose not to pay for it..." haha. COBRA for me was like a second mortgage. "Choose." If you don't have the money, you don't have the money.