13 ms·
Imagine that last year, someone proposed that you and 99 other random people should hole up in your rooms for 3 months. You can't see anyone in person, nobody c
by SpicyLemonZest 7y ago
Imagine that last year, someone proposed that you and 99 other random people should hole up in your rooms for 3 months. You can't see anyone in person, nobody can visit you, you can only leave to get groceries or go for a walk alone. In return, one person gets cured of lung cancer. Do you take that deal?
Of course you don't, it's not even close. That's an absurd degree of sacrifice to make in return for 1/100th of a life. But it's the same degree of sacrifice we would be making in a 3 month lockdown.
- scrollaway 7y agoYou've been using a lot of really contrived scenarios that don't faithfully represent reality. Here's the reality: We're trying to stop a pandemic of a highly contagious disease that can overload most countries' healthcare systems and has the potential to kill millions. Also, putting aside how contrived your example is: yes I fucking would take that deal. 3 months of inconvenience in return for someone's life being saved? You know people fight cancer for years, right?
- perl4ever 7y agoWell, it's a bit contrived, but look at the math with our numbers. 1/100th of a life is worth maybe (at least) $100,000 in present day US society. $100K/3 = $33.3K/month. That's $400K per year. I imagine that I'm creating less value doing what I'm doing now, and probably so are you. So, yes, it seems like a logical person would choose to sacrifice for that. Not everybody should, and currently, indeed some people are going about their jobs more normally. But overall, it makes perfect sense for most according to reasonable estimated costs vs benefits.