2 ms·
I see creation of a vaccine very differently to production of one of a range of existing ventilators. There are many companies using things like 6D CNC machine
by pbhjpbhj 7y ago
I see creation of a vaccine very differently to production of one of a range of existing ventilators.
There are many companies using things like 6D CNC machines with high accuracy that can essentially spit out a part for which there's a definition (and we can 3D scan parts to micrometer accuracy with laser scanners); many electronics companies can make "any" circuit to some extent (I'm guessing ventilators use generic components, some circuits might be generic - like valve controllers, whatever, certainly display controllers I'd expect to be generic). Parts like keys, cases, outside the gas flow/control path are probably injection moulds that factories could pop out a million of within a week (once the dies are duplicated).
A skilled grill worker takes a while to train, but any grill worker given McDo's recipe could make you a functioning BigMac in an hour. I'm not asking for a new product to be designed (one effort - opensourceventilator.ie - are doing exactly that, making a modified BVM system).
Still looks like production could produce output in weeks rather than months.
- salawat 7y agoThe problem isn't production. It's mass automated production. Once you take the human out of the picture to get a machine to do the work you've now involved a programmer, CNC operator, roboticist. and an industrial engineer at a minimum just to get the rough task doable. We could probably have a fully human operated production line up and going relatively quickly, but getting the machines all cut over and integrated so as to do it themselves is hard. Look, thought experiment. You ever watch that show, "How It's Made"? They literally make entertainment out of watching the end result of the final outcome of integrating all of these stages of the fabrication process. But if you have ever watched it, did it not strike you as interesting that they never seem to do an episode with regards to the production of the very industrial equipment automating the fabrication process? They can't/won't because it is bloody hard, error prone, and freaking expensive. Once you've got it, you're gold, but it is by no means a short route getting there.