5 ms·
I wonder what the trade-offs would be if you could amplify mitochondria in skeletal muscle?
by chrisco255 7y ago
I wonder what the trade-offs would be if you could amplify mitochondria in skeletal muscle?
- bamboozled 7y agoI'm pretty sure this is what happens if you're a weight lifter?
- usrusr 7y agoWeight lifting isn't an endurance sport. If you want mitochondria obsession, look for anything long distance.
- labawi 7y agoNon-repetitive weight lifting wouldn't be a good example, but neither is anything in 10s of km. Mitochondria produce ATP as energy. You can't store much¹ ATP, therefore mitochondria must be capable of producing ATP at your near peak output (say 10s average). I'd look at anything with high >10s peak power (probably a bonus if it's aerobic). Many bodybuilding exercises would qualify. ¹ Lactic acid is a byproduct of ATP production, therefore ATP supplies surely last less, than what it takes to start producing lots of lactic acid.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoAs a guess: You would be unable to rest without utter exhaustion, and possibly even not then. You might need to keep flexing your muscles constantly.
- smabie 7y agoWhy would that be?
- DoreenMichele 7y agoI'm basing it off of this comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22643333 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22643333 And this follow-up comment sort of agrees with my inference -- at least the first part of my inference: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22644577 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22644577 Edit: I will add that I am also, no doubt, basing it off of background knowledge about cell function. For example, mitochondria change and develop greater capacity to process X if you consume a lot of it, which is part of the addiction process and part of why withdrawal is a thing. If you consume a lot of, say, alcohol, you need to ramp down gradually so that the body can make changes at the cellular level to adjust to the lesser amount of alcohol and this is part of why cold turkey is so very hard and it is generally recommended that you taper off. I used to ask smart people with PhDs and the like a lot of questions about cell function and read what I could get my hands on that could be followed by a lay person because I have a genetic disorder that impacts cell function.
- hobofan 7y agoThere are other cell types that have a strongly increased amount of mitochondria like brown adipose tissue. They also don't have a "need" to perform some work constantly. As with any cell function how much work mitochondria perform is highly regulated. Just because you have a lot of them doesn't mean you can't turn their function down.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoNadia Commenci was recruited as a gymnast at age five because she was too active and breaking the furniture at home. She made the first ever perfect 10 score in the Olympics. They didn't have a way to display it. It got displayed as 1.00 because they only had three spaces on the sign. Her best friend became a professional ballerina. I have heard that Chuck Norris does two workouts a day and if he skips one, he makes everyone around him crazy. If he does two per day, he's calm, cool and collected and fine to be around. If he doesn't, welp, he can't sit still and he can't control his mouth and he bounces off the walls and everyone can't stand him. I also talked about the addiction process and mitochondrial function in a different comment.
- mszcz 7y agoFor a moment there I thought you were making a Chuck Norris _joke_ in a middle of a non-joke comment... ;)
- DyslexicAtheist 7y ago> I have heard that Chuck Norris does two workouts a day and if he skips one, he makes everyone around him crazy. If he does two per day, he's calm, cool and collected and fine to be around. If he doesn't, welp, he can't sit still and he can't control his mouth and he bounces off the walls and everyone can't stand him. this is a common theme among people who do lot's of sports. I did plenty of marathons, trail competitions in my time and a day without exercise felt like absolute agony mentally. There is probably also a psychological effect from missing the routine. Most sports addicts I know (including and especially body builders) have the problem of not giving their body enough recovery time between workouts causing them to actually perform less well, etc
- nradov 7y agoTop endurance athletes do specifically targeted workouts which significantly increase their skeletal muscle mitochondria density. They don't appear to have trouble resting; rather the opposite.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoTop endurance athletes. You mean they rest just fine after routinely exhausting themselves with unusual feats of extreme endurance? And you think this is somehow a rebuttal of my suggestion?
- nradov 7y agoEndurance athletes do not routinely exhaust themselves during workouts. Instead they work out to build mitochondria (among other goals). Hence the popularity of polarized training programs. Exhaustion impairs proper rest and recovery. Your suggestion is not consistent with what we see happening in humans.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoThey don't remain endurance athletes by skipping workouts for months on end. I've seen articles where some body builder got the flu, couldn't workout for a week or so and lost significant amounts of muscle mass, like 25 pounds. You develop capacity like that, you use it or lose it. And maybe I'm not making my point very well, but everything I've seen in life suggests such people do have a real need to workout regularly. It's not a "nice to have" for them. It's a "must have." There was even a woman who was eventually diagnosed with a genetic disorder whose disorder had long been de facto managed by her very active lifestyle. But I'm going to step away from this discussion. It's starting to look like a pointless pissing contest and that's not really my cup of tea.
- nradov 7y agoIt isn't physically possible to lose 25 pounds of lean muscle mass in a few weeks. That's off by an order of magnitude, check the energy and mass balance calculation. But frequent exercise is certainly a "miracle drug" in that it effectively prevents or treats a host of different medical and psychological conditions.
- ChuckMcM 7y agoYou become more chimp like.
- gameswithgo 7y agoyou would need more red blood cells to feed them, and at sone point that puts you at risk for a heart attack because your blood is too thick
- nradov 7y agoThat's not a realistic risk unless you have some rare medical condition or are doping with a PED like EPO.
- PeterisP 7y agoThe cells would consume more energy, so you'd need more food, so in conditions of food scarcity (i.e. 99% of our [pre]history) you would be at a severe disadvantage as your tribe would starve to death in conditions when more efficient homo sapiens would still survive.
- EamonnMR 7y agoAlso require more oxygen and produce more heat.