4 ms·
This seems like a positive trend. The article quotes a guy saying Twitter is two days ahead of newspapers, but that's severely underselling it; many Twitter sou
by SpicyLemonZest 7y ago
This seems like a positive trend. The article quotes a guy saying Twitter is two days ahead of newspapers, but that's severely underselling it; many Twitter sources were saying "watch out, this isn't likely to be localized" in late January and "this will be a problem everywhere, start preparing for a lockdown" in mid-February. If it's possible for people to be a month ahead of the mainstream media, that's not a matter of higher verification standards - there's gotta be some structural obstacle in place that systematically prevents the media from noticing important new things. And if that's true I'm glad to have alternative sources without the obstacle.
- creato 7y agoMany Twitter sources were also saying that it's nothing or a hoax or whatever right up until a week or two ago (and probably some still are).
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoCertainly, and I get your point, but none of them were sources I would have considered reliable in the first place. There's always a selection problem, just as listening to reliable traditional media requires you to screen out conspiracy outlets who pretend to be legitimate newspapers.
- pault 7y agoYour and GP's comments are a perfect illustration of the social media bubble effect. Some people saw an entire news feed telling them it was nothing to worry about, and another group saw a news feed saying it was going to be a global pandemic. It's easy to point the finger after the fact, but you have to understand that people will believe what they perceive as being "common knowledge", and in this day and age that means whatever their twitter and facebook friends say for the majority of people.
- yibg 7y agoSeems like hindsight bias at play. Would be interesting to see the overall sentiment of tweets about this in Jan.
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoI agree. It's my intuition that there was a distinct cluster of people who were both credible and correct, but I could be wrong.
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoThere may be some bias in your view. Yes, people were saying these things early on Twitter. But I'm pretty sure people were also saying "it doesn't need a lockdown, it's no big deal" as late as today on Twitter. So... Twitter is ahead of the newspapers. And it's totally behind the data, with its head in the sand. And everywhere in between. Twitter doesn't give you an answer; it gives you 10,000 answers. Sure, the truth is in there... somewhere. Good luck finding it reliably, though.
- qznc 7y agoI believe it is mostly hindsight. For any outcome you will find someone who predicted it a month ago on Twitter. It does not help you to determine which of the thousand current predictions will be correct.
- briandear 7y agoTwitter also promotes a bunch of stupid and wrong information as well. There is always some “watch out” tweets concerning pretty much anything that happens. Twitter is noisy and unreliable. It’s basically gossip, some that happens to be true, much that happens to be false.
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 7y agoPeople on social media predict every possible outcome. Of course some will be right. It's not a question of how far ahead they are. It's about being better than that octopus that happened to get the world cup bracket correct. Or at least not telling everyone to get public health information from octopi.
- asdfman123 7y agoIt's positive for everyone who is smart enough to filter and interpret sources correctly, but is negative for everyone who isn't. Remember, for every guy like you there's someone following QAnon and believing in that schizophrenic nonsense.