8 ms·
I’m more and more worried this is an overreaction, even ignoring the economic impact. Look at the projections on page 19: https://www.imperial.ac.uk/media/imp
by hedora 7y ago
I’m more and more worried this is an overreaction, even ignoring the economic impact. Look at the projections on page 19:
https://www.imperial.ac.uk/media/imperial-college/medicine/sph/ide/gida-fellowships/Imperial-College-COVID19-NPI-modelling-16-03-2020.pdf https://www.imperial.ac.uk/media/imperial-college/medicine/s...
They seem to have picked the green line and not the orange line. Hopefully they’re planning for intermittent social distancing, or have some other medium term plan.
- glofish 7y agothe 25 million just does not seem realistic.
- cycrutchfield 7y agoIt's pretty realistic in an unconstrained spreading scenario. That's exponential growth for you.
- ajross 7y agoThe H1N1 epidemic in 2009 was objectively less contagious and less dangerous than COVID-19. In comparison, it grew mostly uncontained and eventually infected about a billion people. If COVID-19 was allowed to do exactly that we'd be looking at 10M fatalities, and realistically it would infect more people (being more novel than a mere flu). The 25M number doesn't seem realistic because every country that has had a COVID-19 outbreak has freaked out trying to control it, and either succeeded via very expensive means or (in most cases) hasn't had the outbreak grow far enough to know whether or not they've failed.
- wolco 7y agoUsing the billion figure best case is 40 million not accounting for which countries would be hit the hardest which would increase the rate as the systems get overwhelmed.
- stevenwoo 7y agoDo you reject the SIR mathematical model for all infectious disease or the numbers chosen for the constants for covid-19 or some other reason?
- wolco 7y agoI thought so too then I did the calculations and realized it could be larger if Italy's death rates transfer.
- maxk42 7y agoThe US death rate is 1.49% and dropping rapidly.
- cycrutchfield 7y agoOnly because the number of new cases is rising rapidly. "Death rate" is not a meaningful metric. What you want is "case fatality rate".
- therealdrag0 7y agoWe haven't overwhelmed our healthcare system yet.
- Animats 7y agoIt's just outside most people's experience. Look at the graph.[1] Those are actuals, not predictions. This gets 10x bigger each week. The US is 12 days behind Italy. US at 10,000 now. 100,000 next week. 1 million in two weeks. The lockdown may slow that down. Probably not enough. [1] https://www.ft.com/content/a26fbf7e-48f8-11ea-aeb3-955839e06441 https://www.ft.com/content/a26fbf7e-48f8-11ea-aeb3-955839e06...
- usaar333 7y agoI don't see any scenario where you could hit 60% of the population that fast. I mean sure, if you held up the same R0, yes, that math works out, but people aren't trees. They'll voluntarily socially distance, dropping R0 significantly.
- dredmorbius 7y agoI wrote a basic model in Awk for US and global "RoW" (ex-China) spread of COVID-19. Both sets of confirmed-case projections (for US see comments for the mathematically correct model) are tracking remarkably close. Lagging slightly below, but only just. (Deaths have trended higher than projection for RoW, lower for US, but the delta remains only a few days.) https://joindiaspora.com/posts/73d4e930421d0138028e002590d8e506 https://joindiaspora.com/posts/73d4e930421d0138028e002590d8e... Exponential growth boggles the mind. Script source: https://pastebin.com/raw/j89ZUdVq https://pastebin.com/raw/j89ZUdVq
- rolltiide 7y agothe medium term plan is more capacity and equipment at hospitals the short term plan alone will flatten the curve too much, if successful, and we simply dont have confirmations about whether we build immunity or the virus dies out, so without those features the short term plan being the long term plan or a recurring plan (even if we build immunity but we flattened too much, then clusters reemerge). But in conjunction with the medium term plan and most people not being reinfected its the best solution long term plan either way is a vaccine, effective treatment edit: can you engineers please tell me and the world what some of you disagree with about this information? this isn't the place to write a dissertation on every edge case necessary to explain whats going on, and the lack of that dissertation doesn't undermine the point or utility of what is written
- ocschwar 7y agoGermany is already starting to administer antibody titers. We will know pretty damned soon how many of us have obtained immunity to the virus.
- adrr 7y agoThe people with immunity will be a critical asset. They can work grocery stores and delivery services.
- rolltiide 7y agoThat's great but every day of not implementing the short term plan exponentially rises the strain on the hospital system. Nothing I said refutes the soon-ness of information coming from all around the world, its still not here though.
- option 7y agoI’m worried it is now becoming political and testing “how much we can do”. What we really need is widespread testing
- MiroF 7y agoWidespread testing? How does that help without any sort of transmission control measures? What is up with this obsession with testing? We need to lower R0 and scale up medical infrastructure. Elimination at this point is a fantasy. To be clear, testing is important. But to suggest that it should be the priority over isolation and distancing seems misguided.
- option 7y agoif you have no reliable data you are shooting in the dark with mounting consequences
- MiroF 7y agoSure, but we have more than enough evidence to show that emergency room visits are increasing and emergency room deaths are mounting. Control then test.
- James_Henry 7y agoI think that when there are calls for widespread testing it is a call for a system similar to what you see in S. Korea where there is a lot of testing, very quick contact tracing, and alerts about positive cases. This allows for lowering the R0 by isolating fewer people and letting more people continue to work.
- MiroF 7y agoFWIW, many of those countries that have been touted as testing+tracing success cases are now reporting patterns consistent with uncontrolled exponential growth of the virus in the past few days (although not in SK yet) [1]: https://twitter.com/mattyglesias/status/1240740763752902670 https://twitter.com/mattyglesias/status/1240740763752902670
- scotty79 7y agoDepends on level of enforcement. I heard one criticism of the model used in this paper is that it doesn't account for superspreaders. Besides, it's better to contain it 'too much' because then you can loosen restrictions a bit and still have managable number of cases, than not contain it enough and have run away process you won't be able contain even with most severe measures you are able to enforce.
- throwaway490194 7y agoExactly. People who bought large volumes of medical supplies early hoping to get rich are highly incentivized to spread it widely.
- kube-system 7y agoThe people spreading this mostly don't even know they have it. The super-spreaders here are most likely people who are doing one or more of: * are ignoring medical advice * have contact with many people * are asymptomatic or incubating * don't follow best hygiene practices
- moftz 7y agoI don't know why takeout at restaurants is still an option. All it takes is one asymptomatic cook to infect hundreds. I'd rather eat canned beans for the next six months than eat a virus-filled burger.
- kube-system 7y agoI'm guessing you're getting downvoted because the CDC says: > Currently there is no evidence to support transmission of COVID-19 associated with food. Before preparing or eating food it is important to always wash your hands with soap and water for 20 seconds for general food safety. But, given that: 1. Takeout food comes in a container which we know can transport the disease, and 2. My local pizza joint has a hard enough time getting a good health department score as it is I am going to be cooking at home for a while until I have a better idea about how this is going to play out in my own community.
- ajross 7y agoAs has been explained almost ad nauseum at this point: diseases grow exponentially. The number of possible solutions that explode to infinity (well, to saturation) and those that dwindle rapidly to zero utterly dwarfs the number of solutions "in the middle". Fitting an exponential curve to go straight through an "almost miss" scenario is really hard, basically. Essentially: either this disease overwhelms us, in which case most people you know will have had it and multiple people you know will have died, or (statistically) no one you know will have gotten sick and the whole thing will look like a nothingburger. But it wasn't. It was a disease that would have killed tens of millions if unchecked, we just got it under control. At least, that's what we hope.
- wtvanhest 7y agoI came to this thread for this comment. It’s a really unintuitive point, and I think someone needs to create some type of visual representation of it so it sinks in. IMO, this thing is a trap for politicians. A true lose lose for them.
- thereisnospork 7y agoThere has to be an endgame to these measures that's not 'wait for a vaccine'. A few weeks is tolerable[0], but what happens when early April comes around and new cases are still popping up? The provisions will have to start unwinding or this could go from an economic hiccup to an economic catastrophe. [0] less so for some.
- ajross 7y agoWhat's the alternative? Let 10M people die to get back 15% of world GDP? (Both reasonable guesses at pessimal death counts and recessions, IMHO). The hope is that it will work everywhere like it seems to have in Hubei and Korea -- near-zero new case counts and a regime of continued care, a few extra regulations, and pervasive testing. And it might work. But if it doesn't, yeah: we should turtle, accept the economic catastrophe, and wait for a vaccine. Would anyone sane argue otherwise?
- 7y ago
- kyawzazaw 7y agoI have no qualifications to speak on this. Not sure if you do, too. My interpretation is overreaction should be what's done to mitigate the pandemic for the foreseeable future. Right now, almost every country is playing catch-up.
- nopinsight 7y agoIf California’s “stay-at-home” order works and they extensively test everyone with suspected symptoms from now on, CA could be well on its way toward containment within a couple of months (not including ’imported’ cases from other states/countries). I read that the paper cited does not include the effects of isolating cases and contact tracing to suppress new infections. Added: Waiting period will result in asymptomatic people showing symptoms and they can then be tested and isolated. That is why the stay-at-home practice is useful during the incubation period. If the actual number of cases in CA is not too large and within family infections can be controlled, then part of everyday life can resume in about 1 month.
- vanniv 7y agoI'm not sure that everyone staying at home for "several months" is sustainable. Actually, I'm sure it is not.
- azemetre 7y agoWhy wouldn’t it be sustainable? As long as the supply chains hold I don’t see why it isn’t doable. There will be a severe economic impact but the alternative is worse.
- bgorman 7y agoThat's a questionable assumption. Lots of business are basically being ordered to go bankrupt.
- vanniv 7y agoUnless you have the military enforce the lockdown, people will eventually refuse to starve quietly in their houses and will brave the "terrifying" 1% chance of death from COVID to go back to being alive. Honestly, with the governor this morning toying with "about 18 months", we are agreeing to give up more than 1% of our life just to reduce the risk of the 1% chance of death. If you do order the military to enforce it, you are likely to end up with a civil war. Some people will eventually resist, and then either the army starts firing on Americans or they let people go on with their lives. On a more personal note, the mental health cost of perfect social isolation is already getting to me, and frankly, I don't think I would survive more than a bare couple of months, even if the magic goods fairy delivered me every essential item I could ever want in infinite quantity.
- bosswipe 7y agoIn a way we have an experiment going on between California and New York since New York has so far declined to issue a shelter in place order. We'll really start to see if the curves diverge in another week, but new cases in New York already seem to be surging ahead of California.
- hkmurakami 7y agoWell they're talking and arguing about it at least. https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/ny-gov-cuomo-says-no-new-york-city-s-shelter-n1162911 https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/ny-gov-cuomo-says-no-ne...
- wideasleep1 7y agoNow Trump's tweet a few days ago makes sense...there was broad agreement across governors would enact shelter-in-place at a given benchmark, and Cuomo signaled otherwise...
- usaar333 7y agoDidn't NY (Cuomo) argue that their restrictions are almost exactly the same as California's? In fact, in what way is NY more permissive at this point?
- shadowtree 7y agoRead the f*cking thing to the end! "Perhaps our most significant conclusion is that mitigation is unlikely to be feasible without emergency surge capacity limits of the UK and US healthcare systems being exceeded many times over. In the most effective mitigation strategy examined, which leads to a single, relatively short epidemic (case isolation, household quarantine and social distancing of the elderly), the surge limits for both general ward and ICU beds would be exceeded by at least 8-fold under the more optimistic scenario for critical care requirements that we examined.In addition, even if all patients were able to be treated, we predict there would still be in the order of 250,000 deaths in GB, and 1.1-1.2 million in the US. ... We therefore conclude that epidemic suppression is the only viable strategy at the current time. " ONE MILLION DEAD AMERICANS. You shit your pants after 3000 died at 9/11.
- casefields 7y ago40,000 die on our streets every year. Our pants are quite dry.
- shadowtree 7y agoYou're proud of that? This is an exogenous event, which will kill a lot of people in short time, on top of the usual circumstances. A natural disaster. A war. 3000 Americans died, a Trillion USD was spent on two wars, civil liberties were irrevocably destroyed (DHS, etc). The USA never suffered casualties of 1+mil ever. Ask the old Europeans how that feels.
- leftyted 7y agoA virus isn't comparable to people hijacking planes and flying them into buildings. For one thing, it should be easy to prevent the latter whereas it's far from clear whether there's much we can do about the former.
- mellow2020 7y ago> A virus isn't comparable to people hijacking planes and flying them into buildings. Being dead is absolutely comparable with being dead though, no matter what lead there. It's the absence of a person that matters, to the people who miss them, not what people removed from that think about it in the abstract. I lost my father through a completely stupid accident, made possible through carelessness on his behalf I think. If he had been murdered by someone, I would have felt a lot of hate, and that would have sucked and damaged me no doubt -- but the grief of missing someone is still the same, and I'd say the difference between murder and an accident are both tiny pebbles compared to a person being gone. Even if he had died to save 1000 million people, I would miss him exactly the same.
- jeremyjh 7y agoThey are assuming suppression measures are only in place for five months and then letup at once uniformly. I don't see a justification for that assumption. I doubt it will play out that way. I would would expect to see people fatigue on the distancing, governments to relax orders as the case numbers drop low, and then they'll be rushed into place again when the numbers start climbing again. We shall all become very bored of hearing about the disease cycle because it will be going on for the next 12 months or more.
- batmansmk 7y agoWhat would be the economic impact of 1 million dead? Twice WW2 in only 6 months? Would the US democracy survive it? I don't think so.
- 0xffff2 7y ago~3 million people die every year in the US. Even if you assume no overlap (which doesn't seem realistic), I'm having a really hard time seeing how a 33% increase is the death of US democracy (if it's even still alive).
- usaar333 7y agoEconomically - if it all happened immediately, probably less than you think given it's mostly concentrated in an older age group past working age. Second order effects would be huge though and you'd still take all sorts of economic and social hits. I don't see why democracy would die. Spanish flu was far worse.
- jacob019 7y agoWhat exactly is the alternative to democracy? Are we suddenly going to become authoritarian? Are you suggesting that we will devolve into anarchy, branch off into warring clans of hunter-gatherer's, substance farmers, and roving gangs of bandits?