9 ms·
An animal that doesn't breathe oxygen
- vanderZwan 7y agoBased on the tone of the researchers giving comments on the results, this feels like a surprisingly uncontroversial discovery given how exciting it would appear to be, as if biologists with expertise in the domain were considering it to be possible but didn't have any examples of it until now. Is that a correct interpretation?
- koeng 7y agoYep, that's correct. There are a lot of things that biologists tend to believe are out there, but are waiting for examples, which makes these kinds of discoveries very pleasant surprises. For example, it could kinda be assumed that we would find a phage that contained a CRISPR, and that turned out to be correct (it uses it to target other phages that infect the same host cell). Another fun example is a reverse-transcription based replicating plasmid found in a fungal mitochondria. Theoretically it was possible, but that madlad did it. A phage that I assume exists is one that replicates via reverse-transcription, but that hasn't been found yet. I hope they find it soon!
- ampdepolymerase 7y agoNot to mention this sort of discoveries are so common now that it would be lucky to get a mention in top journals like Nature and Science at all. The incentives for biology is still deeply traditional; new, interesting, or novel discoveries do not necessarily get well rewarded at all. The biology research and development system strongly favors academia politics and close sourced large corporations.
- itsgrimetime 7y agodo you have links to reading about these? I'm curious but can't figure out search terms to find them myself
- koeng 7y agoSorry for late response, but here is for the reverse transcriptase plasmid - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/VS_ribozyme https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/VS_ribozyme Here's for phage CRISPR - https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-020-2007-4 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-020-2007-4
- ak217 7y agoThe authors characterized an obligate parasite that lost its mitochondria and steals energy from the host instead. While this is technically the first animal to be found to lose its mitochondria, it's not the first eukaryote. They didn't find a novel eukaryotic energy system. There are many parasites that lose essential cellular machinery because the host provides it, this is just a relatively complex one.
- pvaldes 7y agoThe group is still poorly known and giving surprise after surprise in the last decades. Complex life cycle with two totally different kind of spores. Some were wrongly chategorised as two different species, other classified as animals are now known to be fungus (and two different lineages of very distant related fungus noneless)... Really misunderstood group for most of the modern scientific period. The idea that there was not one extant parasitic "jellyfish" [1] , but thousands of a new branch of parasitic cnidarians was revolucionary at 90's. [1] Technically they are not Scyphozoa, Cubozoa or Hydrozoa, so they are not jellyfishes (neither corals).
- dnautics 7y agoOk so to give you a bit of perspective, I didn't click through, and I thought, oh it's probably a parasite because parasites lose their mitochondria. Then I clicked through. I wasn't even a systems biologist, but a chemist/biochemist that got giardia once in grad school.
- pvaldes 7y agoI had studied related species before, is a very strange group and economically surprisingly relevant. Is not clear if they looking at the plasmid or at the spore. Spores are made to endure harsh environments, "aren't totally alive" in a methabolic sense of the term, and could have created different methods to breath. Cnidarians are really old. From the article is possible that we could have a second lineage to mitocondrial origin, or that the animal have lost part of their DNA to simplify and adapt to parasitic life. Evolving to pack as many copies of itself as possible with minimum space and limited resources, and that would be really interesting, yes.
- TallGuyShort 7y agoI think the key is this: >> Some microbes that don't breathe oxygen breathe hydrogen instead, but there's no evidence Henneguya does this. Some parasitic microbes don't breathe themselves, but steal energy molecules called ATP from their hosts. "We believe this is what our parasite is doing," Huchon said. This isn't an entirely novel thing they've discovered. Similar animal-like things have been studied, but this is the first time it's actually animal cells being observed with the behavior. It's something we've seen before, but only in even lower forms of life. It's cool and new interesting, but it's not paradigm-breaking.
- jb775 7y agoHillary Clinton?
- dang 7y agoPlease don't post flamebait to HN. We ban accounts that do that. If you wouldn't mind reviewing https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and using the site as intended, we'd be grateful. The idea is thoughtful, curious conversation.
- jonplackett 7y agoThis was really exciting until I read the bit where it says it just steals ATP from the host. Thought it could be a whole new way of life but looks more like a clever parasite hack.
- SamBam 7y agoI kind of agree. It also makes this statement a little confusing: > However, he believes "it's inevitable" that scientists will find more animals like Henneguya among those that have adapted to living in places with almost no oxygen, such as some parts of the ocean floor. The parasite can live because it's stealing ATP that's being made by an oxygen-burning organism it's attached to. How would you do that with no oxygen-burning organisms around?
- arkades 7y agoThe ocean floor has "almost no oxygen," not "no oxygen." There remain oxygen-burning creatures adapted to living beneath in hypoxic conditions.
- TheSpiceIsLife 7y agoI dunno if hypoxic is the right term here as it’s usually taken to mean oxygen deprivation / insufficiency, which isn’t what’s happening here, as evidenced by organisms being adapted to the conditions.
- akiselev 7y agoThe oxygen concentration is actually quite a bit higher in most hadal zones (> 150 µmol/kg [1]) than oxygen minimum zones that exist in the middle layers (< 45 µmol/kg [2]). It's definitely not a hypoxic environment relative to the rest of the ocean. [1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5829614/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5829614/ [2] https://web.stanford.edu/group/MicheliLab/pdf/oceanographicandbiologicaleffectsofshoaling.pdf https://web.stanford.edu/group/MicheliLab/pdf/oceanographica...
- tantalor 7y ago> steal energy molecules called ATP from their hosts Not unlike a virus which also lacks their own metabolism. This will raise similar question as whether it is "alive".
- swebs 7y agoI doubt it. It's a multi-cellular organism that is capable of moving on its own. I don't think anyone will claim that it is not alive because it can't produce its own ATP.
- jshevek 7y agoA virus also lacks the ability to even duplicate its own genetic material without the help of a host cell. The set of features a virus lacks is much larger. On the other hand, all animals depend on another form of life to provide energetic molecules. As this organism (presumably) depends on ATP from another source, we depend on energy providing molecules like carbs, fat, protein.
- behnamoh 7y agoIt's not an animal, the title is misleading.
- scribu 7y agoWhat is it, then?
- empath75 7y agowhy do you think it's not an animal.
- cambalache 7y agoBecause it is not bigger than a cat duh!
- pvaldes 7y agoHenneguya are definitely metazoans, small and simple, but also very sophisticated ones.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- DarkCoder 7y agoGreat News
- loremdolorsipsi 7y agoMy fellow Wikipedia says Spinoloricus Cinziae was found first. Here's the source BBC article, from 2010: https://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/8609246.stm https://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/8609246.stm, the headline is "First oxygen-free animals found" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spinoloricus_cinziae https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spinoloricus_cinziae
- atdrummond 7y agoThat would be one of the loricaferans mentioned in the original article.
- jshevek 7y agoI'm not sure it's a valid claim, but the author implies there is a significant difference in the quality of the evidence: >In fact, scientists have already proposed that one such group of animals called loriciferans can do that, and had some evidence that this was the case, although not as much or as detailed as for Henneguya. On the other hand, this might just be a justification for low key sensationalism.
- sabujp 7y agowhy can't they just say "first multi-cellular organism"
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- kazinator 7y ago"Scientists discover a clump of anaerobic cells that steals ATP from a host, and call it an animal."
- jshevek 7y agoSeveral comments seem to suggest this is not really an animal, and I don't yet understand why. Is that your intention? If so, why is this not an animal?
- kazinator 7y agoThe point is that "discover an animal that doesn't breathe oxygen" is purely a word semantic game. Not breathing oxygen isn't interesting; anaerobic bacteria do that. If we call those "animals", then we already have non-oxygen-breathing animals. By the way, the following is from ten years ago: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2907586/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2907586/ If that discovery found "animals", then it is rightly the first one.
- jshevek 7y ago>The point is that "discover an animal that doesn't breathe oxygen" is purely a word semantic game. I still don't understand your point. This species is an animal, according to accepted taxonomy.
- vadiml 7y agoThis is proto-zombie animal
- willart4food 7y agoI could have introduced them to my first ex-wife!
- mekoka 7y ago> The parasite doesn't appear to bother the fish much, she said, but tapioca disease can make its meat unmarketable and also cause the meat to spoil more quickly, making it a nuisance for the seafood industry: "No one wants to eat salmon full of white dots inside." In a sense this is, in fact, a symbiotic relationship. It's funny that we'd call it a disease, but this bug is a feature.
- oehtXRwMkIs 7y agoNot really if you have to kill the fish to notice it has the parasite.
- pedalpete 7y agoThat depends, as others have mentioned, if you have to kill the fish to find out if it has the parasite, then that hasn't saved the fish at all. Also, people aren't the only predators for salmon, so you have to wonder if the other creatures are as picky?
- woodpanel 7y agoOff-tpoic: Funny to see that for us it takes a parasite – that gets to its final host by becoming a parasite of a larger parasite first – to find out about "An animal that doesn't breathe oxygen" because it doesn't have mitochondrial DNA, the thing all animals share with plants, funghi, and protists because their once common ancestor catched a parasite giving mitochondria to them. As I read it this parasite, called Henneguya salminocola (and apparently some others), has found a cure to finally get rid of that parasite!
- fogetti 7y agoThat blob looks pretty much like pac-man.