4 ms·
It seems to me like the problem is just that supply chains aren’t legible. I forget where I read this from, but Walmart or Amazon would easily pay billions of d
by SpicyLemonZest 7y ago
It seems to me like the problem is just that supply chains aren’t legible. I forget where I read this from, but Walmart or Amazon would easily pay billions of dollars to know which shipments won’t arrive over the next few months because of the rolling wave of factory shutdowns.
Once you have that legibility, the extra step of snipping the globalized supply chains seems unnecessary. Some businesses will plan to maintain continuity with all international shipping stopped, and a few will receive subsidies and mandates to do so. Others won’t, and that’s fine too; there’s a ton of value in making our lives better even in ways that can’t be sustained during a crisis. (It’s worth noting that international shipping in everything but coronavirus-fighting medical equipment hasn’t stopped during the currrent crisis.)
- zozbot234 7y ago> It seems to me like the problem is just that supply chains aren’t legible. There are a number of efforts to make supply chains in all sorts of sectors more transparent using blockchain-like protocols. So this will hopefully improve in the future.
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoAgreed. Applying Merkle trees to supply chain management is a great idea that deserves a catchy name, although it's unfortunate the idea has been so historically intermixed with weird currency plays and ICO scams.
- hef19898 7y agoOver a decade ago, the supply chain hype was RFID chips. Now, more htan ten years laer, they are not used besides your occasional pallet tracking. or for hteft preventin at shops. And RFID would just have replaced bar codes, so no process changes necessary for a first implementation. Blockchain is a different beast. And most companies wouldn't like the full transparency that comes with it. Decentralized ledgers would result in a lot transparency for everyone. And that trust building is a main issue. That, and that the information flow (blockchain) has to be always sychronized with the physical flow (goods).
- mschuster91 7y ago> And RFID would just have replaced bar codes, so no process changes necessary for a first implementation. There would have been changes necessary. RFID chips fall as electronics under RoHS and probably regional/national recycling regulation which means that their introduction into products would cause an enormous overhead. Additionally chips cost at least 10ct each in bulk which means for a lot of 1m units you would lose at least 100k $ in profit (or offer the product for more money, which is ... difficult to do when dealing e.g. with Walmart). The only way RFID could have taken off would have been if governments mandated their usage.
- hef19898 7y agoYeah, especially price is a major obstacle. A barcode costs nothing and does the job.
- giantrobot 7y agoNot only do barcodes do the job but better and cheaper image sensors and processors allow even 1D barcodes to be read at greater distances and from multiple angles. This was one of the promises of RFID, pallets could just stream off a truck and their ID could be read by some fixed reader on the loading dock. A robot could zip past shelves and take stock of everything. Better barcode reading allows a lot of the same advantages for none of the marginal cost or dealing with extra regulation. Even handheld barcode scanners are starting to use cameras rather than lasers because they're more flexible.
- jacques_chester 7y agoBlockchain works for currency problems because the unit of tracking is the unit of value, the entire system is fully self-contained and no oracle is required to pump information into and out of the system. None of these things are true of supply chain problems. All it adds vs bog-ordinary B2B protocols is the ability to waste electricity on a galactic scale, instead of a merely planetary one.
- Mountain_Skies 7y agoAbout a year after 9/11 I worked at the headquarters for one of our largest retailers. The main hallway through the complex that everyone had to pass through was decorated in flags and other patriotic displays wall to wall, floor to ceiling. But we also received constant emails from the company telling us to contact our members of Congress to prevent customs from knowing where we get our goods such as ceiling fans. The worry was that a spy in customs might give that information to our competitors. Seemed weird to have so many visible displays of "Country First" while at the same time placing paranoia about corporate spies in the government above the legitimate need for customs to know where the goods we were receiving were coming from.
- j-c-hewitt 7y agoAmazon has a program for this called Transparency. It has some other purposes but this is one of the features of it. It's not a perfect way to track the chain but it is vaguely like what you propose.
- elliekelly 7y agoCan you elaborate? What are the other purposes?
- j-c-hewitt 7y agoKicking off any sellers for the specific products in the catalog not using Transparency, providing assurances to buyers that the products are authentic. Making money for Amazon because they charge a fee for every unit. https://brandservices.amazon.com/transparency https://brandservices.amazon.com/transparency (Not employed by Amazon, but work with many Amazon sellers, am an Amazon seller)
- stefan_ 7y agoThat's because the supply chain is as immeasurably complex as the real world. Does your model account for the fact that the polish or german government decided to institute border controls and now there is a 40 mi backed up line of trucks delayed? Does it consider the cascading effects of polish truck drivers being unavailable for 14 days of quarantine if they cross into Poland for non-work reasons?