8 ms·
Has the Covid-19 response gone too far?
- pseudolus 7y agoIoannidis paper: https://www.statnews.com/2020/03/17/a-fiasco-in-the-making-as-the-coronavirus-pandemic-takes-hold-we-are-making-decisions-without-reliable-data/ https://www.statnews.com/2020/03/17/a-fiasco-in-the-making-a... Lipsitch response: https://www.statnews.com/2020/03/18/we-know-enough-now-to-act-decisively-against-covid-19/ https://www.statnews.com/2020/03/18/we-know-enough-now-to-ac...
- acqq 7y agoAlso, the graphics from Italy, 5 days ago: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Is_COVID-19_like_a_flu%3F_ENG.png https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Is_COVID-19_like_a_flu%3F... The x axis is a week number, the bars represent the numbers of cases and dead per week. And now it's worse: they already have more dead than China has, and the increase of number of cases and dead still doesn't slow down enough, in spite of the measures that they started to apply (the lockdown of some areas since February 22, of the whole country since March 10). Approximately the number of dead at the moment doubles every four days -- if that continues for only one month more there will be a half of million who have died, and then 4 days later, a million. That's how fast that goes. Regarding the "we don't have data" claim: it can seem to be true only when the US intentionally ignores the information coming from the rest of the world. There are indeed countries that have made orders of magnitude more tests than the US (making the number of tests performed in the US mostly irrelevant for this discussion) and the resulting growth of numbers of cases and dead are very steadily independent of the number of tests done, which means that the only numbers that matter are the growth numbers, i.e. that the numbers of cases can't be an artifact of the measurements. There is no indication whatsoever that the growth speed can change without applied measures. The data is available, one just has to want to use it.
- war1025 7y agoSomething interesting I heard tonight, that I hope someone will look into more, is that there were reports from Italian doctors way back in October / November timeframe of a "strange pneumonia affecting predominately the elderly". The implication was that coronavirus has been in widespread circulation for longer than people realize, which they theorized was part of why Italy has been unable to contain it. Normally I'd just dismiss that as rumor, but it was on NPR, and I feel like they normally at least try to filter out the complete nonsense.
- creato 7y agoI haven't heard that, but I have read (in a source I can't find at the moment) that the first known patient also had bacterial pneumonia and so was misdiagnosed for several days, during which time several healthcare workers became infected, who in turn infected who knows how many. I'm sure the rate of initial spread, when the number of transmission events is low, is very much subject to chance/luck.
- MikeAmelung 7y agoThis has been part of my thinking for a while. A lot of people's models seem to be based on the idea that they know when the first actual infection arrived in a particular area. Given that a lot of people seem to have almost no symptoms at all, that doesn't seem very likely.
- acqq 7y agoLook at the graph from my parent message again -- that info that you cite (coronavirus being active in November) would completely not match what we already know. We know extremely good how fast it spreads and how fast people start to die: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2020_coronavirus_pandemic_on_cruise_ships#Diamond_Princess https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2020_coronavirus_pandemic_on_c... "On 20 January 2020, an 80-year-old passenger from Hong Kong, China, embarked in Yokohama, and disembarked in Hong Kong on 25 January. On 1 February, six days after leaving the ship, he visited a Hong Kong hospital, where he tested positive for SARS-CoV-2.[47][48]" "On 4 February, the authorities announced positive test results for SARS-CoV-2 for ten people on board, the cancellation of the cruise, and that the ship was entering quarantine." "Two passengers died on 20 February[78] and a third on 23 February, all three Japanese citizens in their 80s.[79] A fourth passenger, an elderly Japanese man, was reported on 25 February to have died.[80] The fifth fatality, a British national in his 70s, died on 28 February.[81] A 78-year-old Australian national, who was evacuated from the ship, died on 1 March in Australia, making him the sixth.[82] A Hong Kong national from the ship died on 6 March, making him the seventh coronavirus-related death from the ship.[83]" With the doubling time of 4 days, if the first case had been dying in November and nothing had been done to prevent the spread now there would be million of dead in Italy now.
- blauditore 7y agoWhat concerns me the most is that many people fail to take a balanced stance. It seems I only hear extreme opinions, but perhaps this has to do with the fact that those with moderate views are not as loud and involved.
- loopz 7y agoI prefer informed stance, like from pandemic health experts.
- threatofrain 7y agoIt's more important to hear from well-reputed voices who are staking their reputations on their statements.
- lmilcin 7y agoI think people should have right to their opinions but voicing some is sometimes just plainly dangerous. Yes, we know it works. China has allowed the disease to spread, yet they have instantly turned it around by introducing extreme measures. Just watch this very informative piece: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mCa0JXEwDEk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mCa0JXEwDEk If you are not convinced extreme measures are worth it, just take a look at Italy which still can't get a grip on its population the way Chinese authorities were able to (being authoritative state has some advantages sometimes). The plague has barely started and they already ran out of space to keep bodies. If you are of another opinion (that it has barely started) the current statistics show that only half of percent of population is diagnosed (https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/ https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/) and if you look at logarithmic graph it barely shows any signs of slowdown. We know there are some asymptomatic cases but only at most 3-4 per one requiring hospitalization which means at most 2-3 percent of population is actually ill. So yes, it just barely started. South Korea is good example where early, aggressive hunting of cases before they spread brings good results, there was an article on HN recently. For this reason I think educating people that this is serious matter and we should all refrain from doing things that can spread the disease, if not for our own health then for public safety, is everybody's responsibility now. This does not mean we have to panic. We just need to understand what is and what is not reasonable prevention. Think about this: if everybody stayed home for two weeks this would mostly be over. I understand we can't all stay home. Not everybody has a job that allows it. But a lot of people can and the ones that have to move around can do a lot of sane things to make it much harder for disease to spread.
- dilyevsky 7y agoIt’s not two weeks. If you want to completely eradicate it you need at least three weeks after number of new cases flatlined completely then clamp extra hard on any remaining pockets
- lmilcin 7y agoThat's why I wrote "it will be mostly over". In two weeks most cases would resolve either way (sorry for being so insensitive..) And yes, you made an excellent point. The point of not moving around is not just prevent spreading the virus but it also lets authorities to clamp down and focus on remaining pockets, which is just as important.
- zozbot234 7y agoI'm fed up with this "it's just a cold" meme. If COVID-19 is "just a cold" or "just a flu", why are ICU's in places like Italy and elsewhere so overwhelmed with severe pneumonia cases?
- th2020032010 7y agoThrow away for the following reasons: this isn’t a point of view I share but I do know that the emotions will take over on this answer, I like my karma but I also don’t want this to be available under my original name here for future out of context quotations. Maybe the reason is that a large number of the people who are dying today are already on borrowed time. Consider this as an option, just for a moment. The medical advancements in the last 100 years increased the survival chances of many who would not be here already, if not said advancements. Natural selection exists for a reason. We, as a species, are actively working against natural selection, definitely on the medical front. Thus what we are maybe witnessing today is a natural selection in action.
- scotty79 7y agoWhy didn't they all die last flu season at the same rate as they are dying now from covid19?
- th2020032010 7y agoBecause the normal flu does not kill at a rate of covid-19. The post above does not try to dispute that covid-19 is what it is and is not suggesting that it is a normal flu. We are definitely dealing with something different than normal flu. But you have to consider that majority of the population will go through this without showing symptoms.
- StavrosK 7y agoWhat you're saying is "a disease kills people who were going to die from it anyway". No, those people weren't going to die if not for COVID-19, and you can say the same thing for any disease, tautologically.
- hnburnsy 7y agoFrom the UK... 'As of 9am on 19 March 2020, 64,621 people have been tested in the UK, of which 61,352 were confirmed negative and 3,269 were confirmed positive. As of 1pm 144 patients in the UK who tested positive for coronavirus (COVID-19) have died.' So that 5% positive and 0.2% death rate of those tested. Seems likely that they would only be testing the worst cases. When I see data like this but see estimates in the news of 1-2 million deaths in the US it makes me shake my head.
- acqq 7y agoLook at the statistics of each day: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2020_coronavirus_pandemic_in_the_United_Kingdom https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2020_coronavirus_pandemic_in_t... In the UK the number of infected doubles every 3 days. The number of dead at the moment doubles every 2 days. Now starting from 3300 infected today, and 144 dead today, calculate the numbers in just one month. If you think that the growth won't continue if nothing is done, compare with the equivalent data from Italy: just 15 days ago, there were 2020-03-04 3089 infected 107 dead today: 2020-03-19 41035 infected 3405 dead and note that they even tried to do the lockdown first of the critical areas and later of the whole country.
- hnburnsy 7y agoThanks, do you know the number tested in Italy?
- acqq 7y agoLike I've said, the number of tested is irrelevant for the estimate of the future, as the growth speed is stable across many countries, where the number of tests hugely differ: US 37824 tests 11,604 cases 161 dead UK 56221 tests 3,269 cases 144 dead But in all countries the doubling time is also around every 3 days. It's very stable information and allows for easy estimates: 30 days of such doubling makes 10 of them, or the factor 2 ^ 10 = 1024 times more. Even if the doubling time (for new deaths) increases to 4 days (the number that can now be derived from Italy) the resulting factor in 30 days changes to 2 ^ 7.5 = 181 which still results in almost 30000 deaths in the next month in each of UK and US... as long as something very resolute isn't done to prevent the growth. But the problem isn't just the dead alone. It's that the number of those that need the hospital treatment is much higher than those that die, and that is when the hospitals aren't overloaded. These numbers are huge. See my other post here for just the number of needed intensive care beds -- those are especially hard to increase.
- scotty79 7y ago> "... Tell people to stay at their homes, get depressed, commit suicide, domestic violence. Who knows? Child abuse, children losing their education, ..." This is so funny. It kind of reminds me warnings about anticipated dangers of early trains: Critics of early steam-spewing locomotives, for example, thought “that women’s bodies were not designed to go at 50 miles an hour,” and worried that “[female passengers’] uteruses would fly out of [their] bodies as they were accelerated to that speed”—which, for the record, they did and will not. https://www.mentalfloss.com/article/67806/early-trains-were-thought-make-womens-uteruses-fly-out https://www.mentalfloss.com/article/67806/early-trains-were-...
- ggggtez 7y agoSo you are saying that you know for certain that keeping children home from school... cannot deprive them of an education? And keeping billions of people home, unable to socialize for months, with no end in sight... won't increase depression and anxiety? I'd like to know how you came to those conclusions... Frankly, the discussion about trains has nothing to do with anything, and should be disregarded. "Once upon a time someone was wrong about something, therefore this person is wrong about an unrelated thing" is silly.
- scotty79 7y agoI'm pretty sure kids will be fine despite spending more time with their parents. Vast differences in educational requirements of different countries assure me that possibly whole years of primary education are worth nothing. Besides, main concerns when it comes to closing schools clearly showed that schools are not so much places of education but most importantly storage pens for children so they don't bother their adults. People who seek knowledge have internet. And keeping billions at home to socialize just with people who live with them and with people who they can call and connect through internet won't increase on average depression and anxiety any more than going out currently does. I came to this conclusion by living at home as vast number of people do. His statements reminded me of the train scare because people had wild theories because they didn't know any better. This guy should have lived at home and should know it's not some hostile environment you are barely able to spend a night in but must escape every morning or you'll surely go insane. Home for most people is the most cozy place in the world and it's filled with their most favorite people, pets and items.
- salex89 7y agoAs far as I'm concerned, no, it hasn't. Writing from Serbia. At this point we're at around 105 confirmed ill, 0 deaths. My fiancée is an MD directly involved in trying to contain the spread. In out of the ordinary conditions people just lose common sense. Just think about driving in the rain. That's relatively benign, but when raining I just can't fathom sometimes WTF I'm seeing. Imagine something like a pandemic with yet unknown consequences and spread trend. We've seen hoarding, conflict, disregard towards public health, panic, leisure, the works... The current action items are: - No going outside for anyone older than 65 - Curfew from 20:00 to 05:00, with a possibility to prolong it - Closed borders - Airports shut down - No transportation between cities - Heavily limited public gathering - Military given law enforcement jurisdiction over civilians - Schools and universities shut down And you know what, even with this measures (although I think they are late), it's still very hard to put sense into people and grab this thing by its neck. Disclaimer: These measures are controversial in the country, because of the current (autocratic/oligarchic, opaque) political setup, which I am not fond of. There is a lack of transparency in this situation, also. But would I choose any different if asked ? Probably no.
- forkexec 7y agoYes. I don't think most people understand or respect the danger. When 10M-100M of people's lives are at risk, economic considerations must take a back seat to taking extreme/difficult measures that may seem like too much. It's better to overdo it and look overreacting than fail to take actions that could've saved many people's lives.
- majkinetor 7y agoCarantine has its own down sides. It may very well finish as worst solution. Massive H1N1 vaccination decade ago also had its own problem [1] and we are talking here about bunch of other things: effects on economy, domestic violence, etc. [1]: https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2015/07/why-pandemic-flu-shot-caused-narcolepsy https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2015/07/why-pandemic-flu-sho...
- logjammin 7y agoWhile I'm not defending the entirety of Ioannidis's argument (he makes a couple of mistakes; e.g. we know social distancing has some effect), it's important to point out what his central argument actually is, and how it's different from how the CBC article that purports to describe it. He doesn't assert that the policy response has gone too far; instead, he asserts that in the absence of good data on the pandemic, it's difficult to know whether the policy response is too much or not enough. In my view, on this point he's exactly right. From the actual Stat article: "At a time when everyone needs better information, from disease modelers and governments to people quarantined or just social distancing, we lack reliable evidence on how many people have been infected with SARS-CoV-2 or who continue to become infected. Better information is needed to guide decisions and actions of monumental significance and to monitor their impact." On "we lack reliable evidence": his point is that we don't have what we need, namely an accurate denominator in calculations of morbidity and mortality. "We don’t know if we are failing to capture infections by a factor of three or 300." He's not wrong! In epidemiology, accurately estimating, say, case fatality rates is notoriously difficult - especially in the middle (or the beginning!) of an epidemic. Given the issues we're all familiar with surrounding the lack of testing, this should come as no surprise. On "better information is needed": I don't think it's that far off-base to say that in the absence of (what asserts is) good data, it's impossible to calibrate policy responses to 2019-nCov so that you're saving as many lives as possible while doing as little damage to the rest of society (e.g. economy) as possible at the same time. This suggestion is eminently reasonable: "The most valuable piece of information for answering [questions about how many people will die of the coronavirus] would be to know the current prevalence of the infection in a random sample of a population and to repeat this exercise at regular time intervals to estimate the incidence of new infections.". Ioannidis (a physician and an epidemiologist) has made a career out of shedding light on science's mistakes and blind spots, and rightly so. I think the controversy surrounding this piece is overblown: the "fiasco" he's talking about is not a policy response fiasco, but an "evidence fiasco" - without knowing (or, in the US, even attempting to know) the true prevalence and incidence of coronavirus, it's impossible to say how well we're responding. * Edit / addendum: Counterpoints to Ioannidis to the effect of "well this is all moot anyway, when faced with high uncertainty about a really scary thing, you act as cautiously as possible regardless of the quality of your data" have a lot of merit. If you're a policymaker right now and you see what's happening in Italian ERs, hell yes you implement social distancing on a mass scale, maybe full lockdown / shelter in place, etc. But these two sets of tools aren't mutually exclusive; we have a lot of smart and capable people, plus a lot of money, to sic on each. We can allow policymakers to react strongly and cautiously right now to maybe save lives, while also setting up the sorts of basic epidemiological studies Ioannidis calls for: repeated random samples of a representative chunk of a population (e.g. the US population) with the ability to test everyone for corona (preferably using multiple different tests) in order to accurately estimate the denominator.
- jvanderbot 7y agoDon't say this. I want the world to learn that mass white-collar work-from-home is not debilitating.
- creato 7y agoI hate to break it to you, but this event as a whole is almost certainly going to be debilitating. WFH advocates will be lucky as hell if this event isn't used to say "WFH doesn't work" for decades. Personally, I'm WFHing now and I don't like it. Many things are more of a pain in the ass to get done despite me having access to top quality tools to do them with, and many day to day things are much harder and slower to do (quick chats with coworkers about work tasks).
- jvanderbot 7y agoWe're certainly facing economic ruin. But it is caused by shelter-in-place and mandatory closings. Those businesses set up for, supported by, and easily pivoting to employees who work from home will suffer less damage than those that require (by policy or nature of work), on-site staff. This is why I'm hopeful that WFH will be seen as a net positive, because it is a distributed system more difficult to knock out. WFH will not stave off economic ruin from COVID-19. But it may save many businesses from closing.
- nilkn 7y agoI'm sure you didn't mean it this way, but I think this is a very myopic take. For many, work-from-home is not an option, and the alternative is just being out of work completely. Many of my friends and family members outside of a few specific industries are already unemployed, moving in with parents (who themselves might be unemployed now), trying to figure out where next month's rent or mortgage payment is going to come from, etc. Given the vast economic devastation being invoked in order to contain the virus, it's worth taking a moment to ask whether we actually have enough information about its spread and mortality to properly calibrate our response when that response involves making decisions of truly monumental impact. Now, on the very small snippet of the COVID-19 response which involves technology workers and programmers working from home, I'm among them, and I'm already counting the days until I can get back in the office, as are at least half of my teammates. Most folks I work with do not like it so far. So I think the effect could be the opposite of what you're positing.
- happytoexplain 7y ago"Dares to ask" is such an awful, dishonest phrase. It's begging to derail/mischaracterize the conversation.
- theologic 7y ago1. The Ioannidis article is published here. It's a quick read. https://www.statnews.com/2020/03/17/a-fiasco-in-the-making-as-the-coronavirus-pandemic-takes-hold-we-are-making-decisions-without-reliable-data/ https://www.statnews.com/2020/03/17/a-fiasco-in-the-making-a... 2. Quite frankly, his argument makes little to no sense to me. He throws out numbers that are exceptionally low. Italy or Iran seems to be obvious experiments showing that no mitigation is a real issue. And we have alternative real world experiments. I worry that in our attempt to make sure we have validate models, we need critical thinking, not just "nobody knows." Ioannidis wrote: "If we assume that case fatality rate among individuals infected by SARS-CoV-2 is 0.3% in the general population — a mid-range guess from my Diamond Princess analysis — and that 1% of the U.S. population gets infected (about 3.3 million people), this would translate to about 10,000 deaths."
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- fmjrey 7y agoIran's death rate must also be seen in the light of its war with Iraq that started in 1988 and left much of the now 60+ people with poor lungs [0]. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iran%E2%80%93Iraq_War#Iraq's_use_of_chemical_weapons https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iran%E2%80%93Iraq_War#Iraq's_u...
- dang 7y agoA thread on Ioannidis' article from 2 days ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22612591 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22612591
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- rich_sasha 7y agoOne thing that did occur to me: if it is mostly the elderly and vulnerable who get affected, why don't we concentrate the isolation efforts on them, and allow the rest of the society to live semi-normally. It's not that I can't be asked to sit at home. Rather: - There is a huge economical toll from locking up everyone. And it's economies that pay for hospitals - While everything else is shut, what diseases, damage etc. is done elsewhere? How many people will die because their lesser-priority illnesses get forgotten? - Would we not be better placed, as societies, to help vulnerable people, if we remained productive? - Do we get best of both worlds of "herd immunity" and protecting those likely to die? As a healthy young person I'm fully committed to protecting the vulnerable, I just wonder if the above is better than an all-out lockdown. [EDIT: formatting]
- singularity2001 7y agoIt effects middle-age people as well, it’s just that when mortality rate rises from 0.01 (flu) to 0.3% in this specific age group it looks much better than for the elderly with over 10% mortality. 0.3% is still catastrophic and even those who don’t die can have severe long-term effects (see Netherlands cases)
- rich_sasha 7y agoI see, thanks. Makes sense!
- majkinetor 7y agoI suspect that certain pharma drugs given to elder people for cardiovascular and diabetes diseases may be in part responsible for current state. The similar thing was probably partly in effect a century ago with aspirin and Spanish flue.
- orwin 7y agoAnti-inflammatory medication is responsible for some of the death, and NSAID are often taken by people with diabetes (joint pain and stuff like that). Still, uncontrolled glycemy + covid19 will likely put you to ICU, NSAID or not. If you have diabetes and controlled glycemy, (+ you're young and did not consumme NSAID), you're likely to come out OK.
- majkinetor 7y agoYou are puting it mild. Those people are often on bunch of drugs concurently: ACE inhibitors, NSAIDs, anti-inflamatories. Many of those drugs deplete essential nutrients such as Zinc, vitamin C etc. Maybe that is the dominannt reason why older folks have such incidence. I wonder what are the stats for old & healthy (rare thing indeed, but not unheard of).
- swat535 7y agoCan someone with a better knowledge explain to me what's going on here? The number of infection is not relevant, shouldn't the number of severe cases requiring hospitalization be the metric to care about the most? It looks like this number is drastically lower.