6 ms·
The unplanned for surge has been in videoconferencing (for work and for school), and while yes they adapt in theory to lower bandwidth, they're terribly affecte
by crazygringo 7y ago
The unplanned for surge has been in videoconferencing (for work and for school), and while yes they adapt in theory to lower bandwidth, they're terribly affected particularly by the higher latency that tends to come with it.
The problem isn't that your videoconferencing goes from 1080p to 360p -- it's that it stutters and stops working for seconds at a time, so students completely miss content, and introduces a lag that makes it impossible to have conversations because people are always talking over each other.
While YouTube buffers ahead, so playback tends to be smooth regardless.
And clearly this has nothing to do with net neutrality, which is about ISP's throttling types of content. This is the content provider itself. And they're giving you the option to manually go back to hi-def.
So I hardly see what there is to complain about. YouTube is just trying to make sure kids are more likely to have usable online classes.
- the8472 7y ago> latency AIUI google uses BBR which attempts to not fill up buffers and thus only add minimal extra latency. Plus in many cases the last mile is the bottleneck, in which case proper queue management on the router or its counterpart can keep the latency low. I think fq-pie is a mandatory part of docsis 3.1 for that reason. Congestion should only result in limited bandwidth, not in significant latency spikes, and youtube will automatically lower resolution anyway if available bandwidth is too low to sustain playback. So no changes should be needed at this point.
- crazygringo 7y agoI think you're talking about a theoretical best-case scenario for YouTube where I'm talking about the real world with videoconferencing. For people at home, the bottleneck is often something like their apartment building or block or neighborhood -- wherever their ISP didn't provision enough. Obviously "proper queue management" on your home router doesn't affect this. To the contrary, a series of routers full of buffers means that congestion absolutely does increase latency, and drastically. "Bufferbloat" is a known phenomenon. We may wish it didn't exist, but it does. So your claim that "no changes should be needed" to ensure videoconferencing latency is unimpacted is just wrong, and flat in the face of all real-world evidence. Have you ever tried personally using videoconferencing on a saturated network? This isn't theory... it's something you can try yourself. (I used to work in videoconferencing and latency caused by network congestion was the #1 quality issue.)
- ipython 7y agoI also wonder how much of this is caused by poorly tuned home WiFi setups. You have congested airwaves, poor channel choices (what’s this channel 2? Nobody’s on that!), and the tendency for everyone to run their access points on MAX power to increase their “range” - all ways to totally demolish real world multi client WiFi throughput.
- the8472 7y ago> Have you ever tried personally using videoconferencing on a saturated network? Yes, my domestic connection often is saturated by p2p software. My router is running CAKE, thus video conferencing runs fine even when the link is close to saturation. > For people at home, the bottleneck is often something like their apartment building or block or neighborhood -- wherever their ISP didn't provision enough. In that case better AQM would have to be on those bottlenecks of course.
- stefan_ 7y agoMaybe we can just skip the video part in videoconferencing and keep only the infinitesimally smaller audio of it all. Honestly I'm already sick of looking at a bunch of balding white dudes barely moving, it adds nothing.
- cbhl 7y agoAnecdotally, I've heard even kindergarten teachers are running reflection sessions over videoconferencing, and trying to help kids feel less lonely. In my personal experience, being able to see others' faces and eyes has been helpful during this time. That said, many video conferencing tools I've used let you switch into an audio-only mode (and not downloading the others' video) if you prefer.
- forrestbrazeal 7y agoMy 4yo did a "circle time" over Zoom with his preschool class yesterday. I was skeptical, but he loved it and it was a huge morale boost to see his friends. This is a hard time for little kids.
- kasey_junk 7y agoMy martial arts dojo is running “virtual” sessions. Is there some theoretical pedagogical advantage to this over nothing? Yes. But the real advantage is having a community to connect to. The video is important for that.
- LifeLiverTransp 7y agoHave some emoticons, that are auto-extracted by the camera, interpolating between states close enough?
- icebraining 7y agoI don't even mention it if others don't turn on their video, but I have to admit I struggle much more to follow someone through audio alone. Ironically I listen to a lot of podcasts and audiobooks, but there I can just press the button to "jump back 30s", which I do on most information dense episodes. I do wonder if we could adapt deepfake tech to improve compression. A keyframe plus tracking of facial features could provide a very low bandwidth simulacrum of video calls.
- segfaultbuserr 7y ago> The problem isn't that your videoconferencing goes from 1080p to 360p -- it's that it stutters and stops working for seconds at a time, so students completely miss content, and introduces a lag Bufferbloat. Ideally, at least for TCP applications, with perfect network congestion control, reduced bandwidth due to streaming should only degrade data rate, but never massively increase the latency. A slight increase is normal, but a huge increase is not. Unfortunately, in real life, it's often the case, and this aspect is often overlooked by vendors, developers, and sysadmins, making things even worse than it should be. Network hardware or software is optimized for throughput, and its performance under heavy traffic is often not tested. One common practice is using a buffer that is as large as possible, so that you can push the data rate to the maximum and avoid dropping packets at all cost. This is called Bufferbloat and it's a latency disaster. When the upstream bandwidth is saturated, the downstream buffer keeps accepting more bytes/packets, effectively breaks the proper feedback signal used by congestion control algorithms, so it never kicks in in a timely manner, and the FIFO nature of the buffer means the latency of a saturated link is always as high as the buffer size. As long as something is using the bandwidth, the network will always be slow like a snail. When people start having this problem, they simply blame the bandwidth-intensive application, and set a QoS up to prioritize things like DNS and VoIP, and to punish downloaders (and big networks usually have incrediblely complex and elaborate rules), This appeared to "fix" the problem, but it does not solve the underlying problem, all it does is moving the problem to the low priority queue. Another trouble is unwanted buffer can exist everywhere, in applications, operation systems, and underlying hardware, and since there's a conflict between throughput and latency, and some buffers are even technically necessary (Wireless networks are the worst offender), there's still a long way to do to fix everything. I am only speaking from my experience of managing small LANs, but I got most of the information from Dave Täht and Jim Gettys, who have been working on this issue in the last 10 years. Gettys writes extensively on bufferbloat in his blog that states similar issues exist at a much larger scale, including the ISP edge and backbone. Perhaps the vast majority of the case we are seeing here is caused by a lack of bandwidth and not related to bufferbloat, but I guess bufferbloat is still here to blame for at least 20% of the cases. Here is a talk Dave Täht recently made: https://blog.apnic.net/2020/01/22/bufferbloat-may-be-solved-but-its-not-over-yet/ https://blog.apnic.net/2020/01/22/bufferbloat-may-be-solved-... And here is Gettys' blogpost: https://gettys.wordpress.com/2018/02/11/the-blind-men-and-the-elephant/ https://gettys.wordpress.com/2018/02/11/the-blind-men-and-th...
- GordonS 7y ago> The unplanned for surge has been in videoconferencing (for work and for school) Thing is, ISPs in the UK (including mine) are saying that typical evening use is 10-20x typical daytime use, so the uptick in remote working isn't actually an issue for them at all.
- Polylactic_acid 7y agoIts most likely the combination of lots of people working from home and people in retail/etc sitting at home mid day streaming content so now the peak time is all day.
- mdasen 7y agoNot according to BT (British Telecom): https://newsroom.bt.com/the-facts-about-our-network-and-coronavirus/ https://newsroom.bt.com/the-facts-about-our-network-and-coro... They've seen a 35-60% increase in daytime traffic, but it's still only half of what they're seeing in the evenings and nowhere near their network capacity. AT&T has noted that their network traffic is up only 27% (https://about.att.com/pages/COVID-19.html https://about.att.com/pages/COVID-19.html). I'm not saying that it isn't reasonable to lower streaming quality (a luxury item) at a time when the internet has become an even more critical link in our well-being - be that economic, social, or even physical as information on the physical danger gets transmitted over it. It's also reasonable to guess that there are a lot of people at home streaming content mid-day. However, the data seems to indicate that while daytime usage is up, it's still well below evening peaks and the increase in traffic isn't as huge as many people are probably thinking.
- kjakm 7y agoBT may claim it is nowhere near their capacity but everybody on my team has seen really noticeably degradation in home internet performance over the last couple of weeks (this includes people who work from home daily).
- reallydontask 7y ago
- blitmap 7y agoObligatory, think-about-the-children. You make solid points, but so does the parent. ISPs have the capacity.
- lonelappde 7y agoA long time ago, "net neutrality" stopped being about net neutrality and started being about unlimited fast cheap internet.