4 ms·
It has crossed my mind that there's an awful lot of information available online and we often, as individuals, can't really know what's true and what's not. So
by DoreenMichele 7y ago
It has crossed my mind that there's an awful lot of information available online and we often, as individuals, can't really know what's true and what's not. So we tend to rely to some degree on "consensus" -- on the idea that if "a billion people" say it's true, it must be true.
While not a completely useless metric, it's also not a completely reliable metric either.
With having this thought, I have doubled down on trying to stay out of things I'm not personally knowledgeable about. For me, this means trying even harder to stay out of most kinds of political discussions, which frequently boil down to gossip and name calling and deciding which "people" you want to be seen as and who you want to be for and who you want to be against.
Political discussion tends to not be about good policy and what kinds of policies we want to have and why. And I have concluded I honestly don't know enough in most cases to have any idea which candidate I should be talking trash about or whatever. And it all too often ends up a case of me parroting sentiments of acquaintances just to try to connect socially.
I wonder how much that's true for other people/"in general." And I wonder if we need to revisit how politics gets done and revise our de facto use of popularity contests now that you are so unlikely to meet people you are voting for or know someone who actually met them and we are reliant on Facebook and what not, which has proven to be very much game-able.
The degree to which modern politics so often looks to me like the plot from "Wag the dog" is pretty disturbing.
Which isn't actually intended to take this into the direction of politics. It's just to say that rubrics of social proof that were probably more reliable when the world was a smaller place have gone weird places in the internet age and we maybe need to think about that more than we do and try to find solutions.
- mister_hn 7y agoThat's basically how medicine or AI works
- DoreenMichele 7y agoTo some degree, all sciences rely on the world respecting the views of "really smart people" who have PhDs or whatever. Most people aren't actually going to understand the science. Medicine seems especially reliant on the social proof angle, but a lot of science is over the heads of a lot of readers and we basically latch onto experts we respect to help us decide which statements we don't understand but will essentially take on faith.
- kortilla 7y agoIt’s a little different because those have negative feedback loops for punishing you for being wrong. There is little punishment for being a steadfast communist/capitalist/whatever for your entire life.
- tdons 7y ago> if "a billion people" say it's true, it must be true. Religion is a great example of this. I have yet to see proof of a god.
- linuxftw 7y agoWhat proof would you accept?
- DoreenMichele 7y agoThere are animals that navigate via sensing the geomagnetic field. Humans can't sense it (at least most can't, at least not reliably or strongly), but we have tools that sense it. There are blind people. There are deaf people. Failure by one person to sense a thing others sense isn't actually evidence it isn't real. I long ago decided this is probably the best explanation for the divide between those who believe in some kind of God or spiritual force and those who think that's clearly Hokum. Edited for typos, possibly due to autocorrect, aka autocorrupt, the bane of my online communication efforts.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoTo be clear, because I don't think I was, I am not saying "God exists and some people are just blind." I'm saying different people have different perceptions (which includes mental models or thought processes) and relate differently to reality around them. It's usually a pretty pointless thing to argue about. Both sides are generally pretty adamant about their views, a la The elephant and the six blind men.
- stOneskull 7y agoWith enough definitions, God certainly exists.
- GrantZvolsky 7y agoProof of god? We can't even prove gravity, or for that matter anything else in the physical world.
- rapind 7y agoPolitical actors have massive incentives to be dishonest and manipulate information to be favourable so it's a bit of an outlier... but it can also leak into a lot of other areas. The average person is up against a well paid army of influencers (PR, marketing, advertising) who's tools of subversion are becoming exceedingly advanced and complex.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoI think it's more complicated than that. Studies I have seen and first-hand experience suggests that people in positions of power are typically fairly competent and got to where they are because of their competence, so they often genuinely feel that people disagreeing with their position are just stupid or simply don't understand the problem adequately. Their first-hand experience backs up this assumption in most cases and fosters habits that end up de facto being "asshole behavior" in many situations. As they accrue power, they get surrounded by yes men who massage their ego, either to curry favor or out of genuine fear or because they are sincere fans who recognize their leader's competence and aren't competent enough themselves to poke holes in anything their leader says. It's inherently hard to figure out how to avoid that outcome. Powerful people often keep long-standing associations with people who knew them back in the day because those people may be the only ones who have any hope of giving them pushback that is actually constructive and not politically motivated (in an "office politics" sense of the word). The world hasn't solved this problem yet.
- pintxo 7y agoI'd say the usual fix we apply for this is limiting term times. Maybe we should be more rigorous with that.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoI mean we haven't found a fix more generally. We still have sayings like "Power corrupts" because we still don't have a terrific handle on how to avoid such outcomes for powerful people generally, having nothing to do with politics per se.