12 ms·
A mother and son who unraveled a geographic hoax
- cheschire 7y agoWhen I talk with people who are not sure what the purpose of life is, I point to people like this guy as an example of what the purpose can be. There's really no point in his travels other than personal satisfaction. That people can be motivated by things like this helps me to relax, and I hope more people learn to enjoy these simple things as well.
- Swizec 7y agoViktor Frankl’s book really helped me here. There is no purpose to life. But you need one to be happy/thrive/survive. So pick a purpose and go for it. Any purpose will do, just choose.
- LandR 7y agoThe book is "Mans Search for Meaning", and I would also recommend it to anyone.
- klenwell 7y agoMy favorite illustration of this principle. From an account of one of the first MMORPGs: Under the resource system, players could gather raw materials, like ore, and make them into finished goods, like armor, which, once used, would begin to break down and reënter the pool as raw materials. Players, it turned out, liked to make things—they were turning out hundreds, and even thousands, of swords and shields and gauntlets—but instead of using them, or throwing them out, which would have had the same effect, they hoarded them. One player reportedly had a collection of ten thousand identical shirts. https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2001/05/28/pimps-and-dragons https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2001/05/28/pimps-and-drag... A collection of ten thousand identical shirts. Yet there are times in my life when I could have certainly appreciated the therapeutic benefit, if not higher purpose, in coming home from the office and spending all evening folding t-shirts in a virtual castle.
- DoofusOfDeath 7y ago> There's really no point in his travels other than personal satisfaction. IIUC, you're advocating hedonism as a sufficient purpose for some lives. I think for many people, the possibility of hedonism as the greatest possible good causes them existential dread. Caveat: I've studied far less philosophy than I should have; I may be talking out my backside.
- function_seven 7y agoI'd wager that "personal satisfaction" is (or can be) something different than "pleasure". To me--also with little philosophical study--"hedonism" refers to just pleasure. It's the sugar of life. But I've gotten the greatest satisfaction in life from things other than sex/drugs/booze/games/etc. From creating new things, solving problems, and helping others. This is the protein of life.
- philwelch 7y agoNah, that’s basically also what Kierkegaard said.
- deanCommie 7y agoInterestingly, I found hedonism as a SOLUTION for my existential dread. Of course I don't call it hedonism, but here is the path I followed. These are statements of fact to me, but of course they are highly debatable. Fork wherever your own experience does not match. 1) There is no God, as in a conscious being who created the universe for a purpose that is yet to be revealed to us 1B) The universe itself is uncaring, and it's current state is just the resolution of a very complex set of causes and effects. It's on a path, but there is no destination or goal. 2) There is no afterlife. Existence is consciousness, and when consciousness nds, there is nothing else. 3) Consciousness may or may not be special but it is irrelevant because we EXPERIENCE it as special. 4) Experiences and feelings are real, complex, evolving, and almost limitless in the range that you can experience over the course of a finite lifetime 5) Positive/unique experiences are inherently good to have. And good to provide to others. 6) Therefore, the only thing we can do is try to maximize the amount of positive feelings/experiences we each have, and maximize the amount we generate in others. 7) The exact balance between focusing on yourself vs generating in others, and the relative worth of being a force multiplier (e.g. sacrificing your own happiness for someone else, or multiple others), is an exercise left to the reader. So long as your actions contribute to a NET good for the world, it's probably okay. 8) What I don't like about the term hedonism is it makes it seem like I want to just sit around eating grapes and having sex. In a more macro sense, technology that helps humanity be more effective and have more leisure, a more egalitarian society, a multi-planetary civilization that is safe from extinction from a wild cosmic event are all things that I believe are of value to contribute to the overall increase of one's happiness/experiences, and to all of civilization. So my philosophy, whatever it is called, is completely compatible with humanity's progress
- Causality1 7y agoIt seems like it wouldn't be terribly hard to check the existence of Moose Flats pond by pulling up the Google maps satellite view and then scrolling backward on the timeline. Even if it's a periodic feature it should show up in some of the pictures taken over time. It's also a bit strange how they lost track of where they were in relation to the lodge. They didn't have phones with them? Even if you were foolish enough to go hiking without an offline mapping app you can still get from point A to point B.
- arethuza 7y ago"They didn't have phones with them?" I've had to give people paper copies of maps more than once when hiking because their batteries were flat on their phones. NB I take a phone, an external battery pack and two copies of paper maps. Edit: As an aside, I'm trying to reduce my reliance on digital maps and go back to using paper maps and compass more as I'm sure it reduces awareness of where you are (I've actually made more navigational mistakes using digital maps than when I mostly used paper maps).
- flyinghamster 7y agoA couple of other important advantages to paper maps: you can get a much better "big picture" view, as printed maps have a much higher resolution and can be printed as large as necessary. Zooming out on a digital map comes at the price of reduced detail. Also, if you drop a paper map onto a hard surface, it doesn't break - and even if damaged, a paper map can still be useful.
- arethuza 7y agoHaving lost a paper map to high winds before I'd add that a waterproof map case with a lanyard to go over your neck can be a good idea!
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Ididntdothis 7y ago
- mywacaday 7y agoThe article says the Island is barely a mile long but a quick measure on goggle maps at the coordinates give puts it at 720m long
- willvarfar 7y agoThe article talks about a seasonal lake. Perhaps the size changes depending on time of year?
- mark-r 7y agoThe seasonal lake is the one on Ryan island. Siskiwit Lake is quite large and I'm sure it's not seasonal.
- JdeBP 7y agoHere's the edit that introduced this to Wikipedia: * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Diff/288109348 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Diff/288109348 You can see how it was falsely sourced by adding it in front of the source that does indeed confirm (it being a re-hash of Shelton's earlier book The Life of Isle Royale, published in 1975) that Siskwit Lake is oligotrophic, but says nothing in support of the added material.
- ahelwer 7y agoI was going to speculate that the wikipedia user was inspired by xkcd's "citogenesis" comic [0] but that was published in 2011 [1] while the edit happened in 2009. [0] https://xkcd.com/978/ https://xkcd.com/978/ [1] https://xkcd.com/978/info.0.json https://xkcd.com/978/info.0.json
- Sniffnoy 7y agoXKCD did not at all invent the idea of putting false information on Wikipedia.
- gabriel_shatana 7y agoIf the island has been mapped with lidar, it would be possible to find it in such way. Lidar can penetrate the trees and give you a surface model of what underneath.
- CodiePetersen 7y agoYou should be careful with the "can penetrate the trees" statement for people who don't understand the technology. But you are correct. Like light, some of the lidar can make it to the ground and give us a partial map of the floor. I'm sure more passes from different angles would get a better picture as well.
- Semiapies 7y agoI'm sure it's not the only completely fake thing in Atlas Obscura.
- azernik 7y agoCitogenesis in action!
- skat20phys 7y agoI've been there and have mixed feelings about this. On the one hand, the boulder has always seemed fishy to me. It's a remote location and I doubt many people would track something that small, or care enough about it to know about the seasonal changes at that boulder. It also doesn't make a lot of sense to me geologically, although it's possible. I also years ago remember people familiar with the site jokingly talking about how "if there were a boulder there..." which lent the whole thing a sense of fiction when I started reading about it. It was easy to see how a humorous fantasy could change into folk legend and then into documentation. On the other hand, where are the photos? Where's the meticulous documentation? To trek all the way there to address this and then not take copious photos to share with the media? They also got lost, which adds to my skepticism they even made it there, or were sure they did. Can you get lost there? I suppose -- there are a ton of islands and things there so I can see that -- but the area is blanketed with topo map coverage, and you've got GPS now. If someone were to get lost there, I'd question whether or not they even got to where they wanted to begin with. Siskiwit Lake is a fairly large feature on Isle Royale, and the nesting doll nature of the goal makes your target hard to miss. In short, I wouldn't be surprised if the boulder isn't there (or isn't surrounded by water). However, I also wouldn't be surprised if this guy and his mother never actually went to where they claimed to go.
- ttul 7y agoI added it to Google Maps anyway.
- Wistar 7y agoDo you know how long it takes to appear on the map? I used google maps as I was reading the story and didn't see anything on Ryan Island.
- zenexer 7y agoBased on my attempts to add local businesses, I'd say it can take quite a while, and some additions seem to just get "lost". Check back in a month or two--and that's assuming the addition includes sufficient photographic evidence. That's easy enough for businesses, but I don't know how they handle geographic features. They might just reject it.
- mark-r 7y agoI hiked across Isle Royale back in 1976. I remember getting a kick from looking down at the largest island in the largest lake in the largest island in the largest lake in the world. I had no idea at the time that it actually had a name, it must not have been included in our maps. There was no hint of another pond in the middle of it.
- anschwa 7y agoWow! Happy to have shared a similar experience on Isle Royal in the summer of 2010. One of the highlights of the trip for sure!
- chrisshroba 7y agoFun fact: The son is Roger Dickey, the creator of Gigster [1]. [1]: https://gigster.com/ https://gigster.com/
- fireattack 7y agoThis somehow makes me more suspicious about this story.
- ilamont 7y agoThe identity of that first Wikipedia user to write about it—with those completely unrelated sources—remains a mystery, but all available evidence suggests that it was a person having a laugh, nothing more. Wonder how many other Wikipedia entries have a similar provenance?
- msla 7y agoThe question nobody wants to ask is, how many books are the same? We know that maps deliberately contain copyright traps. Is this done with other reference material? How would we know?
- DoreenMichele 7y agoIt has crossed my mind that there's an awful lot of information available online and we often, as individuals, can't really know what's true and what's not. So we tend to rely to some degree on "consensus" -- on the idea that if "a billion people" say it's true, it must be true. While not a completely useless metric, it's also not a completely reliable metric either. With having this thought, I have doubled down on trying to stay out of things I'm not personally knowledgeable about. For me, this means trying even harder to stay out of most kinds of political discussions, which frequently boil down to gossip and name calling and deciding which "people" you want to be seen as and who you want to be for and who you want to be against. Political discussion tends to not be about good policy and what kinds of policies we want to have and why. And I have concluded I honestly don't know enough in most cases to have any idea which candidate I should be talking trash about or whatever. And it all too often ends up a case of me parroting sentiments of acquaintances just to try to connect socially. I wonder how much that's true for other people/"in general." And I wonder if we need to revisit how politics gets done and revise our de facto use of popularity contests now that you are so unlikely to meet people you are voting for or know someone who actually met them and we are reliant on Facebook and what not, which has proven to be very much game-able. The degree to which modern politics so often looks to me like the plot from "Wag the dog" is pretty disturbing. Which isn't actually intended to take this into the direction of politics. It's just to say that rubrics of social proof that were probably more reliable when the world was a smaller place have gone weird places in the internet age and we maybe need to think about that more than we do and try to find solutions.
- mister_hn 7y agoThat's basically how medicine or AI works
- DoreenMichele 7y agoTo some degree, all sciences rely on the world respecting the views of "really smart people" who have PhDs or whatever. Most people aren't actually going to understand the science. Medicine seems especially reliant on the social proof angle, but a lot of science is over the heads of a lot of readers and we basically latch onto experts we respect to help us decide which statements we don't understand but will essentially take on faith.
- jogundas 7y agoThe article quotes him as saying "I did Google reverse image search for their profile photos". I am in Europe and Google reverse image search for faces of people certainly does not work. Is that a recent change? Is that local to Europe?
- unreal37 7y agoI've been doing that for years. What do you mean "doesn't work"? Example of how it works for me: https://share.getcloudapp.com/qGuob6D0 https://share.getcloudapp.com/qGuob6D0 I picked a photo of a journalist at random. It identified her.
- blackbrokkoli 7y agoI don't think its analyzing the actual face. It probably only works when the literal same image (maybe cropped or with varying quality) is posted elsewhere, which probably not unlikely for forum profile pictures etc, or with journalists for that matter. I might be mistaken though.
- rogerdickey 7y ago"Son" here. AMA! Fun to see this on HN. A few replies to some good questions: 1. Per @JdeBD, that was the Wikipedia edit that started everything. After 30+ hrs of online research, all roads lead back to this edit. I read 3 books on the island and found no mention of the boulder. 2. I took a bunch of photos that didn't make the article. Happy to share them offline with interested parties, but given that I could not find MB, they don't prove much. 3. The article does focus on us getting lost but that happened well after we left Ryan Island. This confused the NPR reporter too. Ryan Island is pretty easy to get to from Malone bay which is just a water taxi away from Rock Harbor. We had a working GPS with us the whole time which made certain legs of the trip a lot easier. How did we get lost with a GPS? The island is a mix of clearly marked dirt trails and large rock fields with no trail markings. You need to have a great sense of direction and some luck to pick up the trail again after traversing each rock field. We got lost after what must have been a quarter-mile rock field at 1am and the GPS didn't have the hiking trail marked in that area. 4. We made 2 landings at different points on Ryan Island, one southern and the other west / north-western. I did a lot of bushwacking from both points but there was no evidence of any water on the island or even mud where there could have been a "seasonal" pool. I was looking for a clearing or any kind of large flat-ish area but couldn't find anything like that larger than a few feet in diameter. The (small) island is extremely rocky and densely wooded. 5. Re the route, as many have noted it was very convoluted. We originally planned to go 18 miles in a day - the first half mostly paddles and portages, the second half is an 11-mile coastal trail back to Rock Harbor. The plan was to abandon the canoe at the halfway point and come back and get it via water taxi the next morning. After getting lost we gave up at the halfway point around 4am and camped for the night there.
- codezero 7y agoI'm guessing bringing a drone to do a survey would ruin the fun of these excursions for you? :)
- rogerdickey 7y agoHah, good idea but IIRC drones are banned in the park.
- austincheney 7y agoHow does Lake Superior qualify for the title largest lake? Is it because it has the largest surface area of freshwater lakes? The Caspian Sea is technically a lake but is greater than 4.5x the surface area. Lake Baikal is the largest lake by volume, and is fresh water, having nearly double the water compared to Lake Superior. * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_lakes_by_area https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_lakes_by_area * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_lakes_by_volume https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_lakes_by_volume
- kibwen 7y agoThis is (understandably) misinterpreting the criteria for the title "the largest island in the largest lake on the largest island in the largest lake on the largest island in the largest lake in the world". First you would make a (rather small) list of all islands-in-lakes-in-islands-in-lakes-in-islands-in-lakes, then sort descending by largest innermost island and taking the first result. The only reason to actually care about the largeness of the other elements in the chain would be to break ties, which definitely won't be necessary. The fully elaborated form is still technically correct, but is mostly used for the amusement of its own absurdity.
- billforsternz 7y agoI disagree, I think the consensus view is that the feature has to be in Lake Superior because that's the largest lake in the world.
- ghaff 7y ago>Is it because it has the largest surface area of freshwater lakes? Yes. Per Wikipedia "The Caspian Sea is the world's largest inland body of water, variously classed as the world's largest lake or a full-fledged sea."
- 205guy 7y agoMore relevant from the wikipedia link: "Despite its name, it is often regarded as the world's largest lake, though it contains an oceanic basin (contiguous with the world ocean until 11 million years ago) rather than being entirely over continental crust." Regardless, whether it's the largest or not isn't really the point, it's just that it sounds interesting. I believe Manitoulin island (which is a bigger island in a smaller lake) has a similar island-lake recursion pattern. If you start looking at islands (not necessarily the largest ones), there are also several lake-island recursions (Lake Taal on Luzon island being one). And then one could rank the size of the recursive islands (or lakes) at the various levels. It's a lot like trainspotting in the end.
- evandev 7y agoApparently someone says it does exist and is going to prove it when the park opens again in mid-april[0]. > TAUB: Since we have published the story, we've heard from a reader who claims that Moose Boulder does, in fact, exist and that when the park reopens this summer, they're going to go out there and take pictures and send it back to us to prove. And, you know, that would be awesome. [0]: https://www.npr.org/2020/03/13/815546895/the-lonely-non-island-unfortunately-moose-boulder-doesnt-exist https://www.npr.org/2020/03/13/815546895/the-lonely-non-isla...