4 ms·
Nobody is proposing we just let people die. At least, nobody credibly that I have seen. There are some questions on if there was really going to be a curve to
by taeric 7y ago
Nobody is proposing we just let people die. At least, nobody credibly that I have seen.
There are some questions on if there was really going to be a curve to flatten. Such that, if we flatten it now, was it the social distancing we did, or was it going to flatten anyway?
These are not reasons to abandon caution. They do seem valid questions, though. Especially considering the costs of the actions we have taken.
- int_19h 7y agoCan you cite some references on "there was really going to be a curve"? I haven't seen any models that expect it to die out on its own without infecting a significant proportion of the population first - all of them assume exponential spread, just different rates of it (which is exactly what social distancing lowers).
- taeric 7y agoYour question is part of my complaint. There have to be models that this didn't spread exponentially in the severe cases. Where are they, and what were their odds?
- Rexxar 7y ago> There have to be models that this didn't spread exponentially in the severe cases Why ? Model have to fit what we observe. And we always observe exponential.
- taeric 7y agoBut we haven't observed much, yet. This is akin to the xkcd about how married you will be for days after your wedding. We are way too early to know what the later curve looks like.
- jiggawatts 7y agoThe more accurate curve is a Logistic Curve. You have to factor in that eventually people become immune or die, and there's a total population ceiling. Obviously, the number of confirmed cases cannot exceed this limit! There are other fudge-factors as well. There is evidence that the very early stages are not exponential, but possibly quadratic or some other curve, but this doesn't matter very much in the grand scope of things. If you want to be really pedantic, you have to do Monte Carlo simulations using census and geospatial data for each area, factoring in things like school days, work hours, mass transit usage, and tourism. However, it turns out that after all that effort you end up pretty much with a logistic curve, the first half of which is barely distinguishable from an exponential curve. All previous pandemics and plagues have followed curves like this. There is no magic math formula that will dispel this plague. Sorry.
- taeric 7y agoMy main point of contention, is someone has to explain the delta between Italy, China, and Japan. My favored hypothesis on exposure to local pollution does a decent job of explaining. That said, so far every curve people are looking at assumes all nation's curve should be the same. But they aren't. Not even the cruise ships we have locked up have followed Italy or China style patterns.
- jiggawatts 7y agoTo provide an entirely unscientific observation about Japan: I've been there on month-long holidays for the last three years straight, and the thing that struck me as the most alien was their borderline obsessive hygiene and cleanliness. I'm sure you all know that Japanese people take their shoes off when they enter a house, right? Well, the Chinese recently discovered that coronaviruses can live on pavement for days in cool weather, and people track the viruses into their apartments on the soles of their shoes. The kids and pets roll around on the carpet, and presto... everyone in the household gets The Plague. Shops in Japan package everything. If you buy a single strawberry mochi for about $1, it'll come in a tiny little plastic container, which they will put in a little paper takeaway bag, which then they will hand to you in a small plastic shopping bag. They sell individual bananas in plastic shrinkwrap. I shit you not. All this while the cashier wears gloves and a facemask as standard, way before the coronavirus was a thing. The bus and taxi drivers all wear white gloves. They have doilies on the seats, and I bet they wash them daily, given how pristine and white they looked. At shinto temples, the first thing you're meant to do before entering is a ritual washing of your hands with fresh springwater. Then, of course, you take your shoes off. It goes on and on. Meanwhile, I regularly see people in shopping centres here coughing their lungs up. On to each other, the food, or just generally into the air to spice things up a bit. We're playing Pandemic Legacy on hard mode. The cultures are entirely different, and Japan basically didn't even have to change anything to prepare for the coronavirus. They just kept doing what they're doing already...
- Diederich 7y ago> Nobody is proposing we just let people die. Agreed, but a lot of people are arguing for the thing that will almost certainly lead to a lot more deaths. Right now, as I type this, many hospitals in the United States have had all of their excess capacity filled with Covid-19 cases. Not most, but many. Now, please click this link, then click Logarithmic on the top. https://mackuba.eu/corona/#united_states https://mackuba.eu/corona/#united_states Once large groups of hospitals reach saturation, people who could otherwise be saved will be black tagged and left to die. Two women my wife is Facebook friends with, after two weeks of a mild fever, malaise and a moderate, unproductive cough, started having a hard time breathing. They went in and were both positive for Covid-19. They were placed on ventilators, and were soon in critical condition. One of them died this morning, the other is clinging on to life. Neither of these people are old; neither of them have any substantial medical history or other comorbidities. This bug is dangerous for all of us; it's extremely dangerous for some of us. It's true that few people are soberly thinking about the mid and long term economic cost of this pandemic. In my opinion, there's a good chance we're facing something on the order of the great depression. Be that as it may, lives must come first.
- lsh123 7y ago> Right now, as I type this, many hospitals in the United States have had all of their excess capacity filled with Covid-19 cases. Today Santa Clara county has 65 people hospitalized: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Data:COVID-19_Cases_in_Santa_Clara_County,_California.tab https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Data:COVID-19_Cases_in_Sa... In comparison, Stanford hospital has 600 beds: https://facts.stanford.edu/about/hospital/ https://facts.stanford.edu/about/hospital/
- licyeus 7y agoTotal beds is an incomplete picture. Stanford hospital appears to run at 88% capacity [1] and Seattle's Harborview operates at 95% capacity [2]. 1 - https://stanfordhealthcare.org/content/dam/SHC/about-us/bondholder-information/docs/S%26P%20Final%20Report%20-%2003292019.pdf https://stanfordhealthcare.org/content/dam/SHC/about-us/bond... (page 5) 2 - https://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/health/short-staffed-and-undersupplied-coronavirus-crisis-strains-seattle-areas-capacity-to-deliver-care/ https://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/health/short-staff...
- senordevnyc 7y agoWhat makes you think those questions haven’t been asked by the public health experts working on this? And you didn’t answer my question. What is your plan?
- taeric 7y agoI think they haven't been asked because I haven't seen them asked. I'm asking on a sibling top post. I am seeing tons of extra reasons to panic every day. Not much on why to stay calm. That worries me. For my plan? I'm taking the safe route for now. Though, I'm 99% that I had it a month ago. Week of steroids, then a respirator, then another week of steroids. Not tested, as I wasn't in the then current risk profile. Would be today, if even close to those symptoms. Now, if I'm at all close to right, my entire family of six didn't even bat an eye at this. Why? Have we drastically misstated the risk pool? Again, my plan is to take the safe path. Is an easy plan for me, as I can do so. Large parts of our nation can't.
- mafuy 7y agoIf the hospital were full, as they are expected to be due to the steep curve of infected, there is a real chance you could have died. Are you saying that is fine? Should we not try to flatten the curve as much as reasonably possible? Apart from that, it's not like there is no economic help. In Germany, for instance, there is a rather easy process for the employed as well as businesses to get state funding. So it is not like most businesses will go under or people lose their houses.
- taeric 7y agoIf my evidence is that I had it, any attempt to flatten the curve should have happened in January. Effects happening now are just as likely from when we weren't doing anything.