5 ms·
It is absolutely insane that we are so limited in this capacity, months after we knew we would need it. It is so limited and dire that we are barely able to pr
by epistasis 7y ago
It is absolutely insane that we are so limited in this capacity, months after we knew we would need it. It is so limited and dire that we are barely able to provide for our own healthcare workers.
I really hope that after this is over, we have the political strength to diagnose the problems and deal with them. However I fear that the current regime will prevent any such correction because of fear that they could blamed, and the extreme dictator-like narcissism that prevents any corrections because it would mean admitting imperfection.
- ghufran_syed 7y agoSo how long should it take to be able to create a reliable, sensitive and specific test , and then produce millions of such tests, for a virus which didn't exist in humans until 3-4 months ago?
- epistasis 7y agoA week? Two weeks tops? Once we have the viral genome sequence, which we've had for a looooong time, it's really easy to make a test. Testing a new virus is not the difficulty! We've had all the info we needed for months, and the bottlenecks are not anything specific to SARS-COV-2. IDT, TWIST, and others can produce the specifics for this virus in no time. What we are seeing is a massive logistical and organizational failure, driven right from the top of all of the organizations.
- jclulow 7y agoI dunno, how long did it take in South Korea?
- calmworm 7y agoExactly. It’s already done. Why there isn’t more or even any public outcry regarding the US/FDA refusing to use their testing kits/system is beyond me.
- drak0n1c 7y agoFor those reading who may be reminded of a recent news story - There was never any refusal of purportedly offered test kits. The WHO confirmed that there was never such an offer or even availability and that the rumor was false. https://www.politifact.com/factchecks/2020/mar/16/joe-biden/biden-falsely-says-trump-administration-rejected-w/ https://www.politifact.com/factchecks/2020/mar/16/joe-biden/...
- ejstronge 7y agoI’m not sure when the WHO reported that it did not have kits to offer, though they did state that many countries develop their own kits. It still makes sense to ask why FDA only allowed CDC to develop a test, vs allowing all extant, validated tests and/or allowing private US tests.
- calmworm 7y agoThis is not the same story or question. This is a derailing statement and should be removed.
- mehrdadn 7y agoHow were their false negatives? (Edit: typo: just noticed I accidentally wrote false positives instead of false negatives.)
- ajmurmann 7y agoSeems not to matter much given that they were able to get their cases under control
- mehrdadn 7y agoHow have they established this has been due to testing rather than something else?
- yibg 7y agoMaybe instead of looking for excuses we should look at what they have done that can be applied to the US and Europe.
- mehrdadn 7y agoThat's literally what I'm asking. What else did they do besides testing? My understanding is they've been aggressively quarantining people and tracing their contacts via phone GPS tracking, credit card data, and video surveillance [1], which is what really matters. Whereas in the US, they're telling people that testing them wouldn't change the health provider's response, which would be that the patient should self-quarantine if able. Now I don't like this fact, but I don't see why they would be lying about it. And if we assume they're not lying, then testing really would seem pointless. The problem here (as far as I can tell) seems to not be the presence or lack of testing, but the inability and/or unwillingness to provide the same kind of response in the US as in South Korea. [1] https://www.businessinsider.com/coronavirus-south-korea-spread-daily-case-count-decreases-over-time-2020-3 https://www.businessinsider.com/coronavirus-south-korea-spre...
- 7y ago
- neuronexmachina 7y agoLooks like they were on the ball and started developing their tests way back in January, when the virus's gene was first sequenced. I haven't been able to find a detailed timeline of their test production, though: https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2020/03/south-korea-coronavirus-lessons-quick-easy-tests-monitoring-200319011438619.html https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2020/03/south-korea-coronavir...
- nprz 7y agoSouth Korea and the US found their first covid positive case on the same day[0]. I can't understand how the richest nation in the world failed this hard at containing and controlling covid. [0]https://www.reuters.com/article/us-health-coronavirus-testing-specialrep/special-report-how-korea-trounced-u-s-in-race-to-test-people-for-coronavirus-idUSKBN2153BW https://www.reuters.com/article/us-health-coronavirus-testin...
- chrisco255 7y agoIf you look at South Korea's population, they have 1/7th the pop of the United States but yet have 1/3rd the number of deaths. They are doing almost twice as bad as the U.S. in terms of deaths per million people.
- raphlinus 7y agoThere are so many ways to slice the raw data, each giving a different sound of how alarming it is. For example, if you look at just Washington state, it has roughly the same number of deaths of South Korea, with one seventh the population.
- pnw_hazor 7y agoSK reformed their pandemic response in 2015. They were ready long before Covid-19 showed up. https://www.propublica.org/article/how-south-korea-scaled-coronavirus-testing-while-the-us-fell-dangerously-behind https://www.propublica.org/article/how-south-korea-scaled-co...
- mtmail 7y agoOne Germany company managed in January https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-03-12/a-berlin-biotech-company-got-a-head-start-on-coronavirus-tests https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-03-12/a-berlin-...
- IggleSniggle 7y agoI'm not so sure the tests are really the issue here. Were talking about breathing equipment for sick folks (anesthesiologists have proposed repurposing some of the equipment to aid in the shortage). We're talking about personal protective equipment, and the time/energy of the healthcare providers. At least in the case of simply having enough general use equipment for a pandemic, it's something that can be prepared for well in advance.
- sailfast 7y ago> as a measure of lowering healthcare worker exposure and reducing use of limited personal protective equipment supplies. It's not about test availability, but rather exposure of healthcare workers and use of PPE. If you're already in the hospital people will be wearing PPE if they can get it. Now that NY has gotten to this point PPE seems to be the bottleneck.
- madeofpalk 7y agoIt is absolutely insane that we are so limited in this capacity, months after we knew we would need it.
- jariel 7y agoIt is absolutely about test availability. Nations such as S. Korea are doing considerable and widespread testing and are able to protect their healthcare workers. And S. Korea is not on lockdown and they have suppressed their outbreak. Given that we're not going for 'herd immunity' in the short term, the only alternative is widespread testing, forced isolation and excessive testing of those with a recent history of contact of those who turn up positive. This will take coordination, moreover, it will take fairly comprehensive testing. I'm not sure if the USA is geared to do this. Maybe a few states, but not the others, which then creates problems. If those $20 testing kits are available in volume, enough people will able to 'test themselves' and that will serve as a really good '1st pass filter' for the regular medical testing systems.
- marcosdumay 7y agoHonestly, it's amazing that we can do so much about a virus that didn't even exist 5 months ago. The tech angle of the history feels like an Start Trek episode.
- CivBase 7y agoI'm not so sure it's a huge issue. Like OP's quote says, testing wont change what you need to do to get better. You will be told to take the same actions regardless of if it's coronavirus, flu, or common cold. Even if we had unlimited tests, I would rather our medical professionals be focused on treating those who need it instead of testing those who only have mild symptoms.
- ryanhuff 7y agoAggressive testing earlier would have allowed people to be taken out of circulation, which would have limited its spread. That horse has left the barn, however.
- rhino369 7y agoThe horse left that barn when we had a couple weeks of unknown spread in Washington state.
- tempestn 7y agoYes, although it is possible to put the horse back in the barn with lockdown measures. And then IFF you have the extensive testing, those measures can be relaxed after a few weeks without cases exploding again.
- CivBase 7y agoMaybe. What would we have done, though? Tested everyone, even those without symptoms? If your symptoms are mild enough to not need hospitalization, your instructions are the same regardless of if it's the coronavirus, flu, or common cold. Now they're just telling the general population to follow those instructions. What really disappoints me is that people seem to think it's okay to ignore those instructions if it's not the coronavirus. One possible silver lining to this mess is that flu cases will probably be significantly reduced in the short term.
- wool_gather 7y ago
- knubie 7y ago1. According to Gov. Cuomo [0] New York is now testing more per capita than any place else including China or South Korea. 2. This comment [1] illuminates a bit the point about not getting tested by your healthcare provider. [0] Around 11:30 https://www.ny1.com/nyc/all-boroughs/coronavirus-blog/2020/03/21/coronavirus-cases-grow--cuomo-says-40-to-80--in-ny-will-be-infected?cid=facebook_Spectrum_News_NY1 https://www.ny1.com/nyc/all-boroughs/coronavirus-blog/2020/0... [1] https://www.reddit.com/r/nyc/comments/fmb6p5/just_had_a_sobering_conversation_with_my_brother/ https://www.reddit.com/r/nyc/comments/fmb6p5/just_had_a_sobe...
- epistasis 7y agoWe are going to need to massively scale up that testing; per capita tests is not a terribly relevant metric. The best measure is: can we test everybody who needs it? All around the country, many (most?) people with symptoms are being denied any form of testing. We need to go beyond that to massive testing of even asymptomatic people that have come into contact with people who have tested positive. The healthcare workers are thinking about how to best help the people under their care, with severely limited resources. And for them, testing doesn't matter unless it changes treatment. But there are other reasons to test. What the rest of our leaders need to be thinning is how to engage a strategy to contain the broader spread and let people return to normal life, safely, as soon as possible. South Korea has shown us one way, massive testing: https://twitter.com/trvrb/status/1240444836982878213?s=21 https://twitter.com/trvrb/status/1240444836982878213?s=21 https://www.reuters.com/article/us-health-coronavirus-testing-specialrep/special-report-how-korea-trounced-u-s-in-race-to-test-people-for-coronavirus-idUSKBN2153BW https://www.reuters.com/article/us-health-coronavirus-testin... The other ways or get there will be some sort of antiviral treatment or vaccine, but those will not be fast.
- jariel 7y ago"According to Gov. Cuomo [0] New York is now testing more per capita than any place else including China or South Korea" No - this is not accurate. Both your statement and the statement by Cuomo are not true. As of last Wednesday, S Korea has done 295 000 people, of ~50M. [1] As of yesterday, NY has done 45,437 tests for ~20M people. So Cuomo's statement is looking a little Trumpish, I'm not accusing him of lying, but he's spreading false information which happens to make him look good, he needs to be more accurate. Also - your statement misinterprets his - the NYC statement says 'any other state' - not 'any other place'. Canada is testing a little bit more widespread than NY, surely there are others. So NYC is acting, but there's no 'cutting edge' or 'exceptional' response in America of anything right now. S. Korea, Taiwan, Singapore are looking like 'world leaders' here, granted, they have different kinds of systems entirely. It's possible that some of their other social artifacts, such as 'basic face masks' might actually be responsible for reducing spread. Since 'lockdown' in North America the spread has continued unabated, and in S. Korea, there's no lock-down and they have it under control (though they are doing more testing as well). There might possibly be something very specific about the spread of the virus that we don't understand, which if we were to be able to focus on, we could be more effective. [1] https://fortune.com/2020/03/19/coronavirus-south-korea-test-data/ https://fortune.com/2020/03/19/coronavirus-south-korea-test-...
- noelsusman 7y agoIt's about PPE. The time for testing was February. That ship has sailed. The disruptions to supply from Asia combined with the massive increase in demand in the US have resulted in widespread shortages of essential equipment. If you're not sick enough to need hospitalization then don't go force somebody to waste PPE to tell you to go home and stay hydrated.