2 ms·
We have lots of policies with adverse incentives and terrible outcomes. We routinely spend more money in the US on homeless services than it would cost to provi
by DoreenMichele 7y ago
We have lots of policies with adverse incentives and terrible outcomes. We routinely spend more money in the US on homeless services than it would cost to provide homes for free because homeless individuals wind up a lot sicker, etc.
It's not sufficient to show that this makes more money for the owner. It doesn't exist in a vacuum. If it costs the rest of the world too much, no, it isn't the highest and best use by any stretch of the imagination.
Edit:
See for example this hospital decided to just house a few people to lower its expenses:
https://www.wbez.org/shows/wbez-news/homeless-patients-get-novel-treatment-from-chicago-hospitals-housing/45aa031f-85b0-456f-b9fb-29b17f95e3e1 https://www.wbez.org/shows/wbez-news/homeless-patients-get-n...
Please note that I am not actually for "housing first models" or free housing. I'm for market-based housing that makes sense. It's just a nutshell description of the problem space to note that just giving people housing can be cheaper than leaving them to fend for themselves.
- burneraccount12 7y ago> We routinely spend more money in the US on homeless services than it would cost to provide homes for free No. The original study that generated so much headlines in the press said this was true for _temporarily_ homeless -- it would, in fact, be exorbitantly expensive to house _all_ homeless people. This assumption also misunderstands the nature of homelessness: many homeless people, when offered places to stay, refuse it. Mental illness, personal freedom, homeless community, whatever the reason a significant segment couldn't be housed if they wanted to, much less if we could afford it. There is no permanent solution for homelessness, it's not helpful to suggest this problem could easily be solved by just giving away housing for free, if that were even feasible. But to the larger point, people blame AirBnB for 'taking away' cheap housing, as if a landlord as some moral obligation to accept low value for his or her unit. Why? Because it's cheaper for you? Do you have a moral obligation to sell your programming services for a pittance because it's cheaper for your clients? What we need is public policy that encourages the construction of high density housing units...but instead in cities across the globe the NIMBY attitude makes it stiflingly expensive to build, meaning only luxury housing gets built, because that's what's profitable for developers. You could have the state build housing...how has public housing worked out for us? Instead we just make it difficult with historic landmarks and unnecessarily long environmental reviews and endless litigation to build anything. Make it cost effective for developers to build housing instead of blaming landlords for seeking higher value for their properties.
- Dylan16807 7y agoSo just to counteract the dead account arguing with you: "The original study that generated so much headlines in the press said this was true for _temporarily_ homeless -- it would, in fact, be exorbitantly expensive to house _all_ homeless people." Nonsense. Over 80% of homeless people on a given night are temporarily homeless. There's less than a hundred thousand chronic homeless in the entire country. $100 a week would be enough funding for a hotel, but let's drill in the point by doing the math for $200 a week. 90 thousand homeless * $200 * 52 / 320 million people. Final cost: $3 per capita per year to house every single chronically homeless person. And that's not even getting into the strawman they made about forcing landlords to do anything.