5 ms·
Have governments made orders (legal or purchase) for manufacture of ventilators by large scale companies? Presumably ventilators are a relatively niche product
by pbhjpbhj 7y ago
Have governments made orders (legal or purchase) for manufacture of ventilators by large scale companies?
Presumably ventilators are a relatively niche product - what's in them that the World's industrial complexes can't ramp up production of within a couple of weeks?
I imagine it's the pumps that's the limiting factor? Given humanity already has the working tested, established designs.
Can't governments requisition the design, turn the original factories in to test only, or construct and test, centres. Instruct the mega-corps, publicly, which parts they are to make and by when ...
In the West we throw away tens-of-thousands of highly engineered products every day; surely we can step up now?
- meheleventyone 7y agoReporting in the UK says that half a dozen prototypes have been delivered to the NHS for manufacturing approval already.
- kaetemi 7y agoHalf a dozen somehow sounds more impressive than six...
- meheleventyone 7y agoHah, yes! Although six individual companies spinning up a prototype in quick order is pretty impressive as well.
- hnarn 7y agoTangentially (this is HN after all) I also feel like "half a dozen" gives a more fuzzy confidence interval than a regular number ("6"). Of course, half a dozen literally means the amount 6, but am I the only one that reads them slightly differently? I almost see an implicit "about" before the phrase: "[about] half a dozen".
- polytely 7y agoIt's actually a really interesting subject, I think it's closely related to something called "words of estimate probability", the wikipedia article [0] is a good startingpoint. 0: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Words_of_estimative_probability https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Words_of_estimative_probabilit...
- bcrosby95 7y agoIt's a technique you can use in software estimation too. There's an implied difference between saying something will take about 2 months vs 8 weeks vs 57 days, even if they're all technically the same amount of time.
- kaetemi 7y agoAnd we can assume that means 57 bank/gov't working days, which could easily be about 3 years. :)
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jdmichal 7y agoBigger scales typically include an implicit amount of wiggle within the lower scales. People understand that when you say a car cost "25 thousand", that it's not exactly 25,000, but that it's closer to 25,000 than 24,000 or 26,000. Moving to a bigger scale, and then back down to a smaller scale maintains that implicit wiggle room.
- _n_b_ 7y agoI am not an expert on manufacturing biomedical devices, but I do know quite a bit about manufacturing safety-grade nuclear components. So take this with a grain of salt. However, from what I do know, fundamentally the requirements are pretty similar. There is likely nothing magical from a purely mechanical standpoint about making a ventilator. The part that is difficult is: * Have an adequate QA program for you and your suppliers, tracing safety-critical components down to the raw materials * Adjusting your tooling, making molds, etc. * Doing low-production runs followed by testing to validate your process * Getting whatever certification is required; even if there is a flexible emergency process, I think we still want some demonstration of compliance * Not having the lessons-learned of companies who have been doing this for years, and have worked through enough problems to have general domain knowledge * etc. My experience would lead me to believe that short-term returns would better come from finding ways to optimize the supply chain and manufacturing pipelines of existing manufacturers, which potentially could be done much more quickly. If you look at the example of WW2, when auto factories converted to war production, it was not a quick or easy affair. The excellent book Arsenal of Democracy describes the conversion of the Willow Run factory to producing B-24s, it took at least a year and a half to get the plant producing planes at an acceptable quality and quantity.
- dehrmann 7y ago> it took at least a year and a half to get the plant producing planes at an acceptable quality and quantity. I wonder if this would be longer or shorter today with how much of car assembly is automated. How many of the tools do one specific thing a human used to? How many are robots that can be reprogrammed? That, and cars and ventilators are completely different. I'd think a ventilator is closer to a dishwasher than a car (think appliance).
- HeWhoLurksLate 7y agoI've had some experience with the robotics / automation engineering side of industry. It's not easy to take super high-level automation and turn around and make it produce something else entirely. Base / core machinery- such as a 3-axis CNC machine, or a lathe, or a saw, for instance, are fairly nimble- if you have the right cutting bits (which you probably do, considering that it's industry) you can switch from milling out aluminum mounting plates to milling out enclosures for electronics fairly easily. At this level, generally humans are responsible for sticking in the material and telling the machine what to do each time an action is performed. Where it gets more complicated is at the higher levels of automation, where humans might be supervising the machines, but aren't initiating processes themselves- for example, there was a prod cell that I worked with that had a robot putting raw material into a mill and then removing it- humans program those arms, but then after that, it just goes, and goes, and goes. Programming those arms is generally an exercise in making sure the math works, and then implementing the job in a bunch of for loops and hard-coded / static adjustment variables and the like. In these instances, to make the cell produce something else, not only do you have to program the machine that actually produces parts, but you also have to reprogram the bot that puts and pulls from it, and you may also need to change the grip on the bot to support the new geometry. At the really high levels, like how car manufacturing is currently, there are processes where metal blocks go in and a whole monoframe chassis comes out. Taking that and saying "I want a ventilator assembly" is pretty much insane- besides reworking the entire line to support the new process, you've got to wire everything up, test it, inspect it, make sure everything is up to OSHA standards, etcetera etcetera, etcetera. Going from producing one thing with a high amount of automation to another that doesn't have any similar parts is insanely difficult. Not saying it isn't worth it, but it might be better to go to the factories that are already producing the stuff we need- ventilators, masks, respiratiors, tests- and seeing if there are any bottlenecks that could be removed. The best way? Have enough stuff on hand to actually handle a crisis. Too bad prepping for a rainy day doesn't really align with maxing out dividends and payoffs.
- bmulholland 7y agoGermany ordered 10,000 ventilators from a domestic manufacturer, though with delivery "over the next year" so it's unclear what the schedule will be.
- baxtr 7y agoMore like „within several weeks“... https://www.welt.de/wirtschaft/article206603525/Beatmungsgeraete-Draeger-soll-10-000-Stueck-in-kuerzester-Zeit-bauen.html https://www.welt.de/wirtschaft/article206603525/Beatmungsger...
- Mvandenbergh 7y agoSo there are four main ways for breathing machines to be powered: 1) By compressed air from a wall port (majority of ICU machines) 2) With bellows (anesthesia machines) 3) Turbine, either dynamic or constant speed with a proportional valve (home use or patient transport) 4) Piston Let's assume that we use a pneumatic device driven by centrally purified air as that is simplest. The parts then are: -Gas blending to mix O2 and HP air -A fast, precise, and accurate proportional solenoid valve. This turns the constant pressure into the desired waveform -another valve for controlling exhalation pressure. Can be another proportional solenoid, alternatively a manually adjustable valve to ensure constant minimum end exhalation pressure (PEEP) -Flow sensor (range of options, typically variable orifice or hot wire anemometer but other type exist) -Pressure sensor (silicon waver transducer) -Overpressure valve -O2 sensor (highly desirable, arguably you can estimate from O2 blending settings but that will work better on a very well characterised design which this would not be. Anyway O2 sensors are widely used so this will never be a constraint. -Piping to connect it all together -A control and alarm system to drive desired waveform based on user settings and sensors -Patient circuit: Humidifier / heat exchanger, patient valve (one time use), viral filters for intake and exhalation air (one time use), ET tubes (one time use) Probably the limiting factor as far as parts go are the valves since this is a niche application. Here's the problem: as a civilisation, if we had to make a hundred million vents by the end of the year it would be easy. Expensive, sure, but not that hard in an emergency. It is much harder to make an extra 50,000 in a few weeks because it just takes time to turn the machinery of mass production in a different direction.
- butler14 7y agoIn the UK, there's talk of Jaguar Land Rover, JCB and F1 engineering teams all making contributions towards the production of ventilators
- mellavora 7y agoI keep seeing people asking "Why can't we just quickly spin up technology X?" where this is here ventilators, otherwise vaccines, etc... without much awareness of how much specialization goes into almost every aspect of every job. Hell, even fast-food workers-- a skilled grill operator at McDonalds -- take time to train up. No, we cannot quickly undo the 20 years of systematic dismantling of our core infrastructure. We are in for a very rude wake-up call. And then, once we are awake, and are dealing with our new realization on the complexity of our economy, where every part depends on every other part functioning, and trying to get this restarted with a significant number of the parts NOT working... Then we realize that the economy is embedded in an even bigger system called "life on earth" which we have degraded and destroyed on a much larger scale than our economy. If you think the weakness in our society which the virus uncovers are a big deal, you simply lack the full picture.
- mistermann 7y ago> I keep seeing people asking "Why can't we just quickly spin up technology X?" where this is here ventilators, otherwise vaccines, etc...without much awareness of how much specialization goes into almost every aspect of every job. Hell, even fast-food workers-- a skilled grill operator at McDonalds -- take time to train up. > No, we cannot quickly undo the 20 years of systematic dismantling of our core infrastructure. We are in for a very rude wake-up call. Wait a minute. I was with you up until the end of "...take time to train up.", but I've lost the plot between there and "No, we cannot quickly undo the 20 years of systematic dismantling of our core infrastructure." To me, these seem like two extremely different issues, but it appears that you see them as being ~equivalent, or am I misunderstanding? > And then, once we are awake, and are dealing with our new realization on the complexity of our economy, where every part depends on every other part functioning... Agree, but I just wanted to add my $.02: Be careful when using "awake" - this is a very, very tricky word. To say it can be be deceptive is a major understatement. > Then we realize that the economy is embedded in an even bigger system called "life on earth" which we have degraded and destroyed on a much larger scale than our economy. I see your point, but again: for specific definitions of "degraded" and "destroyed", maybe. And even if so, does this have bearing on this particular issue? If not, it should not be part of the analysis. It confuses people, and this situation is confusing enough. > If you think the weakness in our society which the virus uncovers are a big deal, you simply lack the full picture. I assume you meant "...are not a big deal..."?
- jamessb 7y agoThe department of Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy has put out a call for business that could help to supply ventilators or ventilator components [1]. Large manufacturers including Vauxhall and Airbus are apparently planning to produce parts [2]. [1]: https://ktn-uk.co.uk/news/call-for-businesses-to-help-make-nhs-ventilators https://ktn-uk.co.uk/news/call-for-businesses-to-help-make-n... [2]: https://www.theguardian.com/business/2020/mar/17/uk-manufacturers-regear-factories-build-ventilators-nhs https://www.theguardian.com/business/2020/mar/17/uk-manufact...