8 ms·
> Taking on debt to finance buybacks, however, is bad management, given that no revenue-generating investments are made that can allow the company to pay off th
by crazygringo 7y ago
> Taking on debt to finance buybacks, however, is bad management, given that no revenue-generating investments are made that can allow the company to pay off the debt.
This seems to be the crux of the article, and it appears to be completely unsubstantiated.
First of all, this article isn't about just stock buybacks -- the argument of the article applies broadly to dividends just as much, save for minor details.
The point the article is making is that profits ought to be reinvested rather than paid out. But obviously mature firms often can't find ways to reliably re-invest. They don't need to grow any further, nor should they. So investors want them not to re-invest, and throw off dividends or buybacks instead. This way investors can fund the next generation of companies.
And taking on debt to do it isn't inherently irresponsible. In fact, it's just a wise financial decision when interest rates are low. New revenue streams aren't required to be generated -- it's just shifting a subset of future revenue to the present.
So I really don't get this article at all.
- dlp211 7y agoAmerican airliners returned 96% of their profit as share buybacks and are now requesting a $50 billion bailout and you still want to defend borrowing money to finance buybacks, which were illegal until sometime in the 1980's. With this kind of mindset, I'm about to say fuck it, let's not bail these companies out. Let's let capitalism take its natural course.
- jsanford9292 7y agoI am sorry to say that I agree and, to be effective, capitalism needs to work much like natural selection. Weak companies (such as the airlines during the COVID-19 outbreak) need to be allowed to die. If we rescue these poorly managed companies, they will continue to be poorly managed and will need to be rescued again. If they die, they will be replaced by new, better managed companies who won't make the same mistake (because nobody will want to own their stock otherwise). This virus will likely turn out to be a 2-3 quarter demand shock, something that any well-managed company should be prepared to survive.
- TheSpiceIsLife 7y ago> If they die, they will be replaced by new, better managed companies who won't make the same mistake (because nobody will want to own their stock otherwise). Is there much evidence to support this? I'm not saying I've studied the data, but just thinking about what has happened over time it seems reasonable to suspect there are companies that have gone bust, only to be replaced by new companies that then also go bust. This is true of natural selection too: it doesn't necessarily produce organisms that are immune to unexpected shocks. Edit: I also want to add: if the airline hadn't done the share buy back, wouldn't it still be suffering from the unexpected economic shock?
- mywittyname 7y agoAnymore, corporate "death" means that stock & bond holders lose their wealth. Depending on the type of bankruptcy, the assets get purchased for pennies on the dollar by a large firm, or the existing debt is restructured. So yeah, a "stronger" company will emerge from the ashes. But only because other people took a bath. It's like if the bank forecloses on your house. You owe $200k, but they sell it at auction for $50k. The above argument is like saying the new owners who bought your house will be a much stronger financial situation. This is true, but it ignores the fact that majority of involved parties are worse off (you & the bank).
- tracker1 7y agoAnd that bath isn't necessarily a bad thing... poorly managed companies should be allowed to fail... and investors should hold more responsibility in holding management accountable for their actions without always handing out golden parachutes so to speak.
- sixQuarks 7y agoThe reason is the new company knows they will not be bailed out if they encounter a similar situation in the future, thus the expectation is they would be more careful in managing cashflow and saving for a rainy day.
- llcoolv 7y agoWell. The debt that financed the buy backs was created by a central planning authority with a massive control over the economy, so let's don't call centrally-planned collectivist policies capitalism, because they have nothing to do with it. Also, the pressure for the buybacks comes from institutional investors and centralised authorities. Btw this sort of state-run "capitalism" isn't really socialism either, to me it is more reminescent of the 1930s in Southern Europe.
- JMTQp8lwXL 7y agoThe damage from airlines going under (to other sectors of the economy) is greater than bailouts. It would set off a chain reaction, the airline industry supports hotels (all the pilots and flight attendants stay at hotels) and tourism.
- rednerrus 7y agoThen the airlines should have to borrow the money. We can not afford to have industries that are too big to fail that are not nationalized.
- JMTQp8lwXL 7y agoWhen banks were bailed out, they paid back every penny. Holding the airline industry to the same standard would be equitable.
- lovich 7y agoDid they payback every real penny or nominal penny? The paybacks weren't instantaneous and iirc they were given low interest loans.
- spaced-out 7y agoThis is not mentioned enough. I see people often state that the government made money on the TARP bailout, without taking into account inflation. As this Wikipedia article points out, with multiple citations, the government made a 0.6% annualized return on TARP, at a time when inflation was ~1.5%. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Troubled_Asset_Relief_Program#Timeline_of_changes_to_the_TARP_program https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Troubled_Asset_Relief_Program#...
- philwelch 7y agoI would suspect that the entire world economy not collapsing even further than it did would make up for that last 0.9%.
- jsanford9292 7y agoI'm really glad this comment exists. Just because this article is written by 3 PhDs and posted by HBR doesn't mean it isn't complete nonsense. The comment by Michael O'Hare in the comments section of the HBR article is also a good explanation of the complete misunderstanding of market fundamentals by the authors.
- charliemil4 7y agoConflating buy backs with dividends is hazardous reasoning. Dividends are direct payments to investors who will presumably stay investors — the buy back is a ‘buy out’ of existing shareholders. There are quite a few more reasons a buy back is different from a dividend - but probably the most interesting bit is this: for a massive company with limited places to compound their retained earnings, by buying back stock the company pays all the dividends it would pay in perpetuity immediately in that instant. This is all fine and sometimes prudent in a net present value equation.... as long as the cash flows remain consistent* *which is now the issue at hand with Covid-19
- crazygringo 7y ago> Dividends are direct payments to investors who will presumably stay investors — the buy back is a ‘buy out’ of existing shareholders. I don't think that's true at all. Every day there's massive liquidity -- buying and selling -- of any publicly traded stock. Buybacks are generally implemented gradually over time, to the best of my knowledge, and are simply buying the shares people are selling daily regardless, the existing liquidity. Obviously because there's slightly more demand, the price creeps slightly higher, and a margin of people decide to sell (e.g. for $201) where they wouldn't have sold slightly lower (e.g. for $199). But obviously those people were generally looking to sell in the first place. So the idea that buybacks somehow discourage or reduce investing or discourage long-term investment seems totally mistaken.
- charliemil4 7y agoThe shares purchased in a buy back go on the corporation’s balance sheet (sometimes to be retired) - it’s a way to control float along with other things. This is the crux of the issue - you are increasing a liability (debt) to shift another liability (shareholder equity to tStock) — this in theory is meant to increase the earnings per share by reducing the share count and lower your overall weighted cost of capital. (Debt is most always cheaper than equity in terms of a cost of capital) If this is a truly capitalistic society - what should really happen is that all the bought back stock needs to be reissued (sold back) into the market — but that would create excess supply, reduce price, then freak out everyone’s 401k. Finance is a crazy web and really cool - but massively complex. So you are right that there is liquidity every day, but that liquidity does not affect the total number of publicly traded shares until the purchaser is the corporation itself (the buy back). The real screwed up compounding variable in liquidity is who is actually buying (awesome when it’s actual primary investment aka private fundings and ipos, and messy when it’s the secondary market aka the ticker price) — guess what’s even more messy: Passive Funds like ETFs. Passives (where 401ks live) are now the primary vehicle of investment for average America so really no individual investor is actually buying an individual stock- instead you buy a ‘share’ in a prorated basket of stocks based on ratios set in investor agreements (vanguard ishares etc). When money goes into the ETF, the fund buys 10% x, 10% y... so on of the basket of stocks they market. No earnings have changed, no cash flows, but external secondary market forces now drive the market. This is what Michael Barry (of the Big Short) is waiting for next - along with Water, which will be the next decades issue.
- autokad 7y agoalso a large part of stock buy backs are used towards employee comp.
- johannes1234321 7y agoCouldn't that be done by raising salaries?
- the_jeremy 7y agoOP doesn't mean that the buybanks raise employee salaries because the stock they receive now has a higher price, they mean that the stocks the company is buying back are then given to the employees as RSUs.
- gbasin 7y agoI used to also agree that all the arguments against buybacks apply to dividends, but I've since changed my mind. On the surface level, they are identical → cash is transferred from company to shareholders. But the way the cash is transferred matters, and it has second order effects. Specifically, as it impacts stock options. Executives tend to be compensated with options. The more the stock goes up, the richer they get. Distributing $X in dividends should provide an equal total return to the average shareholder as spending $X on a buyback, but that buyback will do it by pushing up the share price. As the share price goes up more and more, execs with options have disproportionately more to gain than the average shareholder. They have a leveraged exposure to the price!
- throw0101a 7y ago> Specifically, as it impacts stock options. Then any regulations should focus on them. Why should I, as a 'retail investor', be punished for return on capital methods because of the chicanery of executives? I'm just going to DRIP any dividends anyway (until retirement) since I don't need income now. I want buybacks because that way I do not have a tax event that has (tax) drag on returns.
- fountainofage 7y agoCould you help me in understanding this? In my head if dividends are paid out, wouldn't this drive the stock price up the same as if a buyback happened? Or is this some sort of market inefficiency / irrationality where the market is rewarding stock purchase volume rather than just looking at the total expected value of the company? Edit: sorry about that, I get it now after thinking through it more. Let's say the stock is truly worth $100 (assuming we could figure that out). Then if the company does buybacks, the stock trades at $100 - great for the executive with stock options. However, if the company pays dividends, then the stock price is reduced by the expected value of those dividends. So total expected value is the same, and long term executive comp is the same because they get the dividends as well, but short term they would prefer the buyback because of the higher stock price. They only benefit the same from dividends if they have a long term view.
- 7y ago
- mgh2 7y agoMaybe this video will help https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ylLTMYt24lA&feature=youtu.be https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ylLTMYt24lA&feature=youtu.be
- lumost 7y agoTaking on debt is an unusual way to return money to investors. Taken to its extreme there are two mechanisms to unwind a business by returning money to investors. 1. Steadily pay out dividends or buy-back stock based on profits. Buy-backs benefit those who hold onto an unwinding venture longest, whereas dividends provide an even return. Eventually when the company has nothing left to sell the business shuts down. 2. monetize the companies balance sheet and distribute money to the investors - Mortgage the assets and borrow against future earnings. The goal in this approach is to steadily transition from low-risk to high-risk debt and eventually bankrupt the company. Naively one would expect such an approach to yield ~5x the value of an otherwise mature business, and leave creditors on the hook. The latter approach needn't be malicious either, simply leveraging a mature business until it can only support interest payments would be viable - bankruptcy would occur when the company runs into trouble and has no assets to invest. The latter path needs to be regulated to have a healthy and stress resistant economy.
- crazygringo 7y ago> Taking on debt is an unusual way to return money to investors. Not if interest rates are low. Suppose interest is 1% and a company takes out a 5-year loan. They pay ~$1.05 to distribute $1 per share now instead of waiting 5 years to distribute it. I, as an investor, can take that distributed $1 and reinvest it at, say, an expected rate of return of 5% -- so that in 5 years I'll have ~$1.28. Obviously that's a much better total deal in the end. I, as an investor, want the company to take on reasonable low-interest debt for dividends or buybacks. Which is exactly why companies are doing this. This is the middle ground between your options #1 and #2, which is financially wise for companies who expect to continue to have healthy profits. Which is exactly why companies are doing it.
- lumost 7y agoWhy wouldn't you as an investor, borrow against your equity holding at a low interest rate? Using the companies balance sheet seems like a mechanism to avoid liability/long-term obligations on the loan rather than producing a net economic benefit.
- 7y ago
- MuffinFlavored 7y ago> This way investors can fund the next generation of companies. This is where I get confused. Say APPL was $100 share, and so many people buy it that it goes up to $200/share. How does this really benefit APPL? They don't ever issue more shares from what I can tell (they don't need to raise capital). Why does the share price of APPL/AMZN/TSLA matter to them? To attract investors/keep a board of directors happy, sure But what do they financially gain by their market cap going up?
- the_watcher 7y agoIt is beneficial to the owners of $AAPL, their shareholders, whose wealth doubled simply via buybacks. Relatedly, it increases the value of unvested stock held by employees, helping with retention and recruitment.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jldugger 7y agoLike most of the bay area, they do issue shares to employees. If you stop thinking of companies as a monolith but rather a diverse set of agents (and owners) then I think you'll realize nothing can ever benefit AAPL, only it's shareholders, directors, managers and employees.
- the_watcher 7y agoI had the same response. I'm sympathetic to the idea that there might be wrong with the increase in buybacks in recent years, although that's more of a sense that any massive change in behavior should have extremely well-understood consequences. This article didn't convince me that _all_ buybacks are bad.
- aalleavitch 7y ago> And taking on debt to do it isn't inherently irresponsible. In fact, it's just a wise financial decision when interest rates are low. New revenue streams aren't required to be generated -- it's just shifting a subset of future revenue to the present. I don't know how someone could possibly make this statement RIGHT NOW of all times? How many businesses are sitting on the edge of folding right now? Whoops! Looks like all that future revenue didn't show up! Guess who's going to suffer for these decisions? Not the investors, they sold out! How about all the employees who just had all the blood sucked out of their job security and future livelihood? In what sense are investors in this scenario not just hostile parasites? At least if it were dividends then the investors would have any sort of remaining long-term interest in the success of the company, and not just how they can most quickly disentangle themselves from taking any responsibility for the survival of the company that they ostensibly had ownership over by gulping down revenue it didn't even generate yet? In what sense is the investor not crippling the company and leaving it weaker than they found it? It's vampirism! Just because the money is there for the taking doesn't mean you should, it doesn't mean that what you're doing isn't irresponsible and even morally reprehensible. You create a nightmarescape of shambling zombie companies just waiting for a global pandemic to remind them that they're all already dead. Enjoy your artificially juiced stock value after it craters because our entire economy is short of legs to stand on.
- heartbeats 7y agoWell, this was a one in a million thing. Nobody could have predicted the world to just shut down for six months, and it's not productive to plan for it. It's far more reasonable to do business as usual and then take loans if things go south. As Matt Levine put it: the dividends they gave since the GFC come to $15 billion, and their equity comes to $12 billion. So it's not even given it would have been the appropriate thing. > How about all the employees who just had all the blood sucked out of their job security and future livelihood? Right. It's like banks. How do we handle it? Insurance: if you want to be a FDIC-insured bank, you must pay the FDIC insurance, and in return they will backstop your creditors up to a certain limit if they go bankrupt. Why couldn't we do the same for employees? If you're an employer of systemic importance, you must have employee bankruptcy insurance: if you go tits-up, your employees get their salary paid up to a maximum limit of $X/yr until they find a new job. The insurance premiums are set by the free market, purely capitalist.
- totalZero 7y agoBuybacks drive the share price up, and manipulate the stock by impacting it disproportionately to the amount of float reduction. Dividends pull the share price down, and allow the recipient to choose whether to reinvest or take cash. If the goal were simply to return capital or concentrate ownership, dividends would be more than sufficient. Buybacks have a different goal. Their goal is to inflate the stock, provide liquidity on selloff days, and take cash off the firm's balance sheet in a way that improves metrics used in fundamental analysis that compare the company's value to its earnings. Some companies compensate executives based on share price appreciation. In that environment, a share repurchase has tangible benefits for the executives who choose to do it.
- philwelch 7y agoThe debt-to-finance-stock-buybacks can also be motivated by differences in corporate tax rate. For instance, Apple made this move some years ago, borrowing money in the US (despite having money outside the US) to finance stock buybacks. Repatriating the money and paying taxes would have been more expensive than the interest on the debt. A lot of these monkeyshines were stopped by the recent tax reform, which brought US corporate tax rates down to levels comparable with most of Europe.