2 ms·
The only (small) problem with the herd immunity plan was that it would overwhelm the capacity of the NHS to deal with it.
by disgruntledphd2 7y ago
The only (small) problem with the herd immunity plan was that it would overwhelm the capacity of the NHS to deal with it.
- dijit 7y agoThe other (small) problem with herd immunity is that it assumes immunity for a long period, which has no evidence to support it. Another (small) problem is that there is permanent tissue damage in the lungs in those that recover.
- arcticbull 7y ago> The other (small) problem with herd immunity is that it assumes immunity for a long period, which has no evidence to support it. True that we don’t know that conclusively here yet, although I wonder if we could base it off other similar viruses. Nobody to my knowledge has been reinfected. Speaking of no evidence... > Another (small) problem is that there is permanent tissue damage in the lungs in those that recover. There is no evidence of that in COVID-19 yet. That doesn’t mean it won’t show up, but it doesn’t mean it will. You’re referencing something that happened in related SARS and MERS diseases which killed over 35%, not 0.35%, of those infected. It’s easily a 2 orders of magnitude worse disease. If you have data or studies share them. Otherwise, stop fearmongering.
- dijit 7y agoSuccinctly; https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BtN-goy9VOY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BtN-goy9VOY Their very nice citations: https://sites.google.com/view/sourcescorona https://sites.google.com/view/sourcescorona Mine: Coronavirus' (common cold) and immunity: https://text.npr.org/s.php?sId=819038431 https://text.npr.org/s.php?sId=819038431 COVID-19's permanent impact to the lungs: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/mar/24/coronavirus-what-happens-to-peoples-lungs-if-they-get-covid-19 https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/mar/24/coronavirus-wh... -- On a more personal note: "fearmongering" is preferred over loss of life here. We will never know if we did too much to prevent this. But we will definitely know if we did too little. Obviously I'm not asking people to panic, in fact, the opposite. Calm, reasonable and responsible actions do not preclude worry and having a healthy amount of fear for you and your loved ones.
- arcticbull 7y ago> Obviously I'm not asking people to panic, in fact, the opposite. Calm, reasonable and responsible actions do not preclude worry and having a healthy amount of fear for you and your loved ones. Out of the 4 links, I skimmed the YouTube video, read the citations, and both of your links. Neither of your links refer to permanent effects after recovery. The only thing in the citations they're referencing to back up their claim is a one-line exerpt from the WHO report: 'Quote: “Lung tissue also displayed cellular and fibromyxoid exudation,desquamation of pneumocytes and pulmonary oedema.”' This appears to describe the actual condition of people with the disease as they have the disease, not after. They they go on to cite a study about the much more dangerous SARS-COV-1. As I said, nothing so far indicates that we will see permanent lung damage, certainly not in the vast majority of cases. It may happen, it may not, but it remains too soon to know for sure. > On a more personal note: "fearmongering" is preferred over loss of life here. As you may have noticed people tend not to react well in panic/fear situations, saturate very quickly and become very much irrational. It isn't always true IMO that fearmongering should be the go-to in difficult times when we have to make life or death decisions with limited data.
- dijit 7y agoTo your last point specifically: You might not have noticed, but while some people bought toilet paper in the UK, the majority treated this as some kind of holiday, taking kids out to holiday destinations and playing on the beach and crowded parks. Businesses were doing everything they could to remain open, even if they were non-essential, forcing employee's to come into the office (often on even more crowded public transportation) It was so bad that the UK government had to forcefully lock everyone in. That is not a reasonable approach to a virus of which we don't know the full effects and whos' closest brothers (SARS-1, MERS, Cold) are incredibly dangerous, incredibly re-infectious and whos' current infection rate is more than double or even triple that of flu.