4 ms·
But do you need both? What if severe cases to total cases is not a fixed rate, as assumed by most models I have seen?
by taeric 7y ago
But do you need both? What if severe cases to total cases is not a fixed rate, as assumed by most models I have seen?
- marcosdumay 7y agoYes, if most of those people do not transmit the virus (or transmit very little), that could lead to a similar scenario if there is insufficient testing. South Korea would need to be a very exceptional point. Anyway, whatever are the ratios, Japan and South Korea should be different because of mask usage too.
- taeric 7y agoMy point was you could have exponential growth with asymptomatic being the dominant number. All of the dire numbers assume that there is a fixed rate of low severity to high severity cases. What if asymptomatic is the norm? Could there be something about the places seeing high severe cases that makes them unique? And it is not just Japan anymore. Germany and Norway both have low severity numbers. Most of the US is finding that the more they test, the more active cases they find today. We could really use testing that let us know the cases they missed a month ago.
- marcosdumay 7y agoI think the idea that asymptomatic cases are the norm is well accepted and widespread already. It still begs the question of why the severity varies so much.
- taeric 7y agoIt is accepted that asymptomatic is common. It is also expected that a large number of asymptomatic cases demands a large number of severe cases. What if there is an environmental agitator that causes the percentage of each to vary? High diesel fumes, as an example, could swing it so a larger portion are high severity.