7 ms·
It’s en vogue to complain about Google, but the stream of data flowing into Microsoft is incredible and who knows if or how it is being used. They have better
by Spooky23 7y ago
It’s en vogue to complain about Google, but the stream of data flowing into Microsoft is incredible and who knows if or how it is being used.
They have better competitive intelligence capability than any other company. Microsoft knows the org chart of millions of companies better than they do, knows who talks to who both in email and voice in some orgs, and knows where people work and where they move at work.
The telemetry sent up for Windows and Office is pretty comprehensive and invasive as well.
I wonder what they do with it. I see no evidence of improved product quality.
- JMTQp8lwXL 7y agoMicrosoft doesn't have eyeballs like Google and Facebook do. Even if they have the data, they aren't a central point of the internet (search) or the prevailing social network (Facebook). The monetization to serve ads isn't there.
- bad_user 7y agoMicrosoft operates Bing and Bing Ads. Nowadays they are also serving ads in Windows 10 itself. Market share is irrelevant, the incentive is there.
- JamesBarney 7y agoI haven't seen any ads in Windows 10. Is that a special version?
- als0 7y agoThey exist in the free version of Windows 10 (without a serial key). They're embedded in all sorts of places, including Solitaire.
- bad_user 7y agoNot only in the free version. I have a licensed Windows 10 at home installed from scratch, ISO downloaded from Microsoft. Before configuring it, yes, it had ads in it.
- kemotep 7y agoYou have never seen the messages on the lockscreen or the preinstalled windows store apps in the start menu?
- dhimes 7y agoI've never seen ads on the lockscreen- and pre-installed crapware has been with us forever. I'm on home edition- it came with the laptop (toshiba satellite, for completeness)
- kemotep 7y agoTo be clear if your lockscreen is the changing pictures there are messages on those that are "ads" in the sense that they can take you to promoted sites. Same with the built in Windows search. If web search is not disabled anything not found on your computer launches a bing search which like google search as results as ads.
- JamesBarney 7y agoOh the text that when I click it searches for something like "grand teton national park wyoming". I guess that's technically an ad, but my goodness it that the least intrusive ad I've ever seen. Wish all ads were like that.
- Dylan16807 7y agoThe crapware installation was never built into the OS before. That makes a difference.
- gherkinnn 7y agoMS does run at the heart of most businesses though. No ads, but potential for other sources.
- est31 7y agoIt's very likely that they sell that data to the US intelligence community. One good example is Skype which they bought two years after rumors surfaced [1] that the NSA offered billions for solutions that can wiretap Skype calls. After they've bought it, they removed end to end encryption as well as the peer to peer system, sending all content over Microsoft servers. It's a bit better if it's "only" shared with the US intelligence community instead of anyone who names a price for it, but obviously still not really good for privacy. [1]: https://www.theregister.co.uk/2009/02/12/nsa_offers_billions_for_skype_pwnage/ https://www.theregister.co.uk/2009/02/12/nsa_offers_billions...
- tinus_hn 7y agoNo major video conferencing setup has peer to peer video because that is an ‘innovation’ patented by VirnetX.
- edoceo 7y agoWhat? So my self-hosted P2P WebRTC is in violation of a patent? And the companies I set these services up for too? Are all the others (zoom, go-to, uberconf, jitsi, etc) just not doing P2P?
- paulryanrogers 7y agoIIRC P2P doesn't scale beyond a few participants because all the streams are going to all participants. Centralized can reduce bandwidth and number of data exchanges
- Roboprog 7y agoCentralize on the peer who hosted/called the meeting?
- paulryanrogers 7y agoI think Skype P2P relied on super nodes which had the best bandwidth and processing
- dilippkumar 7y ago> Microsoft doesn't have eyeballs like Google and Facebook do [Citation needed]
- clairity 7y agocomplaining about google is nothing like the whims of fashion. google is a legitimate threat to privacy and liberty, and that should be laid bare repeatedly so we don't get complacent and forget. facebook as well, to a slightly lesser extent. microsoft is trying to compete on that front (poorly) and should also be called out. it's not an either-or proposition, but an all-of-the-above one.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- threatofrain 7y agoMaybe people want to get their sense of priorities first.
- behnamoh 7y agoActually there's been evidence that repeatedly hearing certain types of news makes people less sensitive to them. In other words, if people constantly hear about GOOG or MSFT being privacy concerns in the 21st century, those people will think of it as the new norm. Sad, but true.
- clairity 7y agothat's definitely a valid concern, but i'm not sure we've reached that point. the constant pressure is certainly needed to get these companies to innovate away from products based on invasiveness and surveillance, or to have new companies pop up to out-compete them.
- rixed 7y agoYou forgot to say why Google would be a bigger threat than Microsoft, which is annoying given the person you are responding to clearly listed the reasons why Microsoft is actually collecting more informations than Google. Also, Microsoft has a much worse historical record than Google regarding protecting their users. For instance, at a time when Microsoft was happyly complying to every rules required to be allowed to do business in China, Google decided to not comply and close its offices in that country, all in the name of privacy. So yes, bashing Google in the comment section of an article about Microsoft Edge misbehavior certainly sounds like the whims of fashion, if not of organised business propaganda. edit: beating Android keyboard to oblivion
- mmPzf 7y agoOne of my guesses is security. The story behind the discovery of MS08-067 reads like a strong argument in favour of some telemetry. The TLDR is that someone at Microsoft noticed a strange crash in some telemetry bucket, and it turned out to be a wormable zero-day. There's a write up at https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/archive/blogs/johnla/the-inside-story-behind-ms08-067 https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/archive/blogs/johnla/the-in..., for those interested, and even though that story is twelve years old by now the general premise still stands.
- threentaway 7y agoYep. Every year the Windows security team catches 0days that are under development from the crash logs telemetry and is able to patch them before they're mass exploited.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- post_below 7y agoIt's nice to hear this mentioned. Just Windows by itself is a privacy nightmare. It's always amazed me that it isn't talked about alongside other companies and software with privacy issues.
- m463 7y agoand they own linkedin and github...
- badrabbit 7y agoEdge is nothing compared to defender ATP telemetry. For those with it, they also know every site you go to (outside of edge),every program you open,every file you interact with and much more. They do a lot with it froma security perspective but I reckon they have plenty other uses for it as well.