5 ms·
One thing that I hope will come out of this coronavirus event, even if just for a short while, is that people no longer at large accept that this anti-social be
by hn_throwaway_99 7y ago
One thing that I hope will come out of this coronavirus event, even if just for a short while, is that people no longer at large accept that this anti-social behavior is just "doing business".
And I realize the article was updated to give a "royalty free license", which is complete and total bullshit because BioFire shouldn't need a license for Theranos' bullshit patents that never worked anyway.
We need to start naming and shaming for this kind of trolling, anti-social behavior. And not just the company name, I'm talking about the principals and lawyers who filed this, who are nothing but a net-negative to society.
- bcheung 7y agoI think there is a lot to be said about social trust and reputation when it comes to brands/companies/individuals. We are seeing that it actually does work and that companies respond when they are called out on bad behavior. Maybe not always, but enough to make a difference. This makes me believe that society has more control than it thinks and that we don't need as much heavy handed government controls that can have unintended consequences and strip us of our freedoms.
- fnord123 7y agoI am not a lawyer, but I wonder if laws against hoarding physical goods like hand sanitizer during an emergency also apply to so called intellectual property.
- pmiller2 7y agoDoes it? I don’t know. Should it? In the case of a global pandemic, it should, IMO. That includes making any vaccines or treatments widely available at or near cost, possibly with government subsidies. Things change when tens or hundreds of millions of lives are on the line. Edit: I don’t know exactly where the line of IP as a public good lies, but with this many lives at stake, we’re certainly well into that kind of territory.
- pooper 7y ago> Does it? I don’t know. Should it? In the case of a global pandemic, it should not, IMO. That includes making any vaccines or treatments widely available at or near cost, possibly with government subsidies. Things change when tens or hundreds of millions of lives are on the line. >> Does it? I don’t know. Should it? In the case of a global pandemic, it should not, IMO. Did you include a not when you meant to not include it?
- pmiller2 7y agoOoh, yes. Thank you.
- Hokusai 7y ago> Things change when tens or hundreds of millions of lives are on the line. Is it Ok when it’s just tens of thousands, thousands, hundreds? At which number it becomes acceptable to abuse patents to sell overpriced medicines for the sick? The system needs improvements. The pandemic is temporal. The injustice have been there for many years.
- pmiller2 7y agoI’m purposely not drawing an exact line. Nonetheless, when potentially hundreds of millions of lives are at stake globally, it’s safe to say we’ve crossed over into IP as a public good land.
- gruez 7y agoDo you really want to set a precedent that (intellectual) property rights are suspended in times of crisis? Maybe I have a great idea for curing coronavirus infections, but now I don't want to pour money into to r&d for it because I know that the government won't uphold my patents next time a coronavirus epidemic rolls around.
- cranky_coder 7y agoYes, I do. It’s a global pandemic - if you’re thinking about profit motive at a time like this you are part of the problem. Full stop.
- frostwhale 7y agoCouldn't have said it better. "Why would i develop something that could save millions of lives if it will save millions of lives and might not make me money". Absurd
- imchillyb 7y agoI wish people like you understood economy. Your proposal is completely unimplementable. The only incentive for innovation on this planet is monetary. That's it. No monies, no solutions. _____ If you stopped to think logically about the situation, you'd see this to be true. If you're proposing robbing peter to pay paul, you're part of the problem. Full Stop!
- mattkrause 7y agoYou may want to read about the polio vaccine.
- wiredfool 7y agoAnd Insulin
- SketchySeaBeast 7y ago
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- redm 7y ago"BioFire shouldn't need a license for Theranos' bullshit patents that never worked anyway" There seems to be a lot of hate for the patent system. The idea of protecting investment in innovation and allowing for public disclosure through a patent is a good thing. Patent Trolls and, sometimes, corporations weaponize these by twisting the language or intent of the patent, but that doesn't mean all patents are BS, even if a company flounders. The patent office also grants its fair share of questionable patents. Theranos raised more than US$700 million in funding. That's a lot of money and research, regardless of the execution or product failures. My honest questions are, have you looked at the patents in the lawsuit? Are they really "bullshit," or did Theranos innovate in a way that BioFire is now using?
- neaden 7y agoI can assure you, Theranos made no meaningful innovation in anything besides fraud. All of their researchers were either being fed bullshit data, so their conclusions are worthless, or were generating bullshit data, in which case they were a scam.
- Haga 7y agoHolding patents should get exponentially more expensive..
- zentiggr 7y ago> The patent office also grants its fair share of questionable patents. I truly wonder how many patents issued in the past twenty-thirty years, would stand up to _any_ amount of actual scrutiny. I'd say there's a LOT of justified hate for the way the USPTO is operating.
- Silhouette 7y agoAs someone who was involved with the patent process for a "legitimate" invention -- meaning one that really was useful and did take considerable thought, time and money to design -- I was somehow both happy and disappointed with the patent lawyer's initial reaction. He said it was a pleasant change to be writing up something where there it a technical person supplying the information and the disclosure really was a genuine advance in the state of the art that might later benefit others. I think there was a recognition and perhaps even a little professional pride there that this was how things were always supposed to work. He also said that a lot of the time they just get handed some sort of vague write-up with little if any help to understand it nor much access to any technical expert involved in creating it. They have to turn it into the right format to describe something and try and extract the key words or phrases that look interesting in order to build up the hierarchy of claims, but there's little real understanding there and the results probably reflect that. Most saddening of all, he said that often works anyway, because ultimately a patent enforcement action is going to take place in a court, and it's likely to be a non-expert jury you have to convince of your case. Rather like a complex fraud trial, the issues involved may well be beyond the understanding of some of those jurors, and so to a regrettable degree. What wins cases can be who had the prettiest illustrations or had managed to coin the most intuitively relevant but still distinctive terminology.
- appleshore 7y agoThere are super smart people I respect but they accept bad behavior as a form of pragmatism. Like they’ll excuse patent trolls because they’re just working a legal angle and trying to make money like everyone else. This idea that unethical things are just a consequence of circumstance and survival is flawed. We shouldn’t excuse those aggressively working to increase the surveillance state or corporate profits just because that’s their job —- we can be better than that.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- rubyn00bie 7y ago> There are super smart people I respect but they accept bad behavior as a form of pragmatism. Like they’ll excuse patent trolls because they’re just working a legal angle and trying to make money like everyone else. They are not smart. Just stop telling yourself this about those people and stop respecting them. Stop it. They're unbelievably ignorant and likely hide that ignorance under the guise of expertise in an unrelated field literally filling your life and others with bullshit. Stop calling fuckos like the ones at Labrador "smart." Stop calling anyone who thinks they're smart "smart." Call them "fuckos," because that's what they are...
- vikramkr 7y agoYeah - I wouldn't have said it so strongly but I fundamentally agree that we shouldn't excuse beliefs based on perceptions of people's intelligence. If their claim is incorrect the claim is what stands on it's own, it doesn't matter who said it. The reason that experience and intelligence matter is because they allow people putting forward those claims to make stronger arguments or know what arguments to make/experiments to run to validate the claim. Intelligence and experience can hell you make better claims, but claims shouldn't be given any more weight or validity because they come from someone with experience or a high score in some (probably somewhat arbitrary and highly subjective) score of experience - that's the core principle of meritocracy in my opinion.
- isoskeles 7y ago
- madez 7y ago"I'm just doing my job!" The deflection of personal responsibility for damaging behaviour as part of a job is a cultural problem.
- belenos46 7y agoHeh. "I'm just doing my job" worked great as a defense at the Hague.
- lm28469 7y ago> We need to start naming and shaming for this kind of trolling, anti-social behavior. We need regulations. As I wrote before, a company is an entity having the sole purpose of making as much money as legally possible. Loose regulations = abuse, it's as simple as that. If you tell your kid it's ok to hit people on the head with a stick you can't blame the neighbour kid when he hits you on the head with a stick.