8 ms·
Why do we need more designs? We have designs. We need more production. If we need simpler designs, brush off the proven designs for 40 year old emergency field
by ineedasername 7y ago
Why do we need more designs? We have designs. We need more production. If we need simpler designs, brush off the proven designs for 40 year old emergency field medicine ventilators and manufacture them. To paraphrase, designs are easy; manufacturing is hard. Stop tossing around unproven designs that are unlikely to roll off the assembly line any time in the next few months and focus on getting current manufacturers anything they need to scale existing production. It's not like there aren't simpler, emergency-ready rapid deployment models already on the market: use them! [0]
[0] http://www.alliedhpi.com/mcv.htm http://www.alliedhpi.com/mcv.htm
- jbay808 7y agoCan my factory manufacture these designs?
- ineedasername 7y agoI don't know anything about your factory. But if you mean, can they do it from the perspective of IP/proprietary data etc., then that's the bottleneck to solve. The DPA could easily cut through that bottleneck if existing factories could quickly be retooled to manufacture existing, proven & approved designs. The alternative is to retool to produce novel, unproven, unapproved designs. If you have a factory, great! You'll need to retool it though. Which design would you rather target? A simple, proven, approved design tailor made for this sort of situation? Or the simple, tailor made, but unproven new ones that are being thrown together in a few weeks?
- _curious_ 7y ago"Which design would you rather target? A simple, proven, approved design tailor made for this sort of situation? Or the simple, tailor made, but unproven new ones that are being thrown together in a few weeks?" Perhaps both paths will prove necessary and valued?
- adammunich 7y agoWhat capabilities does it have?
- jbay808 7y agoWhat capabilities does it need? GP's point was why do we need new designs when company X already has a proven design. Well I can't access that design; it isn't published. My factory has cleanrooms, CNC tools, presses, waterjet cutters, testing equipment, and more, and a lot of flexibility and is presently running well below capacity. But I can't even assess whether that tooling is sufficient to make that design. The open source designs do at least solve this problem.
- systemvoltage 7y agoInjection molding - The TOP thing we need to get mass manufacturing going. I just watched NYTimes front page video of Georgia Tech students trying to 3D print their way - it is unbelievably naive to use 3D printing in a situation that needs thousands and hundreds of thousands of parts. It defies common sense and elevates 3D printing to a new buzzwordy things by the media. Do you have injection molding tools and mold making expertise?
- kilburn 7y agoWhile it is very obviously suboptimal, I don't see why 3D printing should be dismissed entirely in situations like the current one. The point is that we have thousands of these 3d printing machines distributed around the world, with a good amount of source material. At this point, we can afford to brute-force our way to producing hundreds of thousands of items, don't we? This is not going to solve all our manufacturing needs, not even by a long shot, but it seems it could fill very specific critical and unexpected needs.
- systemvoltage 7y agoIt's an opportunity cost. If we allocate resources that can otherwise be put to a better use, why not? Efficiency is king in mass production. By all means, use 3D printing at hospital level to get things made that's needed. A parts of the face shield (such as the head band) can be locally manufacturered using 3d printers. But it is boggling to me that the media keeps wanting to get 3D printing buzzword clicks than actually asking manufacturing engineers.
- ahupp 7y agoFrom the second sentence of the abstract: "This ventilator is an electro-mechanical equivalent of the old, reliable Manley Ventilator. " I don't know enough about the manufacturing process to say if it's faster to spin up a new simpler design from scratch, or expand existing lines. But it's worth evaluating.
- ineedasername 7y agoYes, and the rest of abstract strongly indicates they're still in preliminary collaboration stages, bringing on subject matter experts to figure out the details. I'm not saying it's not worth evaluating, but it isn't going to solve the current bottleneck. Take a look at the link I provided. Their products are literally tailor made for these exact types of situations. Throw all the resources you can at helping them scale production. If necessary use the DPA to force them to open their designs to other manufacturers that can retool their factories to make even more. Sure, by all means have parallel efforts to evaluate designs that can be cheap & scaled even more effectively, but recognize that such solutions will solve the next crisis, not this one (unless we're still in this one a year from now, which, hell I hope not but it doesn't seem beyond the realm of possibility.)
- BooneJS 7y agoThe US has become engineering/design while manufacturing is overseas. Broad stereotype, but I hope this is an opportunity for the US to recognize that manufacturing may actually be an issue of national sovereignty.
- thinkloop 7y agoThe US is the #2 manufacturer in the world [1] and will overtake China this year to become #1 [2]. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manufacturing_in_the_United_States https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manufacturing_in_the_United_... [2] https://www.industryweek.com/the-economy/competitiveness/media-gallery/22011658/top-10-manufacturing-countries-in-2020/slideshow?slide=10 https://www.industryweek.com/the-economy/competitiveness/med...
- anonsubmit2671 7y agoI would bet this is only for final assembly. I seriously doubt there is any "Made in USA" product that isn't completely dependent on some tooling or components made overseas.
- creddit 7y agoYes, but be careful with that conception. That exact same thing can be said of just about anything made anywhere. This is the nature of globalization of supply chains.
- baddox 7y agoI mean it goes back long before the word “globalization” was used to mean “anything I don’t like that involved more than one country.” There was very long-distance trade thousands of years ago. Not every raw material you might want will exist in your immediate vicinity.
- thinkloop 7y agoIt would be hard to find any product these days that isn't dependent on the world-wide supply-chain, but I agree that how "manufacturing" is quantified and measured leaves a lot of room for tomfoolery.
- davidzweig 7y ago"Open Ventilator Project Half the world's population lives on an income of less than $300 usd/month. Who will make ventilators for them? Consider Egypt, 100m people living on a thin strip of land by the Nile, the Philippines, rural Ukraine, India. A yearly salary may not cover a Chinese ventilator." openvent.org Invite discussion. We are testing our centrifugal compressor for pressure/flow tomorrow, driven by $5 quadcopter motor. Any turbomachinary engineers in the house? :-)
- xiphias2 7y agoMaybe if a bit of money would be provided from the $6T, that would help. But at this point I don't see any money being thrown to these projects by the US government, which is just crazy.
- serf 7y ago>Why do we need more designs? We have designs. because a cheaper, ubiquitous, and open design could have lead to us having more than enough ventilators at this point in time had we been considering the need earlier. An open design that was prevalent now could allow manufacturers to spin up production without the fear of IP legal repercussions. Why are people interested in designing such things now? Because the problem has been elucidated and maybe the shortage can be prevented next time. Something majorly bad for fast production : capitalism-oriented-design(read: profit) high tech machines with heavily unique firmwares and lots of high-cost IP in use inside the mechanism.
- DamnInteresting 7y agoThe abstract includes this rationale: "Our design is optimized to permit large sale [sic] production in short time and at a limited cost, relying on off-the-shelf components, readily available worldwide from hardware suppliers" The researchers believe that these could be quickly slapped together in substantial quantities in many parts of the world.
- sschueller 7y agoI agree and actually find it a bit insulting/arrogant that so many people think that they can build a better ventilator/mask in days without any knowledge in the fields. I am appalled to see tv news showing people making home 3d printed masks for use in local hospitals out of PLA and cut up HEPA filters. This is as effective as holding a tissue paper to your face, plus your breath the glass fibers from the HEPA filter you cut up and the bacteria that is trapped in the PLA layers.
- cozzyd 7y agoNo one's claiming to build better versions of these things, but instead reasonable alternatives that are not unobtainium. PLA masks probably are in the category of doing more harm than good though.
- Cthulhu_ 7y agoBut the things ARE the better versions already; they are ubiquitous, the process for mass-production (think of face masks atm) have been developed decades ago. It's a logistical problem caused by a sudden and unexpected surge in demand. There is no shortage of toilet paper, there's warehouses full of them (https://youtu.be/wA4KS546rZo https://youtu.be/wA4KS546rZo), it's just a matter of getting them to the shops. Nobody's out there making a better version of toilet paper.
- Beltiras 7y agoI've seen people swear off toilet paper in favour of the bidet. Perhaps this crisis will wean us off a couple of unnecessary consumer habits.
- sp332 7y agoThere is actually a shortage of masks though. Companies that didn't even make masks before are now producing masks. That's not happening with toilet paper because everyone knows that toilet paper use has not actually gone up and demand will crash quickly.
- 7y ago
- 6nf 7y agoI assume ventilator manufacturers are currently working overtime to expand production?
- Tepix 7y agoI know that Dräger in Germany got an order of 10,000 ventilators by the German government.
- davewasthere 7y agoYeah, Resmed here in Australia are doubling/tripling manufacturing capacity. https://www.businessnewsaus.com.au/articles/resmed-ramps-up-ventilator-production-to-tackle-covid-19.html https://www.businessnewsaus.com.au/articles/resmed-ramps-up-...
- sanjams 7y agoWhy wouldn’t we want people to continue iterating on designs? Should all the world’s designers just start trying to become manufacturing planners? Of course not. This would be a terrible use of their skill set. But more than that, why in the world are you criticizing people who are just trying to help? At a minimum these people are helping to inspire hope.
- martin-adams 7y agoI suspect existing designs require parts that are hard to manufacture or acquire at this scale. So reevaluating the design might be out of necessity to work with what is available in terms of materials, skills and equipment. That’s just my theory, I’ve no evidence to support that.
- leoedin 7y agoThis a thousand times. Developing a robust manufacturable product, even a simple one, is HARD. It takes multiple spins and loads of testing, not to mention a huge amount of work to make it manufacturable. Why are we trying to reinvent the wheel. We should be finding simple, battle proven designs and throwing the manufacturing efficiency machine at them. Developing new products on this timeline is exceedingly naive.
- systemvoltage 7y agoI'd like to add that most media professionals and journalists have no clue about manufacturing engineering and how difficult it is to produce something at mass scale. But they inccessantly write about 3D printing for more buzzword invoked clicks.
- saadalem 7y ago>> Why do we need more designs? The goal is to design a low-cost, simple, easy-to-use and easy-to-build ventilator that can serve the COVID patients, in an emergency timeframe. It should be easy to build locally, its functionality must be easy to verify, and must meet the design requirements.
- kache_ 7y agoDesigns haven't kept up with the recent advancement in production technologies