7 ms·
Maybe if we had kept using bittorrent for TV distribution we wouldn't have so much global traffic downloading "The Avengers" for the millionth time, you would j
by jazzyjackson 7y ago
Maybe if we had kept using bittorrent for TV distribution we wouldn't have so much global traffic downloading "The Avengers" for the millionth time, you would just download it from the nearest host (also the way the internet worked before HTTPS, there used to be way more local caching of content being downloaded over and over again)
- amelius 7y agoExcept residential upload speeds are usually only 1/10th of the corresponding download speed.
- codyb 7y agoIf you’re downloading ten segments from ten different uploaders it can all balance out I think. Bittorrent can be damn quick. Haven’t used it in a while but it was certainly fast on well seeded items.
- notyourday 7y agoBittorrent would eat all of the available bandwidth if the content is popular enough that there are always new leachers available. With enough bandwidth Bittorrent would be less efficient than a single stream TCP between the source and destination because of the protocol overhead.
- TrickyRick 7y agoDoesn't really matter though, still means (Slightly oversimplified) that a peer can connect to 10 hosts and not have to download at all from the origin server. Also this simply isn't true in a lot of European countries where upload and download speeds are equal, but that's a different thing.
- throwaway744678 7y agoCan you explain what you mean by that last statement? It does not sound true to me. As far as I can tell (in my country) almost all consumer offers are asymmetric: ADSL, obviously, but also fiber. Symmetric offers are very much for professional access, and typically more expensive.
- anon8366383917 7y agoIn Sweden, fiber (which is quite common) is pretty much always symmetric. 100/100 is common, many people have 1000/1000 and there is residential symmetric 10 Gb/s to be had. Asymmetric ADSL and Cable is definitely not uncommon though.
- lxgr 7y agoThe math still does not work out. On an 1:10 asymmetric connection, users would need to remain available for seeding 10 times longer than it takes to download (and presumably watch) the film to have a net positive impact on the system. That's not exactly realistic, considering that a lot of traffic goes to mobile devices where this would outright kill battery life.
- orcasauce 7y agoAnd Smart TVs which lack the computational power/storage/memory to serve traffic.
- Hamuko 7y agoYeah, but my residential conncetion is 1000/100.
- Sosh101 7y agoMaybe 10 years ago? I don't know anyone with a connection that badly asymmetrical.
- JimmyAustin 7y agoMy parents connection in Australia is 100/3.
- LynxInLA 7y agoThat's the standard ratio for Spectrum consumer internet. The ratio actually gets worse as you increase the upload speed. They cap out at 35 Mbps upload even with 940 Mbps download.
- mfkp 7y agoMy Comcast gigabit internet is capped at 35Mbit upload as well.
- rahimnathwani 7y agoIt's pretty common if your last mile technology is old, e.g. cable internet coax, or copper phone lines for ADSL. Most Comcast plans in my area come with 5Mbit/s upload, even if the download speed is 15x to 25x that.
- MartinodF 7y agoMost FTTH connections in Italy are 1000/100 or 1000/300 Mbit/s. I guess most people wouldn't even notice the difference in upload between 100 and 1000 Mbit/s.
- lxgr 7y agoMy connection is 1000/50 – theoretically. On a good day, that works out to about 100/2, thanks to my provider vastly overselling their shitty overcongested network as "fiber to the home". (It's just cable.)
- sgt 7y agoSo you've got a "gigabit connection" (in marketing terms), yet worst case your upload speed is like that of ADSL. That's unacceptable.
- codyb 7y agoWasn’t Netflix originally p2p in some manner? I can’t remember the exact details (and I may be wrong), but I could have sworn their original architecture was distributed in one way or the other.
- cjblomqvist 7y agoYou might be thinking about Spotify, which had a torrent-like technology originally. Nowadays I think it's fairly limited.
- TrickyRick 7y agoAlso Voddler I guess?
- codyb 7y agoThanks that might be right!
- laurencerowe 7y agoNetflix was never p2p, but BBC iPlayer was when it first launched.
- knicholes 7y agoIt sounds like it's time for some popcorn.
- orcasauce 7y agoWould you be so kind to pass some to me? Popcorn that is.
- knicholes 7y agoI would never risk suggesting people use the legal app popcorntime to pirate copyrighted material.
- koheripbal 7y agoWhat is the advantage over good ol' fashion torrenting? I guess I'm just an old timer....
- roel_v 7y agoTorrenting is on the way out, from what I (as a casual torrenter) can tell. There is just a lot less material available. Maybe it's better on private trackers, but I haven't been a member of one in 15 years, nor would I know how to access/be invited to one even if I wanted to.
- Polylactic_acid 7y agoIts on the way out for casual use but its still the primary method for enthusiast use, Its the best and sometimes only place to get flac/bluray quality and the only reliable place for console games.
- tallanvor 7y agoNewsgroups and private indexers are generally the best option these days.
- aidenn0 7y agoAt least in the US, Netflix colocates a box with the most popular content on premises with the ISP, so the last mile could be the bottleneck here.
- ivnubinas 7y agoYes, it's the same here (Dominican Republic).
- orcasauce 7y agoAs I understand it Netflix has hardware in ISP data centers to do exactly that. https://openconnect.netflix.com/en/ https://openconnect.netflix.com/en/
- newsclues 7y agoLarge residential buildings (condo and apartments) need a small edge Data Centre in them.
- pythonaut_16 7y agoThis might be a more realistic compromise. Maybe if the industry can agree on an OpenConnect standard with some traffic shaping. Then Netflix, Hulu, Steam, Xbox, PlayStation, EA, Disney+, etc could all share the same edge CDN hardware. Then residential buildings, cities, individuals, whoever, could run their own caching hardware that would cache based on downstream demand.
- cosmodisk 7y agoThat's quite something when a streaming service can go to the ISP with their hardware...
- spyspy 7y agoThis is common for any company that operates a CDN. It just so happens Netflix is a big enough content deliverer that they run their own network rather than pay to use someone else’s.
- megablast 7y agoPretty common.
- rorykoehler 7y agoI was involved in starting a streaming service in SE Asia and the costs of 3rd party edge caching (Akamai etc) were significant. So much so that it made the business model non-viable without work arounds. Eventually we partnered with ISPs and piggybacked their edge caches.
- tehsauce 7y agoThis is called a CDN, and they are very ubiquitous especially for video streaming services
- jolmg 7y ago> Maybe if we had kept using bittorrent for TV distribution we wouldn't have so much global traffic downloading I don't think bittorrent can compare to the efficiency of traditional TV broadcast, neither cable nor over-the-air. Instead of a packet being for a single destination, it's send once, and everyone just listens in.
- skybrian 7y agoYou could think about the opposite way: it's good that Netflix was using so much bandwidth because it encouraged network upgrades. Now, when we need to use this capacity for something else, Netflix can flip a switch and it's available. Excess usage for luxuries like 4k video in good times is a way of preparing for bad times. Ideally we would treat hospital capacity the same way. In good times, everyone gets a private room.
- fiter 7y agoThis is also a reason to eat meat from animals fed food for people. In the bad times, slaughter the animals and eat the meat and the feed. It's changed my perspective on efficiency. There are some forms of inefficiency that can provide a buffer if something goes wrong.
- beamatronic 7y agoThat last line used to be highly internalized by Americans who lived thru the depression, WW 1 and 2, etc.
- eru 7y agoYes. Though Americans were probably least affected by WW1 and WW2 of most war participants. Go ask some people in Russia for a better example.
- eru 7y agoIt's not necessarily inefficiency. Eg flush toilets are a great time saver. But they use a lot of water. If we had a drought tomorrow, we could switch to compost toilets. They are more hassle to use and maintain, but use basically no water. Which one is more 'efficient' depends on the relative scarcity of water vs time.
- Cthulhu_ 7y agoThe difference being that networks and Netflix servers don't cost a lot of money or take up space when they're idling, and/or they can sell the capacity and switch rapidly when they need it, whereas hospital capacity does. I mean I'm all for having excess hospital capacity (and excess capacity for a lot of things), but at the same time who is going to pay for it? This has been the problem before cloud computing; companies had to set up servers and the like for the worst case peak capacity workload, meaning that usually they'd only be operating at 10-20% of capacity.
- kbumsik 7y agoYou missed Netflix's compression. Netflix delivers contents with a way less data with similar quality.
- xyst 7y agoThe greatest advantage of torrents is also its greatest disadvantage. It’s distributed by nature but it relies on a network of computers (peers) to always be available. And given the asymmetric speed of most consumer grade internet connections, most peers tend to be greedy and disconnect from the mesh after the download finishes. This is where private torrent sites stepped in and encouraged sharing ratios. Of course, most of the “peers” ended up being dedicated servers with symmetric gigabit lines rented from some host in a foreign country. So in the end it, the patterns shifted back to data centers and “dumb terminals”
- rorykoehler 7y agoEdge caching should provide similar benefits no?