3 ms·
I'm still not thrilled because hospitals actively breed antibiotic resistant infections. They are a primary source. Keeping invasive equipment adequately steri
by DoreenMichele 7y ago
I'm still not thrilled because hospitals actively breed antibiotic resistant infections. They are a primary source.
Keeping invasive equipment adequately sterile is hard to do, even in a hospital. It's just the nature of the beast.
To be clear, I'm extremely not thrilled at the global acceptance that "we need a zillion ventilators" instead of "we need non invasive alternatives and we need to educate the world as to what they are."
It's well known this is a problem with this kind of equipment. I'm aghast that the medical establishment isn't freaking the fuck out at the need to find some answer better than ventilators because widespread use of ventilators has a rather high probability of leading to the development of new antibiotic resistant infections for funsies, just as we think the worst is behind us.
- arcticbull 7y ago> ...I'm still not thrilled because hospitals actively breed antibiotic resistant infections. They are a primary source. A primary source sure, but likely nothing compared to unnecessarily dosing livestock with antibiotics, and well, large portions of India. [1] 67% of folks in India in an albeit small study exhibited antibiotic resistance. > To be clear, I'm extremely not thrilled at the global acceptance that "we need a zillion ventilators" instead of "we need non invasive alternatives and we need to educate the world as to what they are." Indeed. [1] https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/science/most-healthy-indians-resistant-to-common-antibiotics-study/articleshow/69659707.cms https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/science/most-healt...
- DoreenMichele 7y agoThank you for acknowledging I might have a valid point. As for your comments about dosing livestock: That's kind of like saying "We don't need to combat rapes and robberies because murders still happen and murders are so much worse, so no point in even talking about what to do about rape and robbery until there are no more murders in the world." I beg to differ.
- arcticbull 7y agoSorry if it didn't come off that way, but I agree with you haha. Both problems need to be addressed in parallel.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoYes. At the moment, I would be happy if we just began promoting non-invasive ventilator alternatives. I'm very concerned this is going to turn into the biblical plagues scenario, where the first plague causes the second which causes the third, etc. I predict one of those knock on plagues will be antibiotic resistant secondary infections, many fostered by widespread use of ventilators.
- pbhjpbhj 7y agoNon-invasive alternatives to "breathing for someone whose lung function has fallen below life-sustaining levels" sounds like [deadly] bullshit. I'm not sure coughing in the shower is going to do it for someone about to die from hypoxemia?
- DoreenMichele 7y agoCystic fibrosis accounts for about a third of all adult lung transplants in the US and about half of all pediatric lung transplants. At the time that I was diagnosed with a relatively mild form of it, life expectancy in the US was 36. So I have a quite serious lung condition and I used to own and use (and sterilize at home) various forms of mechanical intervention. I no longer use mechanical intervention, in part because I'm better off when I can find effective alternatives. I'm describing things I know from first-hand experience to work well in the face of lung problems that are supposed to have long ago killed me. I'm doing my best to be very careful and conservative in what I say. I feel it's actively irresponsible to not share such thoughts, in part because a lot of places are de facto rationing health care because there simply aren't enough supplies to go around. If you can't get to a hospital or are denied entry because of overwhelming demand, having the option to puke up a lung in the shower is better than having no alternatives to a ventilator. And perhaps doctors will see my remarks, realize this is a valid criticism and decide to develop some best practices to try to reduce the use of ventilators overall. Worst case scenario if I speak up and no one agrees: I get downvoted to hell. Hardly a novel experience. Worst case scenario if I say nothing: Lots of people die who might not have. So it's an easy decision on my part. When weighing the personal pain of people downvoting me and calling me crazy versus death for others, it's a no brainer. I'll take my lumps, thanks.
- lifeisstillgood 7y agoConsider this an anti-lump. Stored in the back of my mind is a shower based all-other-things-gone-to-hell-in-a-handbasket option. Thank you. Keep sharing - medical best practise moves onward as well. Perhaps your experience is only effective for you, perhaps it's a viable alternative for millions. We'll science the shit out of it in the next few months no matter what :-)