6 ms·
Where did your middle-class customers go?
- bugsy 16y agoI don't agree with the article's cut off point that $50k household pre-tax income is middle class. 2 parents, 2 kids making $50k is $36k after tax. Mortgage on a small house is $1800/month. Cars are expensive too, add $400 a month for payments on that. Food prices have doubled the last couple years. Average family can't afford health care ($12k/yr cost for 60% coverage plan for 2 parents 2 kids according to Congressional Budget Office), housing and food on that income.
- joe_the_user 16y agoIndeed, I don't think you can judge comfort level or disposable income by raw income level very well regardless. I have a friend who grew up in relative poverty. Her family had ten kids closely spaced together including twins. Her father made $150k/year with no benefits and her mother was a house-wife. I had things a good deal easier just because my parents only had two kid even though their income was less.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoFood prices have doubled the last couple years. No, they are up 6.7% since Jan 1 2008. http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/CPIUFDSL http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/CPIUFDSL
- michaelchisari 16y agoFood prices have risen twice as much as inflation. So, no, they haven't doubled, but their rate of increase has outpaced the rest of the economy. And with wages stagnating in relationship to inflation, this is a cause for concern.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoInflation over the same period was 4.1%. http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/CPIAUCSL http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/CPIAUCSL So no, not "double inflation" either. Wages and salaries went up 4.9% over the same period. http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/ECIWAG http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/ECIWAG
- michaelchisari 16y agoSo no, not "double inflation" either. Alright, 163% of inflation, if you prefer to be pedantic. Wages and salaries went up 4.9% over the same period. As always, this only shows part of the story. This is the average for wages and salaries for private industry workers. If you look at median household income, it's stagnated. http://economix.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/09/10/a-decade-with-no-income-gain/ http://economix.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/09/10/a-decade-with-n... Median household income in 1998 was $51,295 (adjusted). Median household income in 2009 was $50,303. So we are seeing a stagnation of income, adjusted for inflation. On top of that, food prices are increasing 163% faster than inflation. Now you can post links to isolated stats, and attempt to handwave away the issue, but it is an issue, and each year that food prices eclipse inflation builds towards increasing social and economic problems for those in lower income brackets.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoIf food prices increased 6.7% (which, BTW, is a lot less than 100%, the number bugsy claimed), but CPI only increased 4.1%, that means other goods and services must have increased less than 4.1%. You have now changed the reference period, and you are also looking at a different quantity. Wages and salaries have actually increased 28% since 2001 (data doesn't go back to 1998). See my previous timeseries. Household income is a separate quantity - it can be raised or lowered by a variety of factors. For example, it can go down as household size decreases or as per-household hours worked go down. That's not the same thing as a wage decrease. Also, your time period seems a bit cherry picked - you are comparing the top of the last bubble to the bottom of the current bubble.
- bugsy 16y agoThose feds number are cooked. They replace steak prices with hamburger prices and say it is the same thing to show there is no inflation, while they have the printing presses running 24/7. Food prices have doubled based on the receipts I enter into Excel. Everyone should do this and find that the Fed's numbers are totally fraudulent. Knowing this, you can then make better business decisions, such as to get rid of cash as fast as you can.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoThey replace steak prices with hamburger prices This seems like the sort of thing they can only do once. Just curious, do you know when they did this? As for my food expenses, month to month variation is bigger than any increase. Which is surprising, seeing as I've been actively trying to eat more for the past year. But I guess healthy food is cheaper than the crap I was eating two years ago.
- stephenbez 16y agoI was curious so I googled it and found this: http://www.shadowstats.com/article/consumer_price_index http://www.shadowstats.com/article/consumer_price_index Apparently it happened early in the Clinton administration. Quoting: The Boskin/Greenspan argument was that when steak got too expensive, the consumer would substitute hamburger for the steak, and that the inflation measure should reflect the costs tied to buying hamburger versus steak, instead of steak versus steak. Of course, replacing hamburger for steak in the calculations would reduce the inflation rate, but it represented the rate of inflation in terms of maintaining a declining standard of living. Cost of living was being replaced by the cost of survival. The old system told you how much you had to increase your income in order to keep buying steak. The new system promised you hamburger, and then dog food, perhaps, after that.
- bugsy 16y agoRight, the steak/hamburger is one of the well known examples and certainly not the only one nor is it an isolated example. It is the way things are done; cooking the books is the official state policy. The adjustments are done across the board and have resulted in massive "savings" (more money for war yay) regarding Social Security payments and such that are indexed to their official inflation rates.
- bryanlarsen 16y ago$50K is listed as the absolute lower bound for middle class. Any lower bound is debatable, but it's about right when there are almost as many that don't fit as do. Many households at $50K aren't middle class, as you demonstrated, but there are lots of households with $40K of income that could be considered middle class. Most single guys/ladies with $40K of income are probably solidly lower-middle class. And families with an $600 mortgage payment instead of an $1800 mortgage could also be considered middle class at $50k. And with current interest rates (3% floating), $600/month will buy half of the houses in the midwest because $140K is the median house price in the midwest.
- roboneal 16y agoConsidering the article cites Census data broadly collected across the country - not sure where you are getting those mortgage/food price numbers? $1800 would buy you a 5 bedroom/2.5 bath/2400sf house in Houston. A "small" house for a couple making $50K gross would run easily under $1000/mo. While prices are higher, I'm not paying double over 2008 prices....otherwise I'd be paying $6 for a gallon of milk or $4 for a loaf of bread.
- anamax 16y ago> Mortgage on a small house is $1800/month. $1800/month is a >$300k 30 year mortgage. > Cars are expensive too, add $400 a month for payments on that. That's absurd. It's not hard to stay well under $20k new and used is even cheaper. Keep it for at least 7 years and $400/month is two cars and change.
- roboneal 16y agoSafe to say that anyone carrying an iPad while talking on an iPhone sipping a Starbucks is middle class. In many, ways middle class is better defined as access to disposable income (at least from a marketing/retail perspective). What defines disposable income varies at all income levels, regions, social situation, etc.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoThe article makes a major flaw. It equates income with consumption, assuming that if people are not earning money, they are not spending it. This assumption is utterly false. ftp://ftp.bls.gov/pub/special.requests/ce/standard/2009/income.txt Households earning $39,999 or less tend to have consumption exceeding income. For example, households with income in [$5000,$9999] tend to consume about $18k. Presumably the difference between earned income and expenses is made up for with credit and welfare.
- borism 16y agoPresumably the difference between earned income and expenses is made up for with credit and welfare. umm, why would credit and welfare not be counted as income? Credit is (presumably) just a future income. And welfare is very real current income.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoWhen the BLS and other government agencies talk about "income", they generally mean "earned income". Welfare is not earned income, neither is credit.
- borism 16y agook, thanks.
- fleitz 16y agoYou can be pretty much sure that any article that discusses the 'middle-class' is politcally motivated. It's ill-defined and redefined for any purpose. The term 'middle-class' is practically meaningless, except as a mechanism to cause the reader to identify with the the group supposedly being victimized. It's purely an appeal to ethos and pathos. That top 5%? Thats us. Never forget it. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Household_income_in_the_United_States http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Household_income_in_the_United_... A couple who lives together making 75K each are in the top 5% of household income in the US. That's not even an incredibly high programmer salary. So as to where did your middle class customers go? Hacker News. As to why the top 5% have so much wealth, well it's by starting early. A year after I got out of high school I had a techsupport job for 36K / year I was making on par with my parents who had 25-30 years experience each, 3 years later and I was no longer a renter. Starting early and building a nice egg early on allows you to take advantage of compounding interest. I had a house at the time that most people were getting out of school with a pile of debt. People in North America have a tonne of disposable income, look at McDonalads, Starbucks, etc. They do very good business trading on disposable income (consumer surplus). You don't need either of those companies, you can make a coffee/burger yourself and save a pile. In fact you can make yourself a fairly decent retirement for a latte a day.
- jbooth 16y agoThat is indeed us. Why we have so much wealth is due to broader economic factors. Add up robotics, automation, outsourcing, there really isn't a role for middle class labor anymore. You're either programming the machines or you're working at wal-mart. Which is all kinds of medium-long term concerning once you start wondering what happens when there's no middle class anymore. If you're programming because you like it (most of us), then you're just lucky to be where we are. I'd still be doing it if it paid crap, it just so happens that it pays extremely well right now. Don't let it go to your head :)
- unshift 16y ago> In fact you can make yourself a fairly decent retirement for a latte a day. not really. $3 * (40*365) = $43,800. in order to save $1M over 40 years, you need to save $2083 a month. and $1M is not a glorious retirement.